Chapter 13 - The Trophy Box

Ottie’s question led Principal Ward back to evidence already collected.
During the investigation, Persie’s parents had voluntarily provided
relevant school items after learning about the group chats. Among them
was a pencil case containing the charm Maelle later admitted taking. But
Maelle’s comment about “trophies” prompted Celeste to search Persie’s
desk at home with her daughter present.
They found a small lavender box.
Inside were objects that did not belong to Persie.
Ottie’s missing scarf pin. Lucy’s friendship bracelet. Theo’s novelty
eraser. A hair clip belonging to another girl. Several folded notes.
Celeste called Principal Ward herself.
Persie sat on her bed while her mother spoke.
“Why did you keep these?”
Persie shrugged.
“Don’t shrug.”
“They were just things.”
“Then why hide them?”
Persie’s eyes hardened. “Because you’d make a big deal.”
Celeste sat opposite her. “Did you steal all of them?”
“Some.”
“Which?”
Persie would not answer.
The school contacted families and returned identified property after
documenting it. The discovery widened the behavioral concern but did not
become a new sensational case. Most objects were inexpensive. Their
importance was psychological.
Persie had collected proof that she could take something and get away
with it.
When Eleanor told Ottie about the scarf pin, Ottie touched the collar of
her coat.
“I thought I lost everything.”
“You didn’t.”
“I started thinking I was stupid.”
Eleanor’s eyes filled.
Ottie continued, “Persie would say, ‘Again? You lose everything.’”
That was the deeper cruelty.
Not taking the object.
Making Ottie distrust herself.
Dr. Morris helped her name it.
“When someone repeatedly changes your environment and then tells you
your memory is the problem, you can begin doubting your own perception.”
Ottie frowned. “So she was trying to make me feel crazy?”
“She may not have used that word in her head. But the effect was that
you stopped trusting what you knew.”
Ottie thought about the mouse.
It had moved.
She had known something was wrong.
For once, everyone else saw it too.
That realization changed the memory slightly.
The mouse was still frightening, but it had also broken the secrecy.
At school, Ms. West asked whether Ottie wanted the old vandalized desk
returned after the investigation no longer needed it.
“No.”
“Would you like it disposed of?”
Ottie thought.
“Can the marker be removed?”
“Probably sanded and refinished.”
“Then do that.”
Ms. West smiled slightly. “Why?”
“Because it’s a desk.”
The answer pleased her.
Not a shrine.
Not a symbol.
A desk.
Meanwhile, Persie’s therapy sessions were becoming harder. She had
admitted the mouse, the notes, the group chat, and the objects. But one
question remained unanswered.
Why had Friday been called “the best one”?
The mouse seemed to fit.
Yet a recovered message from Thursday night suggested otherwise.
Astrid had written:
ARE YOU SURE ABOUT THE SECOND PART?
Persie replied:
SHE’LL NEVER COME BACK AFTER THAT.
No one had found evidence of a second part.
Until the school custodian opened a rarely used supply cabinet behind
Ms. West’s classroom.
On the top shelf sat a plastic bag.
Inside was Ottie’s missing winter coat.
And taped to the coat was a handwritten sign.
THIEF.
May you like
The mouse had not been intended as the final prank.
It had been intended as the distraction.