scribe

Chapter 18 - THE THREE QUESTIONS

Maeve invented three questions for herself.

Did they ask me?

Do I want to?

Is this mine?

She wrote them on an index card and kept it in her backpack.

The card became useful almost immediately.

At school, Ms. Decker asked if Maeve would help a new student organize her binder.

Did they ask me? Yes.

Do I want to? Yes.

Is this mine? For ten minutes, yes.

She helped.

At home, Nia asked Maeve to remind Walter about a doctor's appointment.

Did they ask me? Yes.

Do I want to? Not really.

Is this mine? No.

"Can you text him?"

Nia blinked, then laughed. "Yes. I absolutely can."

At her grandparents' house, Evelyn asked Maeve to set the table.

Yes. Yes. Yes.

She did it without resentment.

That was the surprising part.

Saying no more often made yes feel cleaner.

Walter noticed.

"You're helping more," he said one Sunday.

Maeve frowned. "I thought I was helping less."

"You're helping differently."

"How?"

"You don't look like you're waiting to see what else we'll add."

Maeve had never known adults could see that expression.

"I used to do that?"

"All the time."

She thought about the broom after the vase broke. How she had held it upright, ready for the next instruction.

"Why didn't you say anything?"

Walter looked ashamed.

"Because I liked having someone ready."

Maeve nodded.

The honesty hurt less than the excuses had.

Later that afternoon Darren arrived with a box of old family documents Walter had asked him to bring.

"Maeve, sweetheart, can you sort these by year?"

Maeve looked at the box.

Did they ask me? Yes.

Do I want to? No.

Is this mine? Definitely not.

"No, thank you."

Darren laughed. "No thank you? You're not declining broccoli."

Maeve opened her book.

"I don't want to sort them."

Darren looked at Walter.

Walter said, "Then I'll sort them."

"You've created a monster," Darren muttered.

Maeve looked up.

Walter's face hardened.

"Don't call her that because she said no."

Darren sighed. "It was a joke."

Maeve closed her book.

"Uncle Darren?"

"What?"

"When you say something and then call it a joke because someone doesn't like it, is it still a joke?"

Darren stared at her.

Walter covered his mouth with one hand.

Evelyn turned away, shoulders moving suspiciously.

Darren finally laughed for real.

"Okay, professor. Fair point."

Maeve reopened her book.

A few minutes later Darren sat at the table sorting papers himself.

"This is boring," he announced.

"Yes," Maeve said.

"You would've been faster."

"Probably."

"And you're just going to let me suffer?"

Maeve looked at her index card lying beside her bookmark.

"I think you'll survive."

Darren laughed again.

This time nobody had to repair the room afterward.

That night Maeve added a fourth question to the card.

If I say no, what actually happens?

She thought about the reunion. The message. The papers.

Usually, somebody else did the thing.

Usually, the world continued.

That realization felt almost unfair.

She had spent years believing her cooperation held everything together.

Often, it had only made other people less practiced at carrying their own weight.

The four questions spread beyond chores and messages.

At a birthday party, a group of girls wanted Maeve to hide another girl's shoes as a prank.

Did they ask me? Yes.

Do I want to? No.

Is this mine? No.

If I say no, what actually happens? They might call me boring.

Maeve said no.

They called her boring.

For ten minutes she regretted it.

Then the prank went badly. The birthday girl's mother found the shoes in a laundry basket and made everyone sit in the living room while she asked who had moved them.

Maeve watched three girls look at one another, waiting for somebody else to answer first.

The scene felt painfully familiar.

Finally one girl admitted it.

On the ride home Maeve told Nia.

"I almost helped because I didn't want them mad at me."

"That's normal."

"I hate when normal things are difficult."

Nia laughed. "Me too."

"Would it have been my fault if I helped?"

"Yes, partly. Being pressured explains a choice. It doesn't erase the choice."

Maeve stared out the window.

That was uncomfortable but important.

The questions were not magic instructions that made every decision pure. They were a pause.

After the pause, she still had to choose.

When they reached home, Maeve added a note to the index card:

A reason is not always an excuse.

The sentence reminded her of Walter.

Understanding why he had been afraid of Evelyn never changed who had held the broom.

Maeve replaced the battered index card at the end of the school year. The original had softened at the corners from being pulled out so often.

She copied the questions onto a new card, then hesitated.

Instead of throwing the old one away, she tucked it into her desk.

Not because the paper was important.

Because she wanted to remember needing it.

One day, she hoped, the questions would become automatic.

Until then, carrying them was not weakness.

It was practice.

The old index card eventually tore down the middle. Maeve taped it instead of replacing it again.

Walter saw the repair and smiled.

"Gold paint next?"

"Absolutely not."

May you like

She slid the card into her backpack.

Some things did not need to become symbols just because the family had learned to notice symbols everywhere.

Related Stories

Other posts