Chapter 11

What It Cost and What It Did Not
The question about Theron's life did not disappear simply because he had refused to answer it while Eirwen was feeling guilty.
A week later, she asked again.
This time they were driving to a hardware store because the upstairs bathroom faucet had begun leaking. It was the kind of errand that had always encouraged difficult conversations: no eye contact required, a fixed destination, and enough background noise to keep silence from becoming dramatic.
"I want to ask about something," Eirwen said.
Theron kept his eyes on the road.
"That sentence has never ended cheaply for me."
"I'm serious."
"So am I."
She almost smiled.
"When I asked what raising me cost you, you told me not to make it a ledger."
Theron's jaw shifted.
"I remember."
"I'm not trying to decide what I owe you. I want to understand you as a person, not just as Dad."
That changed him. Not dramatically. He simply became quieter.
"All right," he said after a while. "Ask."
"Did you give up things because of me?"
"Yes."
"Like what?"
Theron turned onto the main road.
"I was accepted into a graduate preservation program in Boston the year after you came to me. I didn't go."
Eirwen stared at him.
"You never told me that."
"There was no reason to."
"Why didn't you go?"
"Because your foster placement was still being reviewed every few months. Moving you across state lines would have complicated everything, and I wasn't willing to risk losing placement for a degree I could pursue later."
"Did you?"
"No. Work changed. Life changed."
Eirwen looked out the window.
"What else?"
"I sold my share in a lake cabin my father left Daniel and me."
"Daniel isn't your brother."
"Different Daniel. Cousin Daniel. Too many Daniels."
"Why did you sell it?"
"Legal fees. Childcare. I had stopped taking overtime because I needed to be home."
"How much?"
Theron glanced at her.
"No numbers."
"Why?"
"Because numbers turn sacrifice into an invoice."
She went quiet.
They drove another mile.
"Did you ever resent me?"
Theron answered too quickly. "No."
Eirwen looked at him.
He sighed.
"Fine. Yes. Sometimes. Not you, exactly. The situation. The exhaustion. The fact that everybody praised me for being noble while none of them volunteered to take a 2 a.m. feeding. I resented that. I resented judges making decisions about you based on files they read for ten minutes. I resented Celia for disappearing. I resented myself for not being more patient."
"But not me?"
"There were nights when you screamed for forty minutes because your socks felt wrong and I resented everybody within a five-mile radius."
Eirwen laughed.
"I still hate bad socks."
"I know."
They reached a red light.
Theron looked over.
"Listen to me. The fact that loving you required things from me does not make those things debts you owe. It means I was a parent. Biological parents give things up too. They just don't usually get asked to itemize it because nobody questions whether the role was real."
The last sentence landed softly.
Eirwen swallowed.
"I did question it."
"Yes."
"I'm sorry."
Theron looked back at the light.
"I know."
"That sounded different from 'I forgive you.'"
"Because it is."
The light turned green.
At the store, they spent fifteen minutes arguing over faucets. Theron wanted a durable brushed-nickel model. Eirwen wanted one that did not look "like it belonged in a municipal building."
They compromised.
On the way home, Eirwen asked, "Did you ever almost marry anyone?"
Theron nearly missed a turn.
"You said person, not full biography."
"That means yes."
"There was someone."
"Who?"
"Her name was Adrienne. You were seven."
Eirwen searched her memory.
"The woman who made lemon cookies?"
"Yes."
"I thought she moved away."
"She did."
"Because of me?"
Theron was silent long enough that her stomach tightened.
"Not because of you," he said. "Because we wanted different lives. She wanted to move to London for work. I couldn't take you out of the country while your adoption-related records were still tied up in a separate appeal about access. She asked if I would consider going later. I said maybe. Later became never. We ended things before resentment did it for us."
"Did you love her?"
"Yes."
Eirwen looked down at her hands.
"I'm sorry."
Theron gave her a tired smile.
"There you go making it a ledger again."
"How am I supposed to hear all this and not feel guilty?"
"By remembering I chose."
"But I said I never asked you to."
"And you were right."
The answer surprised her.
"That doesn't make what I said okay," she replied.
"No. But the problem wasn't the fact. The problem was the way you used it. You said 'you chose to' as if choice made parenthood less meaningful. I think choice is the part I'm proudest of."
Eirwen blinked hard.
They pulled into the driveway.
Theron switched off the engine but did not immediately get out.
"You don't have to repay me by choosing me over Rowan," he said. "You repay nothing. If you want to honor what I did, build your own life carefully enough that you know which sacrifices are yours to make and which ones somebody else is guilting you into."
Eirwen nodded.
That evening, she wrote the sentence in the notes app on her phone.
Choice does not make love less real.
She did not yet know that she would need it again soon.
A few days after the hardware-store conversation, Eirwen called Daniel - the friend Daniel, not cousin Daniel - and asked him about Theron's first years as a parent.
"Am I being interviewed under oath?" Daniel asked.
"Maybe."
"Then I want counsel."
"Daniel."
He laughed.
"What do you want to know?"
"Was he miserable?"
The question silenced him.
"No," Daniel said finally. "He was terrified. Different thing."
"Did he complain about me?"
"Constantly."
Eirwen's heart sank.
Daniel continued, "You had reflux. You slept in ninety-minute shifts. You once vomited into his only clean work shirt while he was leaving for a job interview. Complaining is not rejection."
"Did he ever say he regretted taking me?"
"Never. He regretted being tired. He regretted not knowing what he was doing. He regretted one pediatrician, two daycare centers, and buying a stroller with wheels that squeaked. He never regretted you."
Eirwen sat on the edge of her bed.
"What about Adrienne?"
Daniel groaned. "He told you about Adrienne? Miracles continue."
"Did she leave because of me?"
"No. She left because London was her dream and Connecticut was his life. You were in the life. So was everything else."
"He said he couldn't move because of my records."
"That was part of it. But don't flatten two adults' breakup into a sacrifice story. Adrienne would hate that."
Eirwen smiled faintly.
"Everyone keeps telling me not to make myself the center of other people's decisions."
"Because you're very talented at it."
"I called for comfort."
"Wrong Daniel."
Before they hung up, Daniel said, "For what it's worth, the hardest thing for Theron wasn't money or dating or school."
Eirwen waited.
"It was uncertainty. Until the adoption was final, he never knew whether some judge would decide you belonged somewhere else. He used to keep a small bag packed for you because the caseworker said placements could change quickly."
Eirwen felt cold.
"A bag?"
"Diapers. Clothes. Your stuffed rabbit. He hated that bag. After the decree, he unpacked it and cried on my kitchen floor."
Eirwen closed her eyes.
The argument returned with brutal clarity.
You're not my real father.
Theron had once kept a bag packed because the world had taught him that fatherhood could be temporary.
Twenty years later, she had put the same fear back in his hands with one sentence.
May you like
Knowing that did not mean she owed him her future.
It did mean she understood the wound more accurately.