scribe

Chapter 17 - THE VIDEO WITH THE MISSING SENTENCE

Imani watched the recordings in Angela's office.

She had thought she was prepared.

She was not.

The first videos made her angry.

By the fourth, anger gave way to something colder.

Audra sat at Corey's dining table in a yellow shirt.

Corey's voice came from behind the phone.

“Tell me what you said in the car.”

Audra looked uncertain. “That Mom was late.”

“And how did that make you feel?”

“Bad.”

“Do you want to keep waiting when it's her day?”

“No.”

The edited version ended there.

The original continued.

Audra rubbed her nose.

“But I still want her to come.”

Corey said, “We got it.”

The video stopped.

Imani covered her mouth.

Angela paused playback.

“You want a break?”

“No.”

“You don't have to do all of these today.”

“I do.”

Angela studied her.

“Why?”

“Because she did.”

They continued.

One video showed Audra saying Imani's apartment was noisy.

The next forty seconds showed her explaining the upstairs baby and laughing about how the pipes made a knocking sound.

Another showed her saying she hated switching houses.

The original included: “I wish both houses were on the same street.”

Another showed her crying and saying she wanted Dad.

The full file began ten minutes after Audra scraped her knee at a park and wanted the parent who had been there.

The words were real.

The arrangement was false.

Imani realized that distinction would stay with her.

Angela closed the final video.

“We can seek sanctions if his filing relied on materially edited evidence.”

Imani wiped her face.

“What would that do?”

“Potentially attorney fees. Evidentiary consequences. It depends on what was represented and when.”

“Would Audra know?”

“Not from us.”

Imani stared at the black laptop screen.

“What do we actually need?”

Angela waited.

“I mean for her. Not for me to win.”

“The no-recording order already exists. The guardian ad litem has the originals. We can ask for a clearer provision prohibiting either parent from soliciting statements about preference or using child-created material in litigation without review.”

“Do that.”

“And the fees?”

Imani looked away.

“Ask for whatever is appropriate. I just don't want punishment to become the new thing Audra thinks she caused.”

Angela nodded.

On the last video, before they shut the laptop, Audra's voice came through softly.

“The part where I said I miss Mom. Please keep it.”

Imani closed her eyes.

She had heard Audra describe the moment.

Hearing the actual voice was different.

There was no drama in it.

That was what broke her.

An eight-year-old sounded as if she were requesting someone save a drawing from the trash.

Please keep it.

Don't delete everything.

Angela stopped the recording.

Imani sat very still.

“I want a copy of that one.”

Angela hesitated. “For your records?”

Imani thought about playing it someday to prove something.

To Corey.

To Audra.

To herself.

Then she shook her head.

“No. Never mind.”

“Why?”

“Because that's exactly how this started.”

That evening, Audra came for dinner.

Imani had made baked chicken and rice.

She did not mention the videos.

Audra talked about a book fair.

After dinner, they sat on the couch and watched a nature program.

Halfway through, Audra rested her head on Imani's shoulder.

Imani nearly cried again.

She had spent months terrified Corey would take this ordinary contact away.

Fear had made her want evidence too.

Screenshots of late notices.

Calendars.

Messages.

Proof she was loved.

She understood the temptation.

That did not excuse what Corey had done.

It did help her recognize how easily a parent could turn a child into an exhibit while insisting it was protection.

At nine, Corey arrived to pick Audra up.

Imani stepped into the hallway while Audra put on her shoes.

“I watched the originals.”

Corey's face went pale.

He nodded.

“I know.”

“Do you?”

“Yes.”

She wanted to unload every sentence she had prepared.

Instead she said, “You made her ask you to keep loving me in the story.”

Corey's eyes dropped.

“I know.”

“No. You know now.”

He looked up.

Imani's voice stayed controlled.

“She knew then.”

Audra appeared with her coat.

Both adults stopped.

Imani kissed her cheek.

“Good night.”

In the car, Audra asked Corey, “Why is Mom mad?”

He gripped the steering wheel.

The easiest answer was adult stuff.

Instead he said, “She saw the full videos.”

Audra went silent.

Corey added immediately, “You don't have to talk about them.”

“Did she see the part?”

“What part?”

Audra looked at him.

He knew.

“Yes.”

“The whole part?”

“Yes.”

Audra turned toward the window.

Her shoulders lowered.

Corey understood something then.

For Audra, the video being seen whole did not mean he had lost.

It meant she had been returned to herself.

The next day, Angela filed a short notice stating that Imani would not rely on isolated excerpts from the recordings either. Imani could have used the full videos to embarrass Corey. Parts of them would have been powerful.

But turning Audra's discomfort into a weapon for the opposite side would still have made the child useful to litigation.

When Angela asked whether she was sure, Imani said, “Use the facts about what he did. Don't use her pain as decoration.”

The distinction cost her a dramatic moment in court. It gave Audra something more important: one fewer adult claiming ownership of her voice.

When Imani got home, she opened the co-parenting app and typed three angry paragraphs to Corey. She read them once, then deleted them before sending. Not because the anger was wrong, but because Audra's future pickups did not need to carry the weight of every past recording.

She wrote instead: I reviewed the originals. Counsel will address the legal issues. Please keep communication here focused on Audra's schedule.

May you like

Corey replied: Understood.

It was an unsatisfying exchange. That was one reason it was useful.

Related Stories

Other posts