Chapter 2

The Second Splash Stayed in the House Long After the Water Became Still
Inside, Theron carried Eirlys straight past the living room and into the downstairs study.
It was the quietest room in the house, lined with dark shelves and heavy curtains. He set her gently on the leather sofa and crouched in front of her.
"Let me see your cheek, sweetheart."
Eirlys kept both hands over it.
"It hurts."
"I know. I won't touch it unless you say I can."
Her eyes lifted to his.
He waited.
After several seconds she lowered one hand.
The mark was unmistakable now. Not catastrophic. Not bloody. But visible enough that Theron's stomach tightened.
He went to the small refrigerator beneath the bar counter, wrapped ice in a clean cloth, and returned.
"Cold cloth?"
She nodded.
He let her take it herself.
"Daddy?"
"Yes?"
"Is Mommy mad?"
Theron sat back on his heels.
Outside, faintly, he could hear the patio door opening.
Corisande had come inside.
"You don't need to worry about her feelings right now," he said. "You need to tell me if anything else hurts."
Eirlys shook her head.
"Did Mommy slap you before today?"
The question left his mouth before he could soften it.
Eirlys looked down.
That was answer enough to frighten him.
"Sweetheart?"
"Sometimes she gets mad."
Theron's throat tightened.
"What does she do when she gets mad?"
Eirlys pressed the cloth to her cheek and whispered, "She says I make everything hard."
The study door opened.
Corisande stood there, soaked and furious, a towel wrapped around her shoulders.
"We need to talk. Now."
Theron rose.
"Not in front of her."
"You kicked me into a swimming pool while you were holding a child."
He glanced at Eirlys.
Her eyes had widened.
"Go upstairs and change," Theron said. "We will talk after I take Eirlys to be checked."
Corisande laughed once in disbelief.
"Checked? For a slap?"
Theron crossed the room and closed the distance between them, but he stopped several feet away.
"Do not call it nothing."
"I didn't call it nothing. I said it was one slap."
"And I saw the mark."
"Did you see her trip me?"
"Yes."
That answer surprised her.
"Then you know what she did."
Theron turned to Eirlys.
"And we will talk about that too."
Corisande stared at him.
For the first time, some of her anger gave way to uncertainty.
Theron did not defend what his daughter had done. He did not pretend a three-year-old should be taught that hurting someone back was acceptable.
But he also did not let that become an excuse for Corisande.
"She is three," he said. "You are thirty-two."
Corisande's jaw tightened.
"And you are forty-one. You want to talk about adult behavior? Let's talk about the fact that you kicked me while carrying her."
The words landed because they were true.
Theron looked away first.
"I should not have done that."
Eirlys stared at him.
Corisande seemed almost disappointed that he had admitted it.
"But," he continued, "my mistake does not erase yours."
"Your mistake?"
"Yes. Mine."
The room went quiet.
Theron reached for his phone.
"I'm taking Eirlys to urgent care."
"Don't turn this into some public spectacle."
"This isn't about your reputation."
"Everything becomes about reputation when lawyers get involved."
He stopped.
"Why did you say lawyers?"
Corisande's eyes flickered.
"Because you assaulted me."
Theron felt Eirlys watching both of them.
He put the phone away and lowered his voice.
"Go change. We will discuss this later."
"You're throwing me out?"
"I'm asking you to stay away from Eirlys until we know what happened today and whether anything like it happened before."
"I am your wife."
"And she is my daughter."
Corisande flinched as if the sentence contained more than he intended.
Maybe it did.
She stepped backward.
"Fine. Take her. Make me the villain."
Theron looked at Eirlys's cheek.
"You made a choice. I made one too. We are both going to answer for them."
Corisande left without another word.
Twenty minutes later, Theron buckled Eirlys into her car seat.
She held the cold cloth against her face with one hand and her stuffed rabbit with the other.
As Theron closed the rear door, he caught his own reflection in the dark window.
He looked like the same man who had left for work that morning.
But he no longer felt like him.
On the drive, Eirlys asked a question so quietly he almost missed it.
"Daddy, did you kick Mommy because I made her fall?"
His fingers tightened around the steering wheel.
"No."
"Because she slapped me?"
Theron swallowed.
"Yes. But I should not have kicked her."
"Why?"
He glanced at her in the rearview mirror.
"Because being angry does not mean I get to hurt someone. Even when they did something wrong first."
Eirlys stared at him, thinking in the solemn way small children sometimes did when adults finally stopped pretending life was simple.
"I made her fall."
"We will talk about that too."
"Am I bad?"
Theron's chest tightened.
"No. But you did something unsafe. That is different."
She looked down at the rabbit.
"Mommy said I was bad."
Theron nearly missed the next turn.
"When?"
Eirlys did not answer.
The urgent-care sign appeared ahead.
Theron parked and sat motionless for a second before getting out.
The story he had believed about his home was already breaking apart.
May you like
And he was beginning to understand that the pool had not started anything.
It had only exposed what had been happening while he was away.