Chapter 2 - The First Question

Ms. West did not ask Ottie to calm down. She did not tell the class it
was only a prank. She asked the aide to take the students to the
library, closed the classroom door, and sat on the floor beside Ottie’s
chair.
“Are you hurt?”
Ottie shook her head.
“Did the mouse hurt you?”
Another shake.
“Did someone hurt the mouse?”
“No.” Ottie wiped her face. “It was in a little box. I felt cardboard.”
Ms. West glanced toward the open backpack. “May I look?”
Ottie hesitated, then nodded.
Inside, beneath two textbooks, Ms. West found a small ventilated
pet-store carrier. There was bedding in it and a slice of apple. Whoever
had arranged the prank had not intended to injure the animal. That did
not make the act harmless. It meant someone had planned it.
Ms. West took out her phone and photographed the bag, carrier, desk, and
marker writing before touching anything else. Then she called the school
office and asked for Principal Helena Ward and the campus counselor.
Ottie watched her. “Am I in trouble?”
The question hit Ms. West harder than the scream had.
“No,” she said. “Why would you think that?”
Ottie stared at the floor.
Ms. West remembered other moments. Ottie asking to eat lunch in the
classroom. Ottie volunteering to stay inside during recess. Ottie
arriving early and lingering after dismissal. Each had seemed small in
isolation.
“How long has this been happening?”
“I don’t know.”
“Days?”
Silence.
“Weeks?”
Ottie’s eyes filled again.
Ms. West lowered her voice. “Months?”
Ottie nodded.
Principal Ward arrived with counselor Miriam Shaw. Ms. West stopped them
at the doorway and spoke quietly before they approached. She insisted
that Ottie not be made to repeat everything to multiple adults.
Ms. Shaw sat beside Ottie. “You can tell us what you want us to know
today. We can take the rest slowly.”
Ottie looked toward the window. Snow swirled beyond the glass.
“They call me Ghost because I’m skinny,” she said. “Persie says I look
like I’m already disappearing.”
Ms. West felt anger rise, but kept her face steady.
“Who is Persie with when this happens?”
“Astrid. Sometimes Maelle.”
“Anyone else?”
“People laugh.”
That answer was worse.
Principal Ward asked whether Ottie’s parents should be called. Ottie
stiffened.
“My mom will think she should have noticed.”
“That isn’t your job to protect her from,” Ms. Shaw said gently.
Ottie looked uncertain.
The office contacted Eleanor Blythe, Ottie’s mother, who said she would
come immediately. While they waited, Ms. West examined the desk more
closely. Beneath the fresh black marker were faint traces of older
writing that had been scrubbed away.
This had happened before.
Then she noticed something else.
A corner of folded paper protruded from Ottie’s workbook.
Ms. West asked permission before removing it.
The paper contained a list written in purple ink.
MONDAY — DON’T SIT WITH HER. TUESDAY — TAKE HER LUNCH. WEDNESDAY — GHOST
DAY. THURSDAY — MAKE HER CRY. FRIDAY — SURPRISE.
Friday was today.
At the bottom was a small hand-drawn crown—the same crown Persie doodled
on nearly every assignment.
Ottie stared at the page.
“I’ve never seen that before.”
Ms. West believed her.
From the hallway came hurried footsteps as Eleanor Blythe arrived.
But before Ms. West could show her the note, Maelle appeared at the
classroom doorway.
Her face was wet with tears.
“I need to tell you something,” she said.
May you like
Then she looked at Ottie.
“And Persie can’t know I told.”