scribe

Chapter 18

The Child Services Report Did Not Give Theron the Victory He Expected, and That Was Exactly Why He Trusted It

The final report arrived six weeks after the pool incident.

Lenora insisted Theron read it with her present.

"Because I think you'll react to certain language," she said.

"You think I react to everything."

"I have billing records that support the theory."

Theron sat across from her conference table as she opened the document.

The first section summarized the incident.

Corisande's slap was substantiated as inappropriate physical discipline resulting in visible injury.

Her use of the under-stair storage area as confinement was substantiated based on Eirlys's repeated disclosures, Maris's concerns, Corisande's own statement to investigators, and the physical layout of the space.

The report also documented emotional intimidation: prolonged punitive sitting, harsh statements, and a pattern of making Eirlys responsible for Corisande's emotional state.

Theron felt his stomach twist even though none of it was new.

Then Lenora turned the page.

"Here is the section you won't like."

The report described Theron's pool kick as a serious lapse in protective judgment.

It noted that he used physical force while holding Eirlys, exposing the child to risk of accidental injury and reinforcing a pattern of retaliatory behavior in response to conflict.

It also referenced his prior wall-punching incident and acknowledged Corisande's reports that his physical presence during arguments could be intimidating.

Theron read the paragraph twice.

"They make me sound dangerous."

Lenora waited.

Theron caught himself.

"No. That's defensive."

"Good catch."

He continued reading.

The next paragraph documented mitigating factors: Theron immediately sought medical care for Eirlys, self-reported his own conduct, preserved footage, complied with every safety recommendation, initiated counseling, removed Corisande's unsupervised access, and demonstrated insight into his behavior.

The agency found Eirlys could safely remain in his care with continued therapeutic support and a voluntary family safety plan.

Theron set the report down.

"I thought I'd feel relieved."

"You are relieved."

"Not only relieved."

"What else?"

"Exposed."

Lenora nodded.

"Accurate reports tend to do that."

The report recommended no unsupervised contact between Corisande and Eirlys until a qualified clinician determined whether contact would benefit the child. It also recommended that Corisande complete parenting education and individual therapy focused on anger, control, and child development.

For Theron, the recommendations were different but equally specific: continued individual counseling, participation in a nonviolent conflict-resolution program, and regular communication with Eirlys's therapist.

Theron tapped the page.

"A conflict-resolution program."

"Yes."

"Do they think I'm abusive?"

"The report does not use that conclusion. It says you displayed concerning reactive aggression."

He grimaced.

"That sounds worse somehow."

"It sounds precise."

Theron leaned back.

"I'm going to do it."

"I assumed you would."

"Not for court."

Lenora raised an eyebrow.

"Try not to say things like that in front of your lawyer. We enjoy credit for strategic compliance."

Theron almost smiled.

The criminal side of the incident remained unresolved.

Corisande had reported the kick. The urgent-care report and child-services referral had separately documented the slap. Police had obtained the video.

Two weeks after the child-services report, a prosecutor's office requested that both adults appear through counsel for a pre-charge conference.

Theron sat in another plain room under fluorescent lights.

The prosecutor, Armand Wells, spoke without drama.

"We have a clear recording of two separate physical acts," he said. "Mrs. Viremont strikes a child. Mr. Viremont later kicks Mrs. Viremont. The fact that one occurs first does not legally erase the second."

Neither attorney argued with that premise.

Because the injuries were minor, both parties had no comparable criminal history, and both had begun counseling, the prosecutor offered separate diversion agreements subject to judicial approval.

Corisande would complete parenting intervention, individual counseling, and community service, and comply with all child-contact restrictions.

Theron would complete anger-management and nonviolent-conflict courses, community service, and the no-harassment order.

Successful completion could resolve the charges without trial.

Theron looked at Lenora.

"Accept it," she said quietly. "Unless you want to litigate self-defense or defense of another, which the video makes difficult because the immediate danger had passed."

Theron looked across the room at Corisande.

She was pale.

Her attorney whispered to her.

For one second, their eyes met.

Neither looked victorious.

Theron signed.

So did Corisande.

Outside the building, Lenora asked how he felt.

"Like consequences are less dramatic than revenge."

"Usually."

"I used to think consequences meant someone lost."

"And now?"

Theron watched Corisande get into a waiting car across the street.

"Now I think they mean everyone carries their part."

That evening, Eirlys was coloring at the kitchen table when Theron came home.

"Court?" she asked.

"Sort of."

"You win?"

He smiled.

She still loved that question.

"No winning. I have classes to take because I made an unsafe choice."

Eirlys brightened.

"School!"

"Yes. Daddy school."

"You get backpack?"

Theron laughed.

"Probably not."

She looked disappointed.

The next morning, a tiny pink backpack appeared beside his briefcase.

Inside were two crayons, a packet of crackers, and the wooden giraffe from therapy.

Eirlys stood proudly beside it.

"For Daddy school."

Theron crouched and kissed her forehead.

"Thank you."

May you like

He carried the backpack to his first conflict-resolution class.

He left the giraffe inside.

Related Stories

Other posts