Chapter 3 - Maelle’s Half-Truth

Maelle sat in the counselor’s office with both hands wrapped around a
paper cup of water. Ottie remained with her mother in another room.
Ms. West and Ms. Shaw sat across from Maelle, while Principal Ward
listened from near the door.
“Start with the mouse,” Ms. Shaw said.
Maelle’s fingers tightened.
“Persie brought it.”
“From where?”
“Her cousin has pet mice. She put one in a carrier this morning.”
“Did you know what she planned to do?”
Maelle nodded.
“Did you help?”
A long pause. “I held Ottie’s backpack while Persie put it in.”
Ms. West felt her stomach drop.
“And the restroom?”
Maelle began crying. “I didn’t spit on her.”
“You said, ‘Let’s give her something to remember us by,’” Ms. West said.
Maelle looked shocked.
Ottie had remembered the exact words.
“I said it because Persie was staring at me. She’d been saying I was
getting soft.”
“That does not make what happened acceptable.”
“I know.”
For the first time, Maelle looked directly at Ms. West. “But you don’t
understand Persie.”
“Help us understand.”
Maelle told them about a private group chat called The Court. Persie had
created it at the beginning of the school year. At first it contained
jokes, rankings, and complaints about teachers. Then Persie began
assigning “tests.” Ignore someone for a day. Hide a pencil case. Spread
an embarrassing rumor. Anyone who refused became the next target.
“Why Ottie?” Principal Ward asked.
Maelle wiped her nose. “Because she told Ms. West that Persie copied
answers on a math quiz.”
Ms. West remembered. Ottie had not actually accused Persie; she had
quietly mentioned seeing Persie look at another paper when Ms. West
asked the class whether anyone had noticed irregularities. The matter
had been handled privately. Persie had received a zero.
“That was in October,” Ms. West said.
Maelle nodded.
Four months.
“What else happened?” Ms. Shaw asked.
Maelle stared into the water.
“Her lunch got thrown away twice. Her scarf went missing. Astrid poured
water on her chair. Persie wrote things on her desk. They made fake
invitations to a skating party and told Ottie everyone was going.”
“Was there a party?”
“No.”
Ms. West closed her eyes for a moment.
Maelle continued. “Ottie waited outside the rink. I saw the picture
Persie posted.”
“What picture?”
Maelle stopped.
Principal Ward leaned forward. “Maelle?”
“I shouldn’t have said that.”
Ms. Shaw spoke gently. “If there is evidence, we need to preserve it.”
Maelle’s fear became visible. “My phone.”
The school collected Maelle’s phone with her parent’s consent after
calling her mother. Maelle unlocked the group chat herself.
Hundreds of messages appeared.
Some were childish. Some were cruel. Some were chilling because of how
ordinary they sounded.
Ms. West scrolled only enough to confirm the pattern before handing the
phone to Principal Ward for formal preservation under school policy.
Then Maelle said, “There’s another chat.”
“What do you mean?”
“The Court is the one everyone sees. Persie has another one with
Astrid.”
“How do you know?”
“Because Astrid showed me once by accident.”
“What was it called?”
Maelle whispered the name.
“Erase Her.”
The room went silent.
Ms. West asked, “What was in it?”
Maelle looked toward the closed door behind which Ottie sat with her
mother.
“I only saw one message.”
“What did it say?”
Maelle’s voice trembled.
“By spring, she won’t be at Hawthorne anymore.”
May you like
And suddenly the mouse no longer looked like the end of the bullying.
It looked like part of a plan.