scribe

Chapter 5

The Box He Never Hid

Theron came home at seven-thirty.

Eirwen was sitting at the dining table with the placement folder in front of her.

He stopped when he saw it.

"You opened the fire box."

"You gave me the code."

"I know."

There was no accusation in his voice.

He set his keys down and removed his coat. For a few moments they moved around each other with the unnatural politeness of strangers occupying the same house.

Finally Eirwen said, "I met Rowan today."

Theron's shoulders tightened, but he only nodded.

"He says he thought my mother miscarried."

"All right."

"His parents may have known more."

Another nod.

Eirwen hated how careful he was being.

"You can ask questions."

"I have questions. I'm trying to decide which ones belong to me."

That sounded so much like him that it hurt.

Eirwen pushed the folder toward the empty chair across from her.

"Why didn't you ever show me this?"

Theron sat.

"I would have. You never asked."

"That's too easy."

"No. It's just true. You knew you were adopted. You knew the basic story. When you were twelve, I told you the records were yours whenever you wanted them. You said you didn't care. At sixteen, I asked if you wanted to register with the state reunion program. You told me not to make adoption your whole personality."

Eirwen remembered saying it and winced.

"I was awful at sixteen."

"You were sixteen."

"Why didn't you push?"

"Because your history belongs to you."

She looked at the photocopy of Celia's note.

"Did you ever try to find her after the adoption?"

"Yes."

Theron folded his hands on the table.

"For years. Quietly. I hired an investigator twice. The first time when you were five. The second when you were eleven. I didn't tell you because both searches went nowhere and I didn't want to hand a child hope that had nowhere to land."

"You hired someone?"

"Yes."

"Why isn't that in here?"

"Different folder. Office cabinet."

Eirwen closed her eyes.

Another assumption fell apart.

"Rowan has letters Celia sent to his parents' house. They were returned."

Theron's expression sharpened with interest, not jealousy.

"What dates?"

She told him.

He stood and went to his office. When he returned, he carried a thicker binder.

"The first investigator found one temporary address for Celia three months after you were born. By the time he got there, she was gone. The landlord said she received mail under her own name for about six weeks."

Eirwen scanned the report.

The dates overlapped with Rowan's returned letters.

"She was trying to reach him," Eirwen whispered.

"Looks that way."

Theron did not sound threatened by the possibility.

That made Eirwen feel worse about the night before.

"Why did you tell me he walked away?"

Theron leaned back.

"Because I was hurt and I turned an assumption into a weapon."

The bluntness startled her.

"I spent twenty years thinking if a man knew you existed and never came looking, he had chosen not to. I had no evidence that he knew. I should not have said it."

Eirwen picked at the edge of the folder.

"I shouldn't have said what I said either."

Theron looked at her.

The apology was sitting there between them, still incomplete.

"I don't know how to fix it," she admitted.

"Neither do I."

"Are you going to forgive me?"

Theron took a long breath.

"Eventually, I think."

The answer hurt more than an immediate yes, but she knew it was more honest.

"I love you," he added. "Those aren't the same question."

Eirwen's eyes filled.

"I love you too."

Theron nodded, looking down for a moment.

"That helps."

They sat in silence.

After a while, Eirwen asked, "Do you want to know him?"

Theron's expression shifted.

"Rowan?"

"Yes."

"Not yet."

"Because you're angry?"

"Partly. Mostly because if I meet him right now, I will spend the entire conversation measuring myself against him. That wouldn't be fair to anyone."

Eirwen let out a small, shaky laugh.

"You admit that?"

"I am forty-six. I have had time to identify some of my less attractive habits."

For the first time since the argument, something in the room loosened.

Not healed.

Loosened.

Theron gathered the papers carefully and pushed the binder toward her.

"Take all of it to your room if you want. Make copies. Ask questions. Meet Rowan."

Eirwen stared at him.

"You're not going to tell me not to?"

"No."

"Even after what I said?"

Theron's eyes held hers.

"Especially after what you said. If you stay away from him because you're afraid of hurting me, then every answer you don't get becomes something you can resent me for later. I won't build our relationship on that."

Eirwen looked down at the records.

The folder was not a cage.

It was a door he had left unlocked years ago.

She had simply never tried the handle.

That night, Eirwen carried both folders upstairs but did not read them immediately.

Mae called around eleven.

"Did he kick you out?" she asked without greeting.

"No."

"Did he tell you not to see Rowan?"

"No."

"Did he make a speech about everything he sacrificed?"

Eirwen looked toward the closed bedroom door.

"Sort of the opposite."

She told Mae what Theron had said about not building their relationship on resentment.

Mae was quiet for a moment.

"That sounds like him."

"Why does everyone know my father better than I do?"

"Because you're his kid. Kids are terrible witnesses to their parents having interior lives."

The sentence irritated Eirwen because it sounded true.

She opened the thicker investigator binder. Theron had kept receipts, correspondence, and notes from every search. One yellowed invoice showed that the first investigator had cost nearly a month's rent. Another page contained Theron's handwritten questions before a meeting with the caseworker:

If mother returns, what rights does she have?

If father identified, what happens to placement?

Can I remain contact if child is reunified?

How do I make transition least damaging for Eirwen?

Eirwen stopped on the third question.

Can I remain contact if child is reunified?

At twenty-seven, Theron had been preparing for the possibility that loving her might end with handing her to someone else and asking permission to remain in her life.

He had not written, How do I keep her?

He had written, How do I make transition least damaging for Eirwen?

Eirwen pressed the page flat with both palms.

Mae's voice came through the phone. "You still there?"

"Yeah."

"What did you find?"

Eirwen read the questions aloud.

Mae exhaled slowly.

"That doesn't mean he was perfect."

"I know."

"And you still get to know Rowan."

"I know."

"Good. Because guilt can make you swing from one unfair story to another."

Eirwen leaned against the headboard.

"What do you mean?"

"First Theron was the obstacle and Rowan was the truth. Now you're at risk of making Theron a saint and yourself the villain. Neither story helps."

Eirwen looked at the old paperwork.

Mae continued, "You said something cruel. Apologize. Learn. But don't spend the next ten years performing gratitude because you're afraid being curious makes you disloyal."

Eirwen closed the binder.

"When did you become unbearable?"

"When you gave me enough context to be right."

After they hung up, Eirwen placed Celia's note beside Theron's court statement.

May you like

Two pages. Two adults. Two incomplete decisions that had shaped her life before she could speak.

For the first time, she understood that finding the truth would require resisting not only other people's stories about her, but also her own hunger for a simple one.

Related Stories

Other posts