Chapter 6 - The Empty Chair

Ottie returned to Hawthorne on Monday under a safety plan.
Persie, Astrid, and Maelle were placed in separate supervised learning
rooms while the investigation continued. Ottie could use the counselor’s
office whenever she needed. Ms. West rearranged seating without
announcing why.
Yet the hardest thing was not seeing the girls.
It was seeing their empty chairs.
Each one felt like a spotlight.
At morning meeting, a boy named Theo raised his hand. “Are Persie and
Astrid suspended?”
Ms. West answered carefully. “Some students are learning in different
spaces today. We are not discussing private disciplinary matters.”
Another child whispered, “It’s because of the mouse.”
Ms. West heard.
“So we are going to discuss something we can discuss,” she said. “What
do you do when you see someone being treated badly?”
Hands rose with textbook answers.
Tell a teacher. Say stop. Get help.
Ottie stared at her desk.
Nobody said laugh because you are afraid they will choose you next.
At lunch, Theo sat across from her.
He pushed a sealed packet of crackers toward the middle of the table.
“You can have these if you want.”
Ottie stiffened.
He immediately pulled them back. “Sorry. That was weird.”
“No.” She looked at him. “Thank you.”
It was the first ordinary kindness she had received from a classmate in
weeks, and it nearly made her cry.
After school, Ms. Shaw met with Ottie.
“Do you remember the first time Persie did something that frightened
you?”
Ottie thought.
Not the quiz. Before that.
A birthday party in September.
Persie had invited almost every girl in the class to a sleepover. Ottie
had not been invited, which had hurt but was not bullying. On Monday,
Persie approached her and said, “I heard you cried because you weren’t
invited.”
Ottie had not cried.
“How did she know it bothered you?” Ms. Shaw asked.
“I told Maelle.”
There it was: the first small betrayal.
Ottie’s face tightened. “I thought Maelle was my friend.”
“She may have been.”
“Friends don’t do that.”
“No,” Ms. Shaw said. “But frightened people sometimes betray friends.
Understanding why does not mean pretending it was okay.”
Ottie looked out at the snow.
Elsewhere in the building, Maelle was giving Principal Ward access to an
old tablet synchronized with her messages. She had deleted The Court
from her phone several times, but cloud backups remained.
The IT administrator recovered months of conversation.
There were polls ranking classmates by appearance. Photos taken without
permission. Instructions to ignore Ottie. A picture of Ottie standing
alone outside the skating rink, captioned WAITING FOR FRIENDS THAT DON’T
EXIST.
Then they found a voice message from Persie.
“If she tells again, we make her look crazy. My mom says schools hate
drama. If Ottie becomes the drama, they’ll want her gone.”
Principal Ward replayed it.
Celeste had not necessarily told Persie to target Ottie. The statement
could have been distorted by a child. But the strategy was clear.
Make the victim look like the problem.
Ms. West listened once and felt sick.
Then another recovered message appeared, this one from Astrid.
“What about the notes?”
Persie replied:
“I’ll write both sides. Easy.”
The anonymous notes Persie had produced were not evidence against Ottie.
They were evidence of fabrication.
And below that message was a photograph of a purple marker, a hand-drawn
May you like
crown, and five words:
FRIDAY WILL BE THE BEST ONE.