scribe

Chapter 10 - THE ORIGINAL FILES

Martin Reese came to Corey's house on a Tuesday evening with a laptop bag and no patience for ambiguity.

Audra was at Imani's for dinner.

Corey had made coffee neither of them drank.

Martin sat at the dining-room table where Corey had recorded Audra and opened a checklist.

“Let's go through this once.”

Corey nodded.

“The mediator requested preservation of any recordings you intend to rely on. Opposing counsel has now formally requested the original media files, metadata, and any edited versions.”

“I understand.”

“Do you?”

Corey's jaw tightened.

Martin pointed to the phone. “How many total recordings?”

“Seven that I kept.”

“How many did you make?”

Corey stared at the table.

“I don't know. Maybe twelve. Fifteen.”

Martin leaned back.

“And the others?”

“Deleted.”

“When?”

“Over several months.”

“Before litigation?”

“Before the formal filing.”

“That distinction may matter legally. It does not make the optics good.”

Corey looked away.

“I deleted failed takes.”

“What is a failed take?”

The question sounded ridiculous when another adult asked it.

Corey rubbed his face.

“When she got distracted. When she changed the subject. When she didn't answer clearly.”

Martin's stare was flat.

“When she didn't answer how?”

“I didn't tell her to lie.”

“That isn't what I asked.”

Corey stood and walked to the window.

Outside, a neighbor pushed a trash bin to the curb.

“I was trying to show a pattern.”

Martin closed the checklist.

“You were trying to make the pattern easier to see.”

“Yes.”

“By removing things that complicated it.”

Corey turned.

“Imani is late. She changes plans. Audra gets exhausted. Those things are true.”

“Then why did you need a child to repeat them on camera?”

Corey had no answer that did not sound worse when spoken aloud.

Martin opened the laptop.

“Let's find out whether there are backups.”

Corey frowned. “I deleted them.”

“Your phone syncs photos?”

“Some.”

“What about shared devices?”

Corey thought of the old tablet in the desk drawer. Audra used it sometimes for games. Years earlier, he had set it to mirror his photo library so family pictures would appear automatically.

“I don't know.”

They checked.

The tablet had not synced recently.

But a cloud archive had.

A folder opened containing videos Corey had forgotten existed.

The dates matched his notes.

More files appeared than the seven in his litigation folder.

Martin counted silently.

Eighteen.

Corey's face went pale.

Martin clicked one from December.

Audra appeared on-screen beside the Christmas tree.

Corey's voice came from behind the camera.

“Tell me what you said about going to Mom's tomorrow.”

Audra frowned. “I said I don't want to leave yet.”

“Right. Say you don't want to go.”

“But I do want to go.”

“Audra, just explain that you would rather stay here tonight.”

“Tonight or tomorrow?”

Corey's recorded voice paused.

Then the file ended.

Martin did not speak.

He opened another.

January.

Audra sat at the kitchen table.

“How do you feel after weekends at Mom's?” Corey's recorded voice asked.

“Tired.”

“Because you go back and forth?”

“Because she lets me stay up for movie night.”

“Audra.”

“What?”

“Focus.”

The video ended.

Corey sat down heavily.

Martin closed the laptop halfway.

“You cannot use the edited clips as evidence of an independent preference.”

Corey's mouth went dry.

“Can I explain the context?”

“The context is on the recordings.”

Corey stared at the black edge of the screen.

“Will Imani get all of these?”

“If they are responsive to discovery, yes.”

His first instinct was fear.

Not legal fear.

Imani fear.

He imagined her hearing his voice say Focus.

He imagined Audra older, hearing it too.

Martin watched him.

“There's something else.”

Corey looked up.

“If you're considering relocation, the court is going to examine whether you're facilitating Audra's relationship with her mother. These recordings do not help that question.”

“I've never told Audra she can't love Imani.”

“No. You have been trying to define what that love is allowed to mean for the schedule.”

Corey stood again.

“That is unfair.”

“Maybe. But you hired me to tell you what this looks like to someone who is not living inside your reasons.”

Corey walked into the kitchen.

On the refrigerator was a drawing Audra had made in first grade.

Three stick figures held hands under an enormous yellow sun.

Mom.

Dad.

Me.

It had been drawn before the separation.

No one had removed it.

Martin joined him in the doorway.

“What do you want?” he asked.

“The Charlotte job.”

“That isn't what I mean.”

Corey looked at the drawing.

“I want Audra stable.”

“Then stop making her responsible for proving which adult can give her stability.”

After Martin left, Corey sat alone at the dining table.

The phone stand was still in a drawer nearby.

He took it out.

For several seconds he held it in his hand.

Then he placed it in the trash.

He stared at it there.

The gesture felt dramatic and useless.

The recordings still existed.

The hearing still existed.

Charlotte still existed.

And Audra still knew he had been willing to keep only the parts that helped him.

The next morning, she came downstairs before school and found a new sheet of paper on the refrigerator.

Corey had written one sentence in black marker.

NO RECORDING AUDRA ABOUT COURT OR PARENTING.

Audra read it twice.

Then she looked at him.

“Is that for you or me?”

Corey swallowed.

“For me.”

Audra nodded.

May you like

She did not smile.

But she did not look away either.

Related Stories

Other posts