scribe

Chapter 4 - What Eleanor Didn’t See

Eleanor Blythe had spent the drive to Hawthorne Academy blaming herself.

She blamed herself for Ottie’s exhaustion, which she had attributed to

winter and homework. She blamed herself for the missing scarf, which

Ottie claimed she had lost. She blamed herself for the untouched lunches

that came home because Ottie said cafeteria food smelled better.

When Ottie entered the conference room, Eleanor crossed the space and

stopped just short of grabbing her.

“Can I hug you?”

Ottie nodded.

Only then did Eleanor wrap her arms around her daughter.

Ottie felt painfully small.

“I’m sorry,” Eleanor whispered.

Ottie immediately answered, “It’s okay.”

Eleanor pulled back. “No. You don’t have to make me feel better.”

Ms. Shaw watched the exchange carefully.

Principal Ward explained what they knew. The mouse. The desk. The

restroom. The group chat. She did not yet mention Erase Her because the

school had not confirmed its contents.

Eleanor’s face changed as each detail landed.

“Four months?”

Ottie stared at her knees.

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

Ms. Shaw intervened. “That question can sound like blame even when it

comes from love.”

Eleanor shut her eyes. “You’re right.”

Ottie whispered, “Because you were happy.”

“What?”

“You said this school was finally working.”

Eleanor understood.

The previous year had been difficult after Ottie’s father, Graham, moved

to Seattle for work and the marriage ended. Hawthorne had been Eleanor’s

attempt to create stability. Ottie had heard her mother tell relatives

how relieved she was that her daughter had “found her place.”

Ottie had decided to preserve that relief.

“I thought if I could just be quieter,” Ottie said, “they’d get bored.”

Eleanor covered her mouth.

Ms. West sat across from them. “Ottie, none of this happened because you

failed to be quiet enough.”

Ottie looked at her teacher.

“Persie said teachers always believe her.”

That sentence struck a nerve.

“Why would she say that?”

Ottie hesitated. “Because her mom is on the school board.”

Principal Ward’s posture stiffened.

Persie’s mother, Celeste Vale, was indeed a trustee and major donor.

That fact did not determine disciplinary outcomes, but a ten-year-old

might easily believe it did.

Ottie reached into her coat pocket.

“There’s something else.”

She produced a folded envelope.

Inside were three anonymous notes collected over several weeks.

SNITCH. GHOSTS DON’T GET INVITED. KEEP TALKING AND YOUR MOM WILL HAVE TO

FIND ANOTHER SCHOOL.

Eleanor looked at Principal Ward. “Was my daughter threatened with

expulsion?”

“No.”

“Did anyone at this school tell Persie she could make that happen?”

“Absolutely not.”

Ottie spoke softly. “She said her mother could.”

Principal Ward’s face hardened. “That is not true.”

But Eleanor was no longer interested in reassurance. “I want everything

preserved. Every message, every camera recording that still exists,

every report.”

“You’ll receive documentation consistent with student privacy rules.”

“And Ottie does not return to a classroom with those girls tomorrow.”

“Agreed.”

Outside the conference room, a secretary knocked and handed Principal

Ward a printed email.

Ward read it once.

Then again.

“What is it?” Ms. West asked.

Ward looked toward Ottie.

“It’s from Celeste Vale.”

Eleanor’s jaw tightened.

“What does she want?”

Principal Ward folded the email.

“She says Persie came home distressed and claims Ottie has been

harassing her for months.”

May you like

Ottie’s face drained of color.

And Eleanor realized the next battle had already begun.

Related Stories

Other posts