scribe

Chapter 10

At the First Court Hearing, Theron Discovered That Protecting Eirlys Meant Letting Strangers Examine the Man He Had Been

The courthouse had none of the drama Theron expected.

No marble staircase crowded with reporters. No shouting attorneys. No cinematic confrontation in a corridor.

There were fluorescent lights, security trays, vending machines, and people staring at their phones while waiting for their lives to be rearranged by a judge.

Lenora met Theron outside the courtroom.

"Do not speak to Corisande unless I tell you to," she said.

"I know."

"Do not react to her testimony."

"I know."

"Your face reacts before your mouth does."

Theron gave her a look.

"That face," Lenora said.

He almost smiled.

Then Corisande arrived.

She wore a charcoal suit, her platinum hair pulled into a low knot. There was no visible injury from the pool. She walked beside her attorney without looking at Theron.

For a second, Theron remembered their wedding.

Corisande laughing beneath white roses.

Eirlys, barely two, dropping petals in the aisle and refusing to walk in a straight line.

Theron had believed they were beginning something.

Now they sat on opposite sides of a courtroom while lawyers discussed whether they were dangerous to each other.

The judge reviewed the petition for temporary protective orders and the pending divorce filing Theron had submitted two days earlier.

Corisande testified first.

Her voice was controlled.

She described the garage wall incident. She described Theron following her during arguments. She described the pool kick.

"Were you afraid?" her attorney asked.

"Yes."

"Why?"

"Because he was holding Eirlys and still kicked me. I realized his anger had become more important to him than anything else."

Theron's jaw tightened.

He heard Dr. Reyes in his head: warning signal.

He loosened it.

Then Corisande's attorney asked about the slap.

Corisande looked down.

"I lost my temper."

"Had Eirlys intentionally tripped you?"

"Afterward."

"Before you fell, what had happened?"

"She had been following me, grabbing my clothing, refusing to stop after I asked repeatedly."

"And you struck her?"

"Once."

"Do you regret it?"

Corisande's eyes filled with tears.

"Yes."

Theron wanted to reject the tears as performance.

Then he remembered the silent security footage showing her in the pool after he left, hands over her face.

He forced himself not to decide what every emotion meant.

When Theron testified, Lenora kept the questions simple.

"Did you kick your wife?"

"Yes."

"Were you holding Eirlys?"

"Yes."

"Do you believe that was appropriate?"

"No."

"Why did you do it?"

Theron looked toward the judge, not Corisande.

"I saw the mark on my daughter's face. Corisande admitted hitting her. I became furious and chose retaliation instead of safety."

Corisande's attorney looked up sharply.

Lenora continued.

"What have you done since then?"

Theron described urgent care, the report, the preserved video, the safety plan, Eirlys's therapy, and his own counseling.

"Are you asking the court to excuse your conduct because Corisande struck Eirlys first?"

"No."

"Are you asking the court to ignore Corisande's conduct because you also acted improperly?"

"No."

"What are you asking for?"

Theron took a breath.

"No unsupervised contact between Corisande and Eirlys while the child-safety investigation is open. Clear boundaries between Corisande and me. And time to prove that I can keep my daughter safe without becoming part of the danger."

The courtroom was quiet.

On cross-examination, Corisande's attorney was sharper.

"Mr. Viremont, you are six feet two inches tall and considerably stronger than my client, correct?"

"Yes."

"You have punched a wall during an argument with her?"

"Once."

"You have stood in doorways while she tried to leave conversations?"

"I stood in doorways. I did not understand at the time that she felt blocked."

"That is not my question."

Lenora rose. "Asked and answered."

The judge nodded. "Move on."

The attorney held up a still image from the pool video.

Theron saw himself frozen at the exact moment his foot connected with Corisande.

Eirlys was in his arms.

"Would you call this protective parenting?"

Theron stared at the image.

"No."

"Would you call it violence?"

Lenora shifted beside him.

Theron answered before she could object.

"Yes."

The attorney paused, perhaps expecting resistance.

"And yet you want this court to trust you with a three-year-old child?"

Theron looked at the judge.

"I want the court to judge what I did, what I am doing about it, and whether Eirlys is safe with me. I don't want trust I haven't earned."

The judge called a recess.

Twenty minutes later, she issued temporary reciprocal no-harassment orders between Theron and Corisande, prohibited Corisande from unsupervised contact with Eirlys pending the child-services assessment, and left Eirlys in Theron's care under the existing safety plan.

It was not victory.

Lenora made sure he understood that.

"The court did not declare you right," she said in the hallway.

"I know."

"And it did not declare Corisande irredeemable."

"I know."

Across the corridor, Corisande looked at him for the first time that day.

There was anger in her face.

But underneath it, Theron saw something else.

Loss.

He wondered whether she saw the same thing in him.

Neither spoke.

Then their attorneys guided them in opposite directions.

Outside, Theron found Seraphine waiting with Eirlys in the car.

The little girl pressed both palms to the window when she saw him.

Theron opened the back door.

"Daddy!"

"Hey, sweetheart."

"Court done?"

"For today."

"You win?"

The question caught him off guard.

He looked at Seraphine, then back at Eirlys.

"It wasn't that kind of court."

"Who won?"

Theron buckled her seat belt.

"Nobody."

Eirlys frowned.

He kissed her forehead.

"But you get to come home with me."

May you like

That answer satisfied her.

For Theron, it was enough.

Related Stories

Other posts