scribe

Chapter 23

The Judge Asked Theron Whether He Wanted Corisande Gone Forever, and His Answer Surprised Everyone in the Courtroom

The review hearing occurred nearly four months after the pool incident.

By then, autumn had begun turning the trees around the courthouse copper and red.

Theron had completed most of his required conflict-resolution program. Corisande had completed a parenting course and continued individual therapy. The child-services case was moving toward closure with a long-term safety plan.

The central question was future contact between Corisande and Eirlys.

Dr. Bell submitted a clinical recommendation.

Eirlys was making progress but still associated Corisande with fear, closed doors, and the pool. She was not currently asking to see her. Dr. Bell recommended no in-person contact for the next three months, with the possibility of reassessment later. Written communication could continue if it remained non-demanding and was screened by the therapist.

Corisande's attorney did not object.

That surprised Theron.

Then the judge asked him directly.

"Mr. Viremont, are you asking this court to permanently prohibit all future contact between Corisande Viremont and Eirlys?"

Theron felt Lenora shift beside him.

They had discussed the question.

He knew what fear wanted him to say.

Yes. Forever. Never again.

Instead he answered, "No, Your Honor."

Corisande looked up sharply.

The judge leaned forward.

"Explain."

"I am asking the court to follow Eirlys's safety and therapeutic needs. Right now that means no in-person contact. I support that completely. But I don't think I should decide today what Eirlys may want years from now."

"You would permit contact in the future?"

"If qualified professionals believe it is safe, if Corisande continues the work she's doing, and most importantly if Eirlys wants it."

The judge studied him.

"Most parents in your position ask for finality."

Theron thought of the pink ribbon, the butterfly, the wedding photograph in Eirlys's drawer.

"Finality for me is not the same as finality for her."

Corisande lowered her eyes.

The judge turned to her.

"Mrs. Viremont, do you understand that your prior caregiving role does not entitle you to contact if the child is not emotionally ready?"

"Yes."

"Do you agree not to pressure the child through gifts, messages, relatives, or third parties?"

"Yes."

"And if the child never wishes to resume contact?"

Corisande's face tightened.

A long silence followed.

"Then I will have to live with that."

The judge nodded.

The temporary order was extended with the therapist's recommended terms.

Afterward, Theron and Lenora walked down the courthouse steps.

"You surprised me," Lenora said.

"You knew what I was going to say."

"I knew what we discussed. I wasn't sure whether fear would change your answer."

Theron slipped his hands into his coat pockets.

"It almost did."

"Why didn't it?"

He looked across the street, where Corisande stood speaking with her attorney.

"Because I keep telling Eirlys that her feelings are hers. If someday she wants answers from Corisande, I don't want my anger to have erased the possibility before she was old enough to choose."

Lenora nodded.

"That's a good answer."

"Don't sound so surprised."

"I'm a lawyer. Suspicion is a professional requirement."

At home, Eirlys asked about court.

"Corisande there?"

"Yes."

"She ask see me?"

Theron sat beside her at the craft table.

"The grown-ups talked about whether visits should happen. Dr. Iona said not yet. Corisande agreed."

Eirlys's shoulders relaxed.

Theron noticed.

"Were you worried?"

She nodded.

"I don't want."

"Then you don't have to right now."

"When big?"

"When you're bigger, you might feel the same or different. Either is okay."

Eirlys dipped a brush into green paint.

"If different, you mad?"

Theron's heart tightened.

"No."

"Promise?"

"Promise."

She painted a long crooked line.

"If same, you mad?"

"No."

"Promise?"

"Promise."

Eirlys smiled.

"Good."

The conversation lasted less than two minutes.

Theron thought about it for days.

Children often tested love by changing the hypothetical.

If I want this, will you stay?

If I want the opposite, will you stay?

Theron had spent much of his adult life rewarding agreement. At work, people who aligned with him moved quickly. People who challenged him had to be unusually confident to keep doing it.

He did not want Eirlys to learn that closeness depended on choosing the answer he preferred.

At his next therapy session, he told Dr. Reyes about the courthouse question.

"I wanted her gone forever," Theron admitted.

"And now?"

"I want distance now. I want safety. But forever belongs to Eirlys too."

Dr. Reyes nodded.

"That is a substantial shift."

Theron stared at the floor.

"It doesn't feel like one."

"Growth rarely announces itself with music."

"That's disappointing."

"You can hire a violinist if you need one."

Theron laughed.

Then Dr. Reyes asked, "What would happen if Eirlys grows up and forgives Corisande?"

Theron's smile disappeared.

"I don't know."

"Would you feel betrayed?"

The honest answer came slowly.

"Maybe."

"Then that is work for later."

Theron nodded.

There was always work for later.

May you like

He had once believed a father protected his child by closing dangerous doors.

Now he understood that sometimes protection meant leaving a safe door unlocked for a future choice, then standing far enough away that the child could decide whether to open it.

Related Stories

Other posts