scribe

Chapter 7

Corisande Told Her Version of the Story, and the Truth Became More Complicated Without Becoming Less Clear

Corisande did not return to the mansion.

She moved into a suite at the Fairmont twenty minutes away and communicated only through her attorney for three days. Then, on Monday morning, Dana Cross called Theron.

"We spoke with your wife."

Theron stood at the kitchen window, watching Eirlys stack blueberries into a crooked tower beside her cereal bowl.

"What did she say?"

"I can't disclose the full substance of another party's interview. I can tell you she acknowledged striking Eirlys once."

Theron's jaw tightened.

"Acknowledged?"

"Her account differs from yours in other respects."

"How?"

Dana paused.

"She describes a prolonged pattern of difficult behavior from Eirlys and says she felt unsupported by you. She says the child intentionally provoked her, damaged belongings, and repeatedly ignored instructions."

Theron looked at his daughter.

Eirlys had decided the blueberry tower needed a roof made from cereal flakes.

"She's three."

"I know."

"Did Corisande say she hit her before?"

"I can't answer that yet."

He gripped the counter.

"Did she explain the pantry?"

"Again, I can't discuss details from her interview."

Theron closed his eyes.

"Then why call?"

"Because she made a claim about you that affects the safety assessment."

He turned away from Eirlys.

"What claim?"

"She says you have an explosive temper. She says you have punched walls during arguments."

Theron went still.

"I punched one wall."

"When?"

"Two years ago. Before we were married. We were arguing in the garage. I hit the wall once. Eirlys wasn't there."

"Any other incidents?"

"No."

"Did you disclose that during our interview?"

"You asked whether I had used physical force against Corisande or in Eirlys's presence. You didn't ask about walls. I should have told you anyway."

Dana was quiet.

"I appreciate the clarification."

"Does this change the safety plan?"

"Not immediately. But we will document it."

Theron stared through the window at the pool.

A maintenance cover now stretched across the water.

"Dana, I'm not going to pretend I'm a calm man who made one inexplicable mistake. I get angry. I have spent years thinking that because I don't hit people, my anger is harmless. The pool proved it isn't."

"Have you considered counseling for yourself?"

"I have an appointment Thursday."

"Good."

After the call, Theron returned to the table.

Eirlys lifted both hands proudly.

"Castle!"

The blueberry tower had collapsed into her cereal.

"Beautiful castle."

She laughed.

The sound made him ache.

That afternoon, Lenora sent him a copy of Corisande's petition for a temporary protective order.

The filing described Theron as physically intimidating, controlling, and dangerous. It included the pool kick, the garage wall incident, and two arguments in which Theron had allegedly blocked a doorway while demanding she finish a conversation.

Theron called Lenora immediately.

"I never trapped her."

"Did you stand in doorways during arguments?"

He thought back.

"Maybe. I wasn't stopping her from leaving. I was trying to keep her from walking away while I was talking."

"That's how you experienced it. She may have experienced it differently."

Theron paced the study.

"So I'm supposed to agree with everything she says?"

"No. You're supposed to be precise. Precision is not surrender."

Lenora's voice sharpened.

"And before you get angry at her for describing your behavior in the worst possible light, remember that you are doing the same thing when you describe hers. Some of your descriptions are justified by evidence. Some of hers may be too."

Theron stopped pacing.

"She slapped a three-year-old."

"Yes. And you kicked her while holding that three-year-old. Those facts do not cancel each other."

He stared at the wall.

"I hate that everyone keeps saying that."

"Because you want one person to be wrong enough that the other person doesn't have to examine himself. Family court is not built for that fantasy."

Theron ended the call twenty minutes later feeling angry, ashamed, and unexpectedly grateful.

That evening, after Eirlys was asleep, he opened the garage door and looked at the repaired section of drywall Corisande had mentioned.

He could still remember the argument.

Corisande had accused him of prioritizing work over their relationship. He had accused her of creating emergencies to force his attention. She had turned away. He had struck the wall.

At the time, he had been proud of himself for not shouting in her face.

Now he wondered what she had seen.

A large man.

A closed garage.

A fist hitting plaster.

He did not have to agree with everything Corisande claimed to recognize that intimidation could exist without intention.

Upstairs, a floorboard creaked.

Theron turned.

Eirlys stood in the hallway wearing pink pajamas, rabbit tucked under her arm.

"I can't sleep."

He crouched.

"Bad dream?"

She nodded.

"About the pool?"

Another nod.

He opened his arms but waited.

Eirlys came to him.

"Mommy fell two times."

"Yes."

"I did one. You did one."

Theron closed his eyes briefly.

"Yes."

"Are we both bad?"

He held her a little closer.

"No. But we both made unsafe choices."

"Mommy made one too."

"She did."

Eirlys was quiet.

Then she whispered, "Three bad choices."

Theron looked at her.

The simplicity of it stunned him.

Three bad choices.

A slap.

A trip.

A kick.

Not three bad people.

Not a hero and a villain.

Choices.

Consequences.

A child trying to understand how love survived both.

Theron carried her back to bed and sat beside her until she slept.

May you like

For the first time, he wondered whether the hardest part of protecting Eirlys would be teaching her that people could do harmful things without becoming monsters.

And whether he could learn the same lesson himself.

Related Stories

Other posts