scribe

Chapter 14

Corisande's First Apology Sounded Beautiful Until Theron Realized How Carefully It Avoided the Words Eirlys Needed Most

The letter arrived through Lenora.

"Corisande's attorney says she wrote this voluntarily," Lenora told Theron. "They want to know whether you will allow it to be read to Eirlys by her therapist."

Theron opened the attachment.

The letter was one page.

Dear Eirlys,

I am sorry our day by the pool became so frightening. Grown-ups sometimes become overwhelmed and make choices they wish they could take back. I was tired and upset, and I reacted in a way that scared you. I hope someday you will remember all the good days we shared too. I love you and miss you very much. I hope you can forgive me, and I hope your daddy and I can find a peaceful way through this difficult time.

Love,

Mommy Corisande

Theron read it twice.

The first time, he felt rage.

The second time, he tried to identify why.

Then he saw it.

The letter never said: I slapped you.

It never said: You did not deserve it.

It never mentioned the storage room.

It placed the frightening day around them like weather that had happened to everyone equally.

He called Dr. Bell.

"What do you think?"

"I think the letter is about Corisande's need to be forgiven."

"Exactly."

"That doesn't mean it is worthless. It means it may not be useful to Eirlys yet."

Theron paced slowly, then noticed himself and stopped.

"Can we tell her to rewrite it?"

"You can communicate through counsel that the therapist does not recommend sharing it in its current form."

"What should it say?"

"That isn't for you to script."

Theron sighed.

"Right. Control disguises itself as action."

"You're learning."

"Annoyingly."

Lenora sent a neutral response declining to share the letter with Eirlys at that time.

Two days later, Corisande requested a mediated session with Theron.

The court order allowed communication in structured settings, and Lenora advised that the session might help settle immediate household and divorce issues.

They met in a conference room at a mediation center.

Corisande sat across from him.

For the first time since the courthouse, they were close enough to see each other's exhaustion.

She looked thinner.

Theron wondered if he did too.

The mediator reviewed rules. No interruptions. No threats. No discussion of pending criminal questions. They would focus on temporary finances, residence, and communication.

They resolved almost nothing for the first hour.

Then, during a break, Corisande said quietly, "Did she get my letter?"

Theron looked toward the mediator.

The woman nodded that he could answer.

"Her therapist did. Eirlys did not."

Corisande's eyes hardened.

"You kept it from her."

"The therapist recommended against sharing it."

"Why?"

Theron chose his words carefully.

"Because it asked a three-year-old to forgive you before you clearly named what you did."

Corisande flinched.

"I said I reacted badly."

"You hit her."

Her mouth tightened.

"And she tripped me."

Theron felt anger rise.

Jaw.

Hands.

He relaxed both.

"Yes. She did. And I kicked you. I have said that plainly in court, to child services, to my therapist, and to Eirlys."

Corisande stared at him.

"So now you're morally superior because you confess better?"

"No."

"That's exactly what this feels like."

Theron leaned back.

"Then forget me. Write the letter as if I don't exist."

"What does that mean?"

"Don't mention our marriage. Don't mention peace between us. Don't mention whether Eirlys forgives you. Tell her what you did, tell her it wasn't her fault, and don't ask her for anything."

Corisande's eyes filled.

"You think I don't love her."

Theron looked at her for a long moment.

"I think love that frightens a child still frightens a child."

She looked away.

The mediator did not speak.

Theron continued more quietly.

"I loved you. I still kicked you. Loving someone does not erase what we do to them."

Corisande wiped beneath one eye.

"Do you still love me?"

The question stunned him.

He considered lying because the truthful answer was messy.

"Part of me probably does."

She looked back at him.

"Then why are you divorcing me?"

"Because love is not enough to make this house safe."

For the first time, Corisande had no immediate reply.

The mediator eventually resumed the formal session.

They agreed Corisande would remain in separate housing. They agreed communication would continue only through attorneys or mediation. They arranged access for Corisande to retrieve personal belongings when Eirlys was not home.

At the end, Corisande paused beside the door.

"I didn't plan to become someone who hit a child."

Theron looked at her.

"Neither of us planned the person we became at that pool."

"Is there any way back?"

He thought of Eirlys hiding under a blanket fort.

Of the storage door in the garage.

Of the security footage.

Of Corisande in the water after he walked away.

"Not back," he said. "Maybe forward. But not together."

Corisande nodded once.

Then she left.

That night, Theron reread her letter.

He no longer felt only anger.

He felt sadness for the apology she had almost written.

Sometimes remorse began as self-pity because self-pity was the only pain a person knew how to name.

Whether Corisande could move beyond it was no longer Theron's decision.

May you like

His responsibility was smaller and harder.

He had to make sure Eirlys was never asked to heal an adult who had hurt her.

Related Stories

Other posts