Chapter 17

When Corisande Returned for Her Belongings, the Missing Door Beneath the Stairs Made Denial Harder Than Anger
The retrieval was scheduled for a Saturday morning.
Eirlys spent the day with Seraphine. Lenora arranged for a neutral property coordinator named Graham Holt to be present so Theron and Corisande would not be alone together.
Theron hated needing a witness inside his own home.
He also understood why it was necessary.
Corisande arrived at ten wearing jeans, a camel coat, and no jewelry except small earrings. Two movers followed in a separate truck.
Graham reviewed the rules at the front door.
"We are here for agreed personal property only. No discussion of the case. No arguments. If either of you needs a break, say so."
Corisande gave a clipped nod.
Theron stepped aside.
For the next hour, she moved through rooms that had once been hers.
Dresses disappeared into garment boxes. Shoes went into labeled cartons. Her perfume bottles vanished from the bathroom counter. The bedroom slowly became a place Theron barely recognized.
He remained downstairs most of the time.
Then Corisande came down carrying a framed photograph from their wedding.
Eirlys stood between them in the picture, holding both their hands.
Corisande stopped at the foot of the stairs.
Her gaze shifted past Theron.
To the storage area.
The door was gone.
She stared at the empty frame.
"You removed it."
Theron felt Graham move subtly closer.
"Yes."
Corisande's mouth tightened.
"Of course you did."
"We're not discussing the case," Graham reminded them.
Corisande ignored him.
"You want everything in this house to look like evidence now."
Theron felt anger stir.
Warning signals.
He kept his arms loose at his sides.
"I removed a door Eirlys was afraid of."
"She was not afraid of a door."
"Corisande."
Graham's tone sharpened.
She turned on him.
"Do you know what he does? He turns every mistake into a moral trial. He stands there calm now because there is a witness."
Theron felt the accusation hit because part of it was true.
He was calmer because Graham was there.
The question was whether that made the calm false.
Maybe external structure was what people used until self-control became internal.
"We should stop talking," Theron said.
Corisande laughed bitterly.
"Now you know how to stop?"
"Yes."
That answer silenced her for a second.
Theron continued.
"I wish I had learned earlier."
Corisande looked back at the missing door.
Her shoulders dropped slightly.
"I never hurt her in there."
Graham raised a hand.
"Mrs. Viremont, please do not discuss allegations."
But Theron had already heard it.
Not: I never put her in there.
I never hurt her in there.
Corisande seemed to realize the same thing.
Her face changed.
Theron's pulse accelerated.
He wanted to ask the question.
How many times?
How long?
Why?
Instead he said, "Graham, I need a break."
The coordinator nodded immediately.
Theron walked into the study and closed the door.
His hands were shaking.
He called Dr. Reyes, not expecting an answer on a Saturday.
The therapist picked up after two rings.
"Is this urgent?"
"Corisande is here with a property coordinator. She just admitted, basically, that she put Eirlys under the stairs."
"What do you want to do?"
"Demand an answer."
"And what will that accomplish today?"
Theron closed his eyes.
"Nothing."
"Is Eirlys safe?"
"She's not here."
"Are you safe?"
"Yes."
"Is Corisande safe?"
Theron looked toward the closed door.
"Yes."
"Then follow the plan."
Theron exhaled.
"I hate the plan."
"Plans are rarely designed to satisfy rage."
Theron almost laughed.
"You therapists really do coordinate."
"We have matching jackets."
The call lasted less than three minutes.
When Theron returned, Corisande was sitting on the bottom stair. The wedding photograph rested beside her.
Graham stood a few feet away.
Corisande looked up.
"I put her there four times."
Theron stopped.
Graham immediately said, "I need to remind you not to discuss -"
"I know," Corisande said. "But I'm tired of hearing myself pretend."
Theron did not move closer.
"Why?"
Her eyes filled.
"Because I couldn't get her to listen. Because she would scream. Because I would tell her to sit in time-out and she'd get up. The storage room was safe. There was nothing dangerous in it. I would close the door for a few minutes."
"The latch was outside."
"I know."
Theron's jaw tightened.
"She couldn't get out."
"That was the point."
The words hung between them.
Corisande covered her face.
"God. Do you hear how that sounds?"
Theron did.
He also heard how close his own past reasoning had come to similar territory: I did not hit her. I only hit the wall. I did not trap her. I only stood in the doorway.
Intent had been his favorite defense too.
"Did you leave her in the dark?" he asked.
Corisande shook her head.
"The light was usually on. Once it went off automatically and she cried. I opened the door."
Theron felt sick.
"How long?"
"I don't know. Five minutes. Ten. Maybe longer once."
Graham stepped between the conversation gently.
"This needs to go through counsel and the investigators. I am stopping this discussion now."
Theron nodded.
Corisande did too.
She picked up the wedding photograph.
Then, unexpectedly, she held it out to Theron.
"Keep this for her."
He took it.
Corisande returned upstairs.
When the movers left two hours later, the house felt stripped.
Theron carried the photograph to Eirlys's room but did not put it on display.
He placed it in a drawer.
Not hidden.
Not honored.
Simply kept.
That evening, Eirlys came home and noticed empty spaces in the closet.
"Mommy clothes gone."
"Yes. She picked up some of her things today."
"Mommy come back?"
Theron sat beside her on the bed.
"Not to live here."
Eirlys absorbed that.
"Because bad choices?"
"Because the grown-ups decided living separately is safer."
She touched the pink ribbon around Rabbit's neck.
"Mommy still Mommy?"
Theron swallowed.
"She was your stepmom. She cared for you for a long time. You can call her whatever feels right in your memories."
Eirlys nodded.
Then she asked the question Theron had been waiting for.
"She love me?"
He looked at his daughter.
"I think she did. I think she also hurt you. Both can be true."
Eirlys seemed to consider this.
"Love not hit."
Theron's eyes filled.
"Love should not hit."
May you like
He wished the rule were enough to explain the world.
For a three-year-old, perhaps it was a good place to begin.