scribe

Chapter 16

The Apology Between Two Fathers

Theron invited Rowan to lunch without telling Eirwen until after Rowan had accepted.

"You did what?" she asked.

"I asked him to eat food in a public place. It is a common social ritual."

"Why?"

Theron shrugged too casually.

"Because I owe him an apology face-to-face."

"You already emailed."

"Email is excellent for scheduling contractors and avoiding meetings. It is not always enough for the important things."

Eirwen studied him.

"Are you going to fight?"

Theron looked offended. "We are middle-aged men, not rival elk."

"That was not a no."

"No, Eirwen. We are not going to fight."

They met at a diner halfway between their offices.

For the first several minutes, they discussed traffic, coffee, and an upcoming bridge restoration project Rowan's firm had consulted on. Both men were grateful for a topic that did not involve twenty years of missed fatherhood.

Finally Theron set down his cup.

"I wanted to say this in person. I was wrong when I told Eirwen you walked away from her."

Rowan's eyes lowered.

"You already apologized."

"I know. I also want you to understand why I said it. Not as an excuse."

Rowan nodded.

Theron continued. "For years, I imagined an unnamed man who knew about a baby and never came. I got angry at that person because anger was easier than admitting I was afraid he might appear one day and matter more than I did."

Rowan looked up.

"You were afraid of me before you knew my name?"

"Not you. The idea of you."

"I understand that more than I'd like to."

Theron gave a humorless smile.

"When Eirwen told me she had found her biological father, every ugly fear I thought I'd outgrown showed up at once. Then she said what she said. I wanted to hurt the person I imagined had hurt her, so I used you to hurt her back."

Rowan was quiet.

"Thank you for saying that."

"I'm not asking you to forgive it."

"I do."

Theron frowned slightly.

"That was fast."

"Because I have said worse things in fear."

Rowan turned his water glass in his hands.

"I owe you something too. I made you the obstacle in my head because I needed somebody to blame who was still alive and reachable. My parents lied. Celia lied. I stopped looking. Time did the rest. Then I found Eirwen and saw your surname on everything. It was convenient to imagine you had filled the space where I should have been."

Theron's expression tightened.

"I didn't fill your space."

"I know that now."

"I filled mine."

Rowan nodded.

The server brought their food. Neither man touched it immediately.

"She told me about the guest room," Theron said.

Rowan closed his eyes. "Of course she did."

"Dresser organizer was ambitious."

"Finn already mocked me sufficiently."

Theron almost smiled.

Rowan leaned forward.

"Can I ask you something difficult?"

"You seem committed to the theme."

"Do you think of me as her father?"

Theron considered the question seriously.

"Biologically? Obviously. Historically? You were absent, mostly through no fault of your own at first. Relationally? That's up to the two of you."

"And emotionally?"

Theron took a breath.

"Emotionally, I don't like the word belonging to anyone else."

Rowan nodded.

"Thank you for not pretending."

"Pretending would make me resent you faster."

Rowan finally picked up his fork.

"I don't want to take anything from you."

Theron looked at him for a long moment.

"You can't take twenty years."

"No."

"And I can't take biology, Celia, Finn, your family history, or whatever relationship you and Eirwen build next."

"No."

"So maybe we stop talking like she is acreage with disputed boundaries."

Rowan laughed.

"Agreed."

They ate.

The conversation remained uncomfortable, but not hostile. Rowan asked what Eirwen had been like as a child. Theron told him about the year she refused to wear any color except purple, the disastrous recorder concert, and the time she tried to rescue a squirrel by bringing it into the house in a laundry basket.

"She still does that thing where she decides a problem is hers before checking whether it wants help," Rowan said.

Theron smiled. "Yes."

They both recognized her.

That mattered.

Before leaving, Rowan said, "Father's Day is next month."

Theron's expression became guarded.

"It is."

"I am not asking you to negotiate custody of a holiday."

"Good."

"I'm telling you because I don't know what to do with it."

Theron put on his coat.

"Ask her."

"What if I don't like the answer?"

"Then practice being her father by surviving an answer you didn't choose."

Rowan stood very still.

Then he nodded.

"That sounded annoyingly wise."

"I have twenty years of material."

May you like

For once, the joke did not feel like competition.

It felt like shared responsibility.

Related Stories

Other posts