scribe

Chapter 16 - THE PHOTO ON THE MANTEL

Evelyn replaced the family photo on the mantel in September.

The old picture showed Walter, Evelyn, Nia, Darren and Maeve at Thanksgiving three years earlier.

The new one came from the summer reunion.

Everyone looked good except Walter, whose eyes were half closed.

"Absolutely not," he said.

Evelyn laughed. "You look human."

Maeve studied the photo.

She stood between Nia and Simone. Darren was at the far edge, one hand lifted as if he had been speaking when the shutter clicked.

"Why isn't the old one staying?" Maeve asked.

"No room," Evelyn said. "One frame."

Walter disappeared into the garage and returned with another frame.

"Problem solved."

Evelyn rolled her eyes.

Maeve watched him place both photographs side by side.

"You didn't have to fix it," she said.

Walter looked at her. "I wanted both."

"What if Grandma only wanted one?"

Walter paused.

Evelyn smiled. "Then we would discuss where the second one goes."

Walter moved the older photograph to the bookshelf.

"Compromise."

The exchange seemed ordinary.

That was why Maeve remembered it.

A few days later she had a disagreement with her best friend, Lacey.

Lacey had promised to save Maeve a seat at lunch but sat with two other girls instead. When Maeve arrived, there was no room.

After school Lacey said, "I thought you wouldn't care. You're chill about stuff."

Maeve hated the word immediately.

Chill.

Easy.

Mature.

Understanding.

Different costumes for the same expectation.

"I did care," Maeve said.

Lacey frowned. "Why didn't you say anything?"

"Because I didn't want to make lunch weird."

"It was already weird."

Maeve almost smiled.

They sat on a bench near the bus loop.

"I'm sorry," Lacey said. "I should've saved the seat."

Maeve looked at her.

"I'm still annoyed."

"Okay."

"You're not mad that I'm annoyed?"

"No. Why would I be?"

Maeve thought about how many family apologies had once required the injured person to immediately become cheerful.

"No reason."

That evening she told Walter about it.

"What did you say to your friend?"

"That I was still annoyed."

Walter smiled. "Good."

Maeve gave him a look.

"Right. No gold star."

He raised his hands.

"What did she say?"

"Okay."

Walter nodded thoughtfully.

"That's a useful word too."

"I used to say it when I didn't mean it."

"Me too."

"What did you mean?"

Walter sat back.

"Usually, Please stop being upset with me."

Maeve laughed.

"That's a lot of words for okay."

"Exactly."

They sat quietly.

The two family photos remained visible across the room.

Walter looked toward them.

"You know, I spent years thinking harmony meant everybody agreeing on one picture."

Maeve followed his gaze.

"Maybe you can have two."

"Maybe you can have twenty."

"Grandma won't let you put twenty frames on that mantel."

"Then some go on the bookshelf."

Maeve smiled.

She liked the idea more than she expected.

Not every memory had to replace the one before it.

Not every version had to win.

Sometimes making room was enough.

A few days after the lunch-seat argument, Lacey came over after school.

Nia put snacks on the table and disappeared into the laundry room, leaving the girls to work on a history project.

For twenty minutes everything was easy. Then Lacey reached for Maeve's new markers without asking.

Maeve's first instinct was to say nothing. They were only markers. Lacey was her friend. Correcting her would make the afternoon awkward.

Then Lacey uncapped the gold one.

"Can you ask first?" Maeve said.

Lacey looked surprised. "For markers?"

"For my stuff."

There was a small silence.

"Okay. Can I use the gold one?"

Maeve considered.

"Yes."

Lacey used it.

The awkwardness lasted eight seconds.

Maeve nearly laughed at herself.

Later she told Walter.

"I thought saying something would ruin the whole visit."

"Did it?"

"No."

"I spent half my life making decisions based on imaginary disasters too."

Maeve looked at him.

"Like Grandma being mad?"

"Exactly."

They stood in front of the two framed family photos.

Walter adjusted one by half an inch.

"Sometimes we make other people pay for a catastrophe that exists only in our heads."

Maeve thought about the seat at lunch, the markers, the vase.

"How do you know if the disaster is real?"

"You usually don't. You tell the truth anyway and find out."

Maeve did not love that answer.

But she trusted it more than the old one: keep everybody comfortable and nothing bad will happen.

Walter kept both family photos after the move. In the new house, the mantel was smaller, so one photograph went on a hallway table.

Maeve noticed which one.

"You put the old one out here."

"Your grandmother chose the reunion photo for the mantel."

"Are you upset?"

"A little. I like the old one better."

"Why didn't you argue?"

Walter smiled. "I did. Then we decided each of us could choose one place in the house for a favorite photo. This is mine."

Maeve looked at the hallway table.

Compromise, she realized, did not always mean splitting the difference. Sometimes it meant each person having a small territory of choice.

Lacey later apologized for taking the markers without asking, even though Maeve had not demanded one.

"My little brother does that to me and I hate it," she admitted.

Maeve smiled.

"Then you get it."

"I get it when it's my stuff. I forget when it's yours."

May you like

Maeve understood that sentence more than she wanted to.

People often recognized a rule fastest when it protected them.

Related Stories

Other posts