scribe

Chapter 19 - THE LETTER COREY NEVER FINISHED

Dr. Wynn gave Corey homework.

“Write the letter your father should have let you write.”

Corey hated the assignment before he started.

He sat at the dining-room table after Audra went to bed, legal pad in front of him, and stared at the first line.

I want to live with Dad because...

That was how Leonard had begun the letter thirty-one years earlier.

Corey crossed it out.

He tried again.

I like Dad's house because my room stays the same.

True.

I like Mom's apartment because she lets me sleep on the couch when she works late and comes home tired.

True.

Dad helps with homework.

True.

Mom makes grilled cheese in a frying pan because the toaster oven is broken.

True.

Mom is late sometimes.

True.

Dad gets angry when she is late.

True.

I don't like moving.

True.

I don't like when Dad says moving means Mom doesn't know how to make a home.

True.

I want things to stay the same.

True.

I want Mom.

True.

I want Dad.

True.

Corey stopped writing.

His eyes blurred.

The full letter was messy.

That was the point.

Children's loyalties were not legal briefs. They did not become cleaner because adults removed contradictions.

The next session, Dr. Wynn read the letter after Corey handed it over.

“What do you notice?” he asked.

Corey looked at the ceiling.

“My father wasn't lying.”

“No.”

“He picked the true parts that made one story.”

“Yes.”

“I thought lying was the line I wouldn't cross.”

Dr. Wynn waited.

Corey rubbed his hands together.

“I crossed something else.”

“What?”

“I treated context like it was optional.”

They sat with that.

Corey had expected therapy to produce explanations for why he behaved the way he did.

Instead it kept returning choices to him.

His father's behavior mattered.

His childhood mattered.

Fear mattered.

None of them held the phone in his hand.

That had been Corey.

Later that week, Denise came over to watch Audra while Corey attended a work dinner.

Audra asked Grandma Denise if Dad had ever lived with her after the divorce.

Denise paused halfway through slicing an orange.

“Did Dad tell you about that?”

“He said Grandpa made him write a letter.”

Denise nodded.

“He lived mostly with your grandpa for a while.”

“Did he stop seeing you?”

“No.”

“Did you miss him?”

“Every day.”

Audra thought about that.

“Was Grandpa bad?”

Denise set down the knife.

“He did some things that hurt me and your dad. He also loved your dad very much.”

Audra frowned.

“Both?”

“Both.”

“That's confusing.”

“Yes.”

Audra peeled a piece of orange skin from the cutting board.

“Dad loves me.”

“I know.”

“He still did the videos.”

“Yes.”

Audra looked relieved that Denise did not rush to make one fact erase the other.

“Mom loves me too.”

“I know.”

“She still was late.”

“Yes.”

Audra smiled faintly.

“You say yes a lot.”

“Sometimes children aren't asking us to fix the sentence. They're asking if we're brave enough to let it stay complicated.”

Audra considered that phrase.

“Did a therapist tell you that?”

Denise laughed so loudly she nearly dropped the orange.

“No, baby. Life charged me for that lesson.”

When Corey returned, Audra was asleep on the couch.

Denise helped him carry her upstairs.

At the bedroom door, she whispered, “She asked about the divorce.”

Corey's face tightened.

“What did you tell her?”

“The truth, age eight edition.”

He nodded.

Denise studied him.

“You look different.”

“Therapy is annoying.”

“Good therapy usually is.”

After she left, Corey checked on Audra.

The glow-in-the-dark stars were fading above her bed.

He went back downstairs and opened the letter to his childhood self.

At the bottom, he added one final line.

Nobody should have asked you to make one parent smaller so the other parent could feel chosen.

He stared at the sentence.

Then he thought of Audra's plea on the video.

Please keep it.

Don't delete everything.

Corey folded the letter and placed it in his desk.

For the first time, he did not feel like hiding it.

Corey did not show the childhood letter to Audra. He thought about it, then decided the letter was primarily work he needed to do with Dr. Wynn. He had begun to recognize another habit: using disclosure to make Audra understand him before he had fully understood himself.

At the next session, Dr. Wynn asked what Corey had wanted from Denise as a child after Leonard used the letter.

“I wanted her to tell me I hadn't betrayed her.”

“Did she?”

“Every time I saw her.”

“What did you want from your father?”

Corey was quiet for a long time.

“I wanted him to say the letter wasn't a contract.”

The words surprised him.

A child's statement, he realized, could become a contract in a parent's mind: You said you were happier here, so keep being happier. You said you were tired there, so don't miss it. You said you wanted me, so don't make me feel unchosen later.

Corey had nearly handed Audra the same invisible contract.

He went home and removed one more thing from the refrigerator: an old color-coded custody calendar he had once used to count overnights during the dispute. The new calendar showed only school, appointments, pickups, and ordinary plans. No red for Mom. No blue for Dad.

Audra noticed the change the next morning.

“Where did the colors go?”

“I don't need them anymore.”

May you like

She looked at the plain squares.

“Me neither,” she said.

Related Stories

Other posts