Chapter 14 - THE PAPER AUDRA WROTE FOR HERSELF

Naomi Ellis interviewed Corey and Imani separately.
She visited both homes.
She spoke with Ms. Reed, Audra's teacher, and the after-school coordinator. She reviewed the co-parenting messages, the school attendance record, Imani's work schedules, Corey's job offer, and the full set of recovered recordings.
Then she asked to see Audra again.
Audra arrived carrying no backpack this time.
Naomi had the copy of THINGS I SAID in a plain folder.
She placed it on the coffee table.
“I want to ask you about one line.”
Audra looked at the page.
“Which?”
“Why do I have to explain everything twice?”
Audra picked at the cuff of her cardigan.
“Because if I say something bad about Mom, Dad thinks it means I want less Mom.”
“And if you say something bad about Dad?”
Audra thought.
“I don't say as much bad about Dad to Mom.”
“Why?”
“She gets sad.”
Naomi nodded.
“Does she tell you not to?”
“No.”
“Does she ask what happens at Dad's?”
“Sometimes she starts to. Then she stops now.”
“What happens when Dad asks?”
“He stops more now too.”
Naomi made a note.
“What would make things easier?”
Audra looked toward the window.
There was a playground across the street. Two children were taking turns on a swing.
“I want everybody to stop listening for the useful part.”
Naomi's pen stopped.
“What do you mean?”
Audra turned back.
“When I say Mom was late, Dad hears Mom was late. When I say I still wanted to go, that part gets smaller.”
“And with your mom?”
“If I say Dad's house is calmer, Mom hears calmer like it means better.”
“Does she?”
“She used to.”
Naomi folded her hands.
“What does calmer mean to you?”
“Dad doesn't have neighbors upstairs. Mom's apartment has a baby over us.”
Naomi smiled faintly.
“That's useful context.”
Audra gave her a serious look. “See?”
Naomi laughed once. “Fair point.”
They talked about Charlotte.
Audra repeated that the school was nice.
She also said she did not want to move three hours away.
“Would you feel differently if you could see your mom for longer blocks of time?” Naomi asked.
“I don't want Mom to turn into vacations.”
The sentence made Naomi sit very still.
Audra went on.
“I want regular Mom. Grocery-store Mom. Late-pickup Mom. Pancake Mom. Not just summer Mom.”
Naomi wrote slowly.
“And Dad?”
“I want regular Dad too.”
“What if Dad moved without you?”
Audra's eyes filled immediately.
“I don't want that either.”
There it was.
The impossible shape of the adult plans.
Audra wanted two parents within reach.
Corey wanted a job three hours away.
Imani wanted a schedule that preserved frequent contact.
No sentence from Audra could make all three true.
Naomi leaned forward.
“I need you to hear something. The adults may make a decision you don't like. That does not mean you chose it.”
Audra stared at her.
“What if they say it's what I wanted?”
“Then I will correct that if it isn't accurate.”
“You promise?”
“I can promise to report what you tell me as fully and carefully as I can.”
Audra considered the wording.
It was not a perfect promise.
That made her trust it more.
Before leaving, she pointed to her paper.
“Can I add something?”
Naomi handed her a pen.
At the bottom Audra wrote:
I DON'T WANT MOM TO TURN INTO VACATIONS.
Then she added:
I DON'T WANT DAD TO MOVE AWAY EITHER.
She stared at both sentences.
“That's the problem,” she said.
Naomi nodded.
“Yes.”
“Can you put both?”
“I will.”
When Corey picked Audra up, he asked whether she wanted ice cream.
Audra gave him a suspicious look.
He understood immediately.
“No signing anything.”
Her mouth twitched.
“Okay.”
They went to a small shop near the courthouse.
Audra chose mint chocolate chip.
Corey chose coffee.
They sat by the window.
He did not ask about Naomi.
Audra noticed.
After several minutes she said, “You can ask how I feel.”
Corey looked up.
“I thought I wasn't supposed to ask what you said.”
“That's different.”
“How do you feel?”
Audra licked a drop of ice cream from the spoon.
“Tired.”
“Of talking?”
“Of checking if talking is dangerous.”
Corey's face tightened.
He nodded.
“I understand.”
“No, you don't.”
The correction came gently.
Corey almost defended himself.
Then he stopped.
“You're right,” he said. “I don't.”
Audra looked at him.
The answer surprised her.
She returned to her ice cream.
For the rest of the afternoon, they talked about black holes.
Corey did not once turn the conversation into evidence of where she felt happiest.
That evening, Audra copied one sentence from her paper onto a fresh index card: I WANT REGULAR MOM AND REGULAR DAD. She did not show it to anyone. She tucked it into the back of her desk drawer beside old birthday cards.
The act felt different from keeping evidence. No date. No explanation. No audience.
It was simply a sentence she wanted to belong to herself.
Weeks later she would forget the card was there, which was perhaps the clearest sign that she no longer needed every thought prepared for cross-examination.
On the drive home from Naomi's office, Audra watched people cross at a downtown light and wondered how many of them had families with sentences that did not fit neatly together. Corey asked whether she wanted music. She said no. He did not treat the silence as evidence that the interview had gone badly.
At home he made grilled cheese. Audra burned the edge of hers because she insisted on flipping it herself. Corey scraped the black part with a knife and handed it back without replacing the sandwich.
“You can still eat it,” he said.
May you like
Audra looked at the imperfect toast and smiled. “It's still the same sandwich.”
Neither of them said why the sentence felt familiar.