scribe

Chapter 16

Theron Learned That Saying Sorry to a Child Required More Courage Than Defending Himself in Front of a Judge

Dr. Reyes asked Theron a question he had been avoiding.

"Have you apologized to Eirlys?"

Theron frowned.

"I told her the kick was wrong."

"That is a statement. I asked whether you apologized."

Theron looked at the bookshelf behind the therapist.

"I don't want to make her responsible for comforting me."

"Good. Then don't."

"She's three."

"Exactly. Use three-year-old words."

Theron leaned back.

"What would you say?"

Dr. Reyes shook his head.

"No. You don't get to outsource this."

Theron gave him a tired look.

"You charge a lot to make people do their own work."

"An excellent business model."

Theron smiled despite himself.

Then the smile faded.

"I keep thinking about the moment before I kicked Corisande. The video shows I had time. Maybe two seconds. Three. I always told myself it was instinct. It wasn't only instinct. I wanted to hurt her back."

"And what are you afraid happens if Eirlys knows that?"

"That she sees me differently."

"She already saw you do it."

The answer landed hard.

Theron rubbed his jaw.

"I suppose I'm still trying to protect the version of me she had before."

"That version is gone."

"You could say that more gently."

"Would it become less true?"

Theron said nothing.

Dr. Reyes continued.

"Children do not need flawless parents. They need adults who repair ruptures without asking the child to pretend the rupture never happened."

That evening, Theron found Eirlys sitting on the nursery rug lining up toy animals.

"Can I play?"

She handed him a wooden giraffe.

"You be this."

Theron sat cross-legged beside her.

For several minutes they moved animals through an imaginary zoo. Then Theron set down the giraffe.

"Eirlys, I want to tell you something."

She kept moving a zebra.

"Okay."

"About the pool."

The zebra stopped.

Theron felt his throat tighten.

"When I saw your cheek, I got very angry. Then I kicked Corisande into the water. That was wrong."

Eirlys looked at him.

"I know."

"I know you know. But I need to say something else. I'm sorry you had to see me do that. I'm sorry I was holding you when I did it. You should have been able to feel safe in my arms."

Eirlys stared down at the zebra.

"You mad at Mommy."

"Very mad."

"Because slap."

"Yes. But being very mad did not make kicking okay."

She moved the zebra closer to the giraffe.

"You say sorry Mommy?"

Theron paused.

"I told the court I was wrong. I will take responsibility with Corisande through the grown-ups helping us. But I am talking to you right now because you were there."

"Mommy say sorry me?"

He thought of the letter.

"She tried. Your feelings doctor thinks she needs to say it more clearly before you hear it."

Eirlys nodded as if that made perfect sense.

Then she picked up a lion.

"Lion kicks?"

"Maybe Lion gets angry."

She made the lion stomp around.

"Lion mad!"

"What can Lion do instead of kick?"

Eirlys frowned, thinking.

"Roar stop."

Theron smiled.

"Roar stop."

She made the lion face the zebra.

"STOP!"

"Good."

Then she put the lion down.

"Daddy?"

"Yeah?"

"You still get star."

Theron felt tears rise unexpectedly.

"Thank you."

Eirlys climbed into his lap.

He did not tighten his arms around her until she leaned back against his chest.

They sat quietly.

Theron had imagined apology as a dramatic moment in which guilt moved from one person to another and forgiveness settled the debt.

Instead, Eirlys asked whether giraffes could sleep standing up.

The world continued.

Maybe that was mercy.

Later that night, after she was asleep, Theron opened an old storage box in his closet.

Inside were photographs of Elowen.

He had not looked at them in months.

One showed Elowen sitting cross-legged on a hospital bed with newborn Eirlys against her chest. Her dark hair was tangled. Her face was exhausted and radiant.

Theron sat on the floor holding the photograph.

After Elowen died, he had made one silent promise above Eirlys's crib: Nothing will happen to you.

It was the kind of promise grief made people believe they could keep.

Nothing will happen to you.

As if fatherhood could defeat chance.

As if money could buy certainty.

As if the right house, schools, gates, cameras, and carefully selected adults could eliminate danger.

When Corisande entered their lives, Theron had wanted to believe he had repaired the missing shape of a family. He had wanted a mother for Eirlys, a partner for himself, a future that looked less haunted by loss.

He had mistaken structure for safety.

Then, at the pool, his old promise had erupted in its ugliest form. Something had happened to Eirlys, and Theron had tried to erase helplessness with force.

He placed the photograph on his bedside table.

The next week, he told Dr. Reyes about the promise.

"Maybe the goal was impossible," Theron said. "Nothing will happen to you."

"Of course it was impossible."

"Then what do I promise instead?"

Dr. Reyes thought for a moment.

"Maybe: when something happens, you won't face it alone."

Theron looked down.

That was less heroic.

More human.

That night, when Eirlys woke from another pool dream, Theron carried her to the window and held her while she watched rain touch the glass.

"Daddy?"

"I'm here."

He did not promise nothing bad would happen again.

He did not know enough to make that promise anymore.

He only stayed until her breathing slowed.

May you like

And when she finally slept, he whispered the new promise into her hair.

"Whatever happens, you won't be alone."

Related Stories

Other posts