Chapter 6

The Questions at the Dining Table Were Gentle, but Theron Knew Every Answer Could Change His Daughter's Life
Dana Cross chose the dining table instead of the study.
"Less formal," she said.
Theron understood the reason. The study looked like a room where a man negotiated outcomes. The dining room looked like a place where a family was supposed to tell the truth.
Dana's colleague, Miles Avery, set a folder on the table but did not open it immediately.
"Where is Eirlys now?" Dana asked.
"With my sister, Seraphine."
"Does your sister know why we're here?"
"She knows Corisande struck Eirlys and that I reacted physically toward Corisande. She has not seen the video."
Dana glanced up.
"You have video?"
"Exterior security footage. My attorney preserved it."
"We will request a copy."
"I'll authorize it."
Miles finally opened the folder.
"Mr. Viremont, before we get into details, I want to be clear that our purpose is child safety. We're not here to decide criminal liability."
"Understood."
"Tell us what happened from the beginning."
Theron did.
He did not dramatize Corisande's slap. He did not minimize his own kick. He described Eirlys extending her foot. He repeated the words his daughter had used. He explained the trip to urgent care, the doctor's examination, and the things Eirlys had said about the pantry and the mudroom bench.
Dana took notes.
"Has Corisande ever used physical discipline in your presence?"
"No."
"Has Eirlys ever appeared afraid of her before this week?"
Theron hesitated.
"Not in a way I recognized as fear."
"What did you think it was?"
"Shyness. Clinginess. A phase."
He hated each word as he said it.
Dana did not reassure him.
"How much time does Eirlys spend alone with Corisande?"
"Most weekdays after preschool, several hours. I often get home around six-thirty."
"Who handles bedtime?"
"Usually me. Sometimes Corisande."
"Meals?"
"Corisande or our cook."
"Bathing?"
"Usually Corisande if I'm late."
Theron saw the pattern forming in Dana's notes: access, opportunity, routine.
"When did you marry?" Miles asked.
"Eleven months ago."
"How long had you known Corisande before that?"
"About a year."
Dana looked at him.
"And Eirlys's biological mother?"
Theron's eyes moved to the windows.
"Elowen died when Eirlys was seven months old. A ruptured cerebral aneurysm. Sudden."
The room quieted.
"I'm sorry," Dana said.
Theron nodded once.
"After that, I had help from my sister and a nanny. When Corisande and I became serious, she wanted to take on more of the parenting herself. I thought it meant she loved Eirlys."
"Did staff change after the marriage?"
Theron frowned.
"Yes."
"How?"
"The nanny left. Corisande said we didn't need someone in the house all day. Our housekeeper reduced her schedule."
Dana and Miles exchanged a glance.
Theron noticed it.
"What?"
"Nothing yet," Dana said. "It's something we document."
"I should have noticed."
"Mr. Viremont, this interview isn't about assigning you emotions. It's about information."
Theron almost laughed at the precision of that sentence.
He had spent three days drowning in emotions. Information felt almost merciful.
"What happens now?"
Dana folded her hands.
"We need to see Eirlys, preferably in a child-appropriate setting. We need to speak with Corisande. We'll review medical documentation and the video. We may contact preschool staff and other adults who regularly see Eirlys."
"Will she be removed from my home?"
The question came out more abruptly than he intended.
Dana did not pretend she had not expected it.
"Based on what you've told us today, and assuming Corisande is not residing here with unrestricted access, we do not currently see a need for emergency placement."
Theron breathed out slowly.
"But," Dana continued, "we need a written safety plan."
"Anything."
"Corisande does not have unsupervised contact with Eirlys. You will not engage in physical confrontation with Corisande or anyone else in Eirlys's presence. If Corisande comes to the home unexpectedly, you do not argue at the door. You call law enforcement if necessary."
"Agreed."
"We also recommend that you temporarily remove or change any access Corisande has to the house while your attorneys address property and marital rights."
"I'll handle that through counsel."
Miles leaned forward.
"There is one more thing."
Theron waited.
"Eirlys may be confused about what happened. At her age, she may think she caused everything because she tripped Corisande."
Theron looked down.
"She already asked if she was bad."
"Then be careful not to turn her into the witness who has to fix the family. She is not responsible for proving what happened."
The sentence struck Theron harder than he expected.
He had spent three days collecting evidence, dates, memories, and footage.
Eirlys had spent those same days trying to figure out whether adults still loved her.
"I understand."
Dana closed her notebook.
"Do you?"
Theron met her eyes.
"I think I'm starting to."
After they left, he called Seraphine.
"Can you bring her home?"
"Of course. How did it go?"
"They aren't removing her."
Seraphine went silent.
"You thought they might?"
"Lenora warned me."
"Theron..."
"I kicked Corisande while holding Eirlys. They had every reason to ask whether I can control myself."
His sister's voice softened.
"And can you?"
The old Theron would have been offended.
The new one was too tired for pride.
"I have to."
"That's not what I asked."
He sat at the table where Dana's empty water glass still stood.
"I don't know yet," he admitted. "But I'm going to learn."
When Eirlys came home, she ran into the dining room and found him still there.
"Daddy!"
He opened his arms.
She stopped three feet away.
That pause frightened him.
"Can I hug you?" he asked.
Eirlys nodded and ran the rest of the way.
Theron held her gently.
Over her shoulder, Seraphine watched him.
No one said anything.
But Theron understood the new rule of his life.
May you like
Love could no longer be measured by how fiercely he felt it.
It would be measured by whether Eirlys felt safe receiving it.