scribe

Chapter 4 - The Witness Who Wasn’t There

Cassian photographed the waiver before Lucien could stop him.

His uncle’s expression cooled.

“That document is privileged corporate material.”

“It concerns my mother.”

“It concerns a company you run.”

“And a property you want me to sell tonight.”

Lucien placed both hands on the table. “Cassian, do not confuse guilt with governance. You had an unpleasant exchange with your mother in public. Fine. Apologize. Learn a few more signs if it makes you feel better. But do not let a domestic embarrassment infect a transaction that protects eight hundred employees.”

The precision of the sentence disturbed Cassian.

“How do you know I had an unpleasant exchange with her?”

Lucien blinked once.

Then: “Your driver called security because you were delayed.”

Cassian knew that was possible.

He also knew his uncle had answered too quickly.

He stood. “I’m not signing tonight.”

“Montclair’s offer expires tomorrow at noon.”

“Then it expires.”

Lucien’s voice hardened. “Your father built this company by knowing when sentiment had become a liability.”

Cassian looked at the copy of the waiver.

“My father also signed documents with witnesses who were actually present.”

He left before Lucien answered.

Apolline’s apartment stood on the fourth floor of an old building in the Seventh Arrondissement, narrow and bright, with books stacked two deep along the walls. Eulalie had arrived before Cassian. She sat at the dining table with the green leather portfolio in front of her.

Apolline had not opened the sealed compartment.

“It was hers to open,” she said.

Eulalie pressed the brass latch.

Inside were three bundles of paper, a small key, two photographs, and an envelope bearing her name.

Her hands hovered over the envelope.

Cassian set the photograph of the waiver on the table.

Eulalie looked at it.

The color left her face.

Apolline leaned closer.

“That is my mother’s signature,” she whispered.

“You’re sure?” Cassian asked.

“Yes.”

Eulalie shook her head violently.

Apolline turned to her.

“You never signed this?”

NO.

“Did Claire witness anything for you on October eighteenth, 2004?”

Eulalie stared at the date.

Then she signed.

CLAIRE WAS IN LYON. HER FATHER HAD SURGERY.

Apolline went still. “Grand-père’s first heart operation.”

She stood, crossed to a bookcase, and pulled down a family photograph album. After several minutes, she found a page dated in her mother’s handwriting.

LYON — OCTOBER 17–20, 2004.

There was Claire beside a hospital bed, holding the hand of an elderly man. On the edge of the photograph, eight-year-old Apolline grinned at the camera with missing front teeth.

Cassian looked back at the waiver.

A photograph was not proof that Claire could not have returned to Paris for an hour. But the distance, the dates, and Eulalie’s immediate certainty were enough to turn suspicion into something heavier.

Eulalie finally opened Claire’s envelope.

The letter inside was five pages long.

Apolline read aloud because Eulalie wanted Cassian to hear every word.

“Eulalie, if you are reading this, then either I found the courage to return these papers to you, or I did not live long enough to do it myself.”

Apolline’s voice faltered.

She continued.

“I am sorry for leaving when I did. I was frightened. Lucien told me that if I challenged the documents, he would make certain my work in Paris ended and that he would accuse me of stealing confidential material. I believed him.”

Cassian sat slowly.

The letter described meetings in 2003 and 2004. It described a document called the Contribution Agreement. It described Eulalie’s rights over Varenne and royalties from a design collection called Étoile.

Then came the sentence that altered the room.

“Étienne knew the first diversion had occurred.”

Eulalie shut her eyes.

Cassian whispered, “My father?”

Apolline kept reading.

“He told me it was temporary. He said he would repay what had been moved and restore your rights after the debt crisis passed. Lucien told him there would be no company left to restore if he did.”

Beneath the letter lay a photocopied ledger page.

At the top, in faded blue ink, were two words:

AURORE 17.

After security was mentioned, Apolline asked whether they should move the green portfolio elsewhere immediately. Cassian suggested the safe at his private residence. Eulalie rejected that with one quick sign. Apolline translated: “She says a Valmont safe is still a Valmont safe.” Cassian almost objected, then stopped. They agreed instead to photograph the contents, create a dated inventory, and leave the originals overnight with Apolline, whose connection to the company was indirect. Cassian sent encrypted copies to outside counsel without describing conclusions he had not yet verified.

May you like

That discipline calmed him. Facts had edges. Shame did not. He could not undo what he had said on the plaza, but he could stop allowing guilt to make him careless. Eulalie seemed to notice the difference. When he asked her to identify which signatures in the papers were genuinely hers, she did not recoil. She examined them line by line, marking some as authentic and others as unfamiliar. On one 2002 authorization she pointed out a tiny flourish she had stopped using after injuring her wrist. The detail reminded Cassian that handwriting was physical history, not just ink.

Apolline, meanwhile, photographed the album page from Lyon and called her aunt to confirm the hospital dates. Her aunt remembered Claire sleeping in a plastic chair beside her father for three nights. It was still not absolute proof, but the wall around the waiver had gained another crack. By midnight, none of them was talking about coincidence anymore.

Related Stories

Other posts