scribe

Chapter 17

The First Father's Day With Two Fathers

Eirwen had never thought of Father's Day as complicated.

For nineteen years, it meant breakfast made badly on purpose, a card Theron pretended not to care about and saved anyway, and some activity that usually ended with both of them complaining about crowds.

This year, her phone began filling with ads two weeks early.

Gifts for Dad.

Celebrate the man who made you who you are.

One day. One father. One uncomplicated noun.

Rowan asked first.

They were having coffee when he said, carefully, "I know Father's Day is coming."

Eirwen's shoulders tensed.

He raised a hand. "I'm not claiming it. I'm asking whether you want to do anything."

"I already have plans with Theron."

Rowan's face changed before he could control it.

"Okay."

Eirwen heard disappointment and immediately became defensive.

"We've done the same thing every year since I was five."

"I said okay."

"Your face didn't."

"My face is allowed to have feelings."

That stopped her.

She had accused Theron of the same thing in reverse: treating discomfort as control before he actually acted on it.

"You're right," she said. "Sorry."

Rowan nodded.

"Could we have dinner that night?"

Eirwen thought about it.

"Yes."

Relief softened him.

"I'd like that."

Sunday arrived bright and warm.

Eirwen found Theron in the garage at eight in the morning, already pretending not to be waiting.

She held up a paper bag.

"Breakfast."

"If that's the same place as last year, they forgot the hot sauce twice."

"Happy Father's Day to you too."

He smiled.

They ate on the back porch, then drove to the small maritime museum they had visited every June since Eirwen was a child. At noon, she gave him a card.

Theron opened it slowly.

Inside she had written:

I used to think "real" was a category I didn't have to define. I know better now. You are my father because you raised me, because you chose me, because I chose you back, and because twenty years of ordinary love is not made less true by blood I didn't know about. I am sorry I used that word to make you feel temporary.

Happy Father's Day, Dad.

Theron read it twice.

Then a third time.

"You didn't have to write an essay," he said, voice rough.

"You raised me. You knew I was dramatic."

He folded the card carefully.

"Thank you."

"Do you forgive me?"

Theron looked out at the harbor.

For weeks, he had resisted giving her the answer simply because she wanted relief.

Now he nodded.

"Yes."

Eirwen's breath caught.

"Completely?"

"There will be moments I remember it and hurt again. Forgiveness is not amnesia. But yes. I forgive you."

She hugged him.

That evening, she met Rowan at a quiet Italian restaurant.

He had dressed too formally. There was a small gift bag beside his chair.

"You're giving me something?" Eirwen asked.

"It is not a Father's Day gift to myself, if that's what you're thinking."

Inside was a fountain pen.

"You said you wanted to read Celia's journals and maybe write down questions. I thought..."

Eirwen smiled.

"Thank you."

Dinner was good until the waiter, noticing their resemblance, said, "Father-daughter dinner?"

Rowan looked at Eirwen before answering.

The pause mattered.

"We're getting to know each other," he said.

The waiter smiled vaguely and moved on.

Eirwen relaxed.

Later Rowan asked, "What did you and Theron do?"

She told him.

He listened.

When she mentioned the card, his gaze dropped briefly to the table.

"I envy him," he admitted.

Eirwen appreciated the honesty.

"I know."

"I also think he earned every line you wrote."

She looked up.

Rowan continued. "Both can be true."

Celia's sentence echoed in Eirwen's mind: I loved you and still left you. Both things are true.

Maybe adulthood was mostly learning how many truths could survive beside one another.

After dinner, Rowan walked her to her car.

"Thank you for tonight."

"You're welcome."

He hesitated.

"Can I tell you something without making it your responsibility?"

"Try."

"Today hurt."

Eirwen waited.

"Not because you did anything wrong," Rowan added. "Because I spent the day imagining twenty Father's Days I didn't know I was missing."

"I'm sorry."

"You don't have to be."

"I can still be."

He smiled faintly.

"Fair."

Eirwen hugged him.

It was the first time she initiated it.

Rowan held her carefully, not too tight.

When she drove home, Theron's porch light was on.

He did not ask whether dinner with Rowan had been good in a tone that demanded the answer be no.

He simply asked, "How was it?"

"Good. Sad. Good."

Theron nodded.

"Sounds about right."

Eirwen went upstairs.

On her desk, she placed Rowan's fountain pen beside the card draft she had written for Theron.

Two fathers.

Two histories.

One life that did not need to be divided into equal halves to be whole.

After Eirwen left the restaurant on Father's Day, Rowan stayed at the table another twenty minutes.

He had told her the day hurt without making the hurt a demand. He was proud of that. He was also miserable.

He called Finn.

"How was your first complicated Father's Day?" Finn asked.

"You knew?"

"Dad, you have been emotionally pacing for a week."

Rowan looked at the empty chair across from him.

"She spent the day with Theron. Dinner with me."

"Seems fair."

"I know."

"But?"

"I wanted the whole day."

Finn was quiet.

"Can I say something mean?"

"Apparently everyone can now."

"You already got my whole childhood."

Rowan frowned.

Finn continued, "I don't mean that as blame. I mean maybe you're so focused on the years you missed with Eirwen that you're forgetting the years you did get with somebody."

The sentence landed hard.

Rowan closed his eyes.

"I'm sorry."

"Don't apologize to me because you have feelings. Just notice me too."

"I do notice you."

"Mostly. But you've been rearranging your whole emotional life around Eirwen. I like her. I love that she's my sister. I also don't want to become proof that you know how to be a father while you chase the daughter you didn't raise."

Rowan sat very still.

"That was not mean," he said.

"Give me time."

They spoke for another half hour.

The next weekend Rowan drove to Vermont and spent two days with Finn without mentioning Eirwen unless Finn did first.

When Eirwen learned about the trip, she felt an unexpected relief.

Rowan was not a father who had been frozen for twenty years waiting for her.

He had another child, another history, another set of mistakes and successes.

May you like

That made him less mythic.

It also made him more real.

Related Stories

Other posts