scribe

Chapter 29

The Question From a Fifteen-Year-Old Girl

The question came during a workshop at Eirwen's nonprofit.

She was leading a small group of teenagers through an exercise about personal narratives: how to tell a story about yourself without letting the worst thing that happened become the entire plot.

One girl named Shay had been in foster care for four years and had recently moved in with an aunt.

On the worksheet, a prompt read: Who is family to you?

Shay stared at it for a long time.

Then she raised her hand.

"Can you have two dads?"

Eirwen smiled cautiously.

"Sure. Lots of people do."

"No, I mean like one real dad and one foster dad."

The word real moved through Eirwen like an echo from another room.

For one moment she was twenty again in Theron's living room, angry enough to turn biology into a blade.

She did not give Shay the answer she had learned for herself as if it were universal.

"What does real mean to you?" Eirwen asked.

Shay shrugged.

"Like the one you're actually related to."

"Biologically?"

"Yeah."

"Then biological dad is a precise phrase."

Shay frowned.

"But my foster dad is the one who comes to everything."

"Then maybe you need another precise phrase for him too. Or maybe just Dad, if that's what you both want."

"People ask which one is my real dad."

Eirwen sat on the edge of the table.

"People like simple categories. Families don't always cooperate."

Shay looked unconvinced.

"What do you call yours?"

Eirwen had mentioned being adopted earlier in the workshop, so the question was fair.

"Theron is my dad. He raised me. Rowan is my biological father, and I have a relationship with him too. Both relationships are real. They are not identical."

"Does your biological father get mad you don't call him Dad?"

Eirwen thought of Rowan's guest room, Father's Day, the fundraiser introduction, and all the work that had followed.

"He used to feel hurt by it. Sometimes he probably still does. But feelings are not always instructions for other people."

Shay nodded slowly.

"My foster dad says I can call him whatever I want."

"Sounds like he's making room for you to decide."

"My real dad says that means he's trying to replace him."

Eirwen felt the familiar tug toward judgment.

She resisted it.

"I don't know enough about your family to tell you what either man is doing. But you are allowed to care about more than one person without proving loyalty by hurting somebody else."

Shay looked down at the worksheet.

Then she wrote something.

Eirwen did not ask what.

That evening, she called Theron.

"A teenager asked me which father was my real father today."

Theron was silent.

"What did you say?"

"That you're my dad and Rowan is my biological father."

"Okay."

"That's all?"

"Were you expecting me to send a trophy?"

"Maybe a small one."

Theron laughed.

Eirwen sat on her apartment floor beside a box of program materials.

"I realized something."

"Dangerous start."

"When I said you weren't my real father, I wasn't actually talking about reality. I was talking about hierarchy."

Theron went quiet.

"I meant biological was higher. More legitimate. More mine."

"Yes."

"I don't believe that anymore."

"I know."

"How?"

"Because you stopped acting like knowing Rowan required explaining me away."

Eirwen looked at the green ring on her hand.

"And you stopped acting like loving me gave you veto power over him."

"Mostly."

"Mostly."

A comfortable silence settled.

Then Theron said, "I have a question."

"What?"

"Are you going to be home next Saturday?"

"Why?"

"I'm coming down."

"You always come down Friday."

"This time Saturday. Project meeting."

The old anxiety stirred.

He heard her pause.

"I am telling you as soon as I know," he said.

Eirwen smiled.

"I noticed."

"Growth is humiliating."

"Tragic."

Before hanging up, Theron said, "I'm proud of you."

"For the workshop?"

"For not giving that girl your answer as if it had to be hers."

Eirwen blinked.

"How did you know I almost did?"

"Because you're my daughter."

The words were easy now.

Not possessive.

Not threatened.

A description of a relationship they both continued to choose.

After the call, Eirwen found the original workshop worksheet she had filled out during training months earlier.

Who is family to you?

At the time she had written one name.

THERON.

Now she added:

ROWAN. FINN. MARA. MAE. DANIEL. BEATRICE, MAYBE.

She laughed at the last word.

May you like

Then she left Theron's name where it had always been.

First did not have to mean only.

Related Stories

Other posts