scribe

Chapter 16 - The Letter

Persie’s letter was four pages long.

Ottie read it once alone at the kitchen table while Eleanor sat nearby,

available but silent.

Persie did not ask for forgiveness.

She described the math quiz, Maelle, the group chat, the scarf pin, the

fake skating invitation, the restroom, the mouse, and the planned theft

accusation.

She wrote:

I wanted you to feel like nobody would believe you. I think I did that

because I was afraid people would stop believing me if they saw I was

scared.

Ottie paused.

Then continued.

The sentence that hurt most was not about the mouse.

It was about the skating rink.

I watched you wait from across the parking lot. I knew after five

minutes you understood nobody was coming. I stayed anyway because Astrid

was laughing and I wanted to be the person laughing, not the person

being laughed at.

Ottie folded the page.

“I hate her.”

Eleanor nodded.

“I hate that she knows exactly what she did.”

“I understand.”

“It would be easier if she didn’t.”

Eleanor did not tell her hatred was unhealthy. She did not hurry her

toward forgiveness.

Ottie returned to the letter.

The final paragraph read:

My therapist says apologies are supposed to name what you did and not

ask the other person to fix your feelings. So I am sorry. You do not

have to answer. You do not have to forgive me. I am going to work on

becoming someone who would not do this again even if you never know

whether I changed.

Ottie finished.

Then she cried.

Not the silent crying from the restroom.

This was loud, furious grief.

“I was her punishment for being scared,” she said.

Eleanor held her only after Ottie leaned toward her.

The next therapy session, Ottie brought the letter.

“Do you believe her?” Dr. Morris asked.

“Some of it.”

“Which part?”

“That she was scared.”

“And the apology?”

“I believe she’s sorry now.”

“Does that change what happened?”

“No.”

“Does it require anything from you?”

Ottie thought.

“No.”

That answer gave her unexpected relief.

At Hawthorne, spring parent conferences approached. Ms. West showed

Eleanor Ottie’s academic work. Her grades had recovered. More

importantly, she participated again.

“She argued with me about a reading question yesterday,” Ms. West said.

Eleanor smiled. “Good.”

“It was.”

Ottie waited in the hall and heard them laughing.

For a second, old fear returned.

Are they laughing about me?

She stepped toward the doorway.

“What’s funny?”

Eleanor answered, “Ms. West says you told her the author’s answer key

was wrong.”

“It was.”

Ms. West raised both hands. “And she had evidence.”

Ottie smiled.

Evidence.

The word had once belonged to adults collecting photographs of her

humiliation.

Now it belonged to her defending an interpretation of a story.

That night, she put Persie’s letter back in the wooden box.

Not beside the broken charm.

Under it.

The next morning at school, she found another note on her desk.

This one had a name.

Theo.

I’m sorry I laughed in October. I was scared. That doesn’t make it okay.

You don’t have to answer.

Ottie read it.

She did not tear it up.

She wrote beneath his message:

Next time, don’t laugh.

Then she handed it back.

Theo read her answer and nodded.

May you like

“Next time, I won’t.”

For the first time, Ottie believed someone might mean it.

Related Stories

Other posts