Chapter 2 - THE EASY ONE

The next morning, Maeve found the pieces of the vase spread across newspaper on the dining table.
Evelyn had matched most of them into a rough circle. A tube of ceramic glue sat nearby, unopened.
"Can it be fixed?" Maeve asked.
"Maybe," Evelyn said. "Not perfectly."
Maeve touched no pieces. "Will you keep it if the cracks show?"
Evelyn looked at her. "Probably."
"Why?"
"Because I still know what it is."
Maeve nodded as if storing the sentence somewhere.
Walter entered carrying coffee. He paused when he saw her.
"Morning, sweetheart."
"Morning."
He put the mug down. "About yesterday -"
"I have spelling first. Mom's picking me up at three-thirty."
Walter stopped.
Evelyn glanced at him but said nothing.
Maeve packed an apple into her lunch bag and zipped it closed.
Walter tried again. "I want you to know I was wrong."
"You said that."
"I don't want you thinking I'd let you take blame for me."
Maeve's eyes lifted. "You did."
He went quiet.
She did not say it sharply. That made it harder to argue with.
"I mean going forward," he said.
Maeve considered that too. "Okay."
Her mother, Nia, arrived ten minutes later. Maeve kissed both grandparents goodbye and left without mentioning the vase again.
Nia noticed the silence in the car.
"Everything okay?"
"A vase broke."
"Anybody hurt?"
"No."
"Grandma upset?"
"At first."
Nia smiled faintly. "That house has survived worse."
Maeve watched telephone poles pass outside the window.
"Grandpa broke it."
"Oh."
"He asked me to say sorry first."
Nia's hand tightened on the steering wheel.
"For what?"
Maeve explained the whole thing in order. The mail. The elbow. The plan. Evelyn's accusation. Walter's delay.
Nia drove another block before speaking.
"Did Grandpa tell Grandma it was him?"
"After I asked if it was his turn."
Nia exhaled through her nose.
"He apologized."
"That matters."
"Grandma said he put it on a nine-year-old."
"She's right."
Maeve turned from the window. "Would you have done it?"
Nia glanced at her. "Asked you to take blame for me? No."
"Grandpa said he was trying to stop Grandma being angry."
"Adults are allowed to be uncomfortable with each other. You don't have to stand in the middle and make it easier."
Maeve looked back outside.
The sentence should have relieved her. Instead, it opened a drawer in her mind.
At Thanksgiving, when Uncle Darren had arrived an hour late, Grandpa had asked Maeve to run to the door and say everyone had only just sat down so Darren would not feel bad.
At Christmas, when Evelyn disliked the scarf Walter bought her, Walter had whispered, "Tell her you helped pick it. She won't complain if she thinks you chose it."
When Evelyn had argued with Nia about letting Maeve stay up late, Walter had told Maeve, "Just say you were tired anyway."
None of those moments had felt like lies at the time. They had felt like jobs.
Small jobs for the easy one.
That afternoon, after school, Maeve sat at the kitchen table doing fractions while Nia prepared dinner.
"Mom?"
"Mm-hmm?"
"What does it mean when people say I'm easy?"
Nia turned down the stove.
"Who says that?"
"Everybody. Grandma says I'm easy to take places. Grandpa says I'm easy because I listen. Ms. Decker says I'm easy to pair with anybody."
"Usually they mean you're flexible."
"Is that good?"
"It can be."
"Can it be bad?"
Nia pulled out the chair beside her.
"Yes. If people start expecting you to be flexible every time."
Maeve stared at the number line in her workbook.
"Like if someone breaks a vase?"
Nia was quiet.
"Like that," she said.
Maeve erased an answer she had already gotten right.
That evening Walter called.
Nia offered Maeve the phone.
Maeve looked at the screen, then at her mother.
"Do I have to answer?"
"No."
It was the first no Maeve had heard that felt like permission.
She let the phone ring until it stopped.
At school, Maeve noticed how often the word easy followed her.
Ms. Decker asked for volunteers to help clean paint cups after art. Before Maeve raised her hand, another student said, "Maeve will do it. She always does."
The class moved on before Maeve answered.
She stayed after and washed the cups anyway.
While drying the last one, Ms. Decker said, "Thank you for helping."
Maeve looked at the sink.
"Did I volunteer?"
Her teacher paused.
"I thought you did."
"I don't think I did."
Ms. Decker replayed the moment in her head.
"You're right. Tyler volunteered you. I should have asked."
Maeve nodded.
"Would you have helped if I had?"
Maeve thought about it.
"Probably."
"Probably isn't yes."
The phrase stayed with her through the afternoon.
At home she told Nia.
"I still washed them," Maeve said.
"Did you want to?"
"By then I thought I should."
Nia sat across from her at the table.
"People can get so used to someone being helpful that they stop noticing the difference between a favor and an assignment."
Maeve drew a circle around one of her spelling words.
"Is that what happened with Grandpa?"
"Partly."
"Then how do I know if I'm helping because I want to?"
Nia smiled sadly. "You practice noticing before you answer."
That evening Maeve stood in front of the bathroom mirror and tried saying three sentences aloud.
Let me think.
Not this time.
Can you ask me first?
May you like
They sounded impolite in her own voice.
She practiced them again until they sounded merely unfamiliar.