scribe

Chapter 14 - The Vote That Failed

The emergency board meeting began at 4:30 p.m.

Cassian arrived at 4:27 with outside counsel, certified copies of the Contribution Agreement, the notary file extracts, and a preliminary ownership memorandum on Montclair.

Lucien was already seated.

Nine directors attended in person or by secure video. Sabine sat three chairs from her father, expression unreadable.

Lucien opened the meeting.

“This board is not a family tribunal. Our purpose today is to determine whether the chief executive’s recent conduct has impaired his ability to act in the company’s best interests.”

Cassian did not interrupt.

When his turn came, he did not defend his tone in Paris. He did not describe his guilt. He did not ask anyone to trust his instincts.

He distributed documents.

“The proposed Varenne sale was presented to me as an arm’s-length transaction. It was not fully disclosed. The buyer’s ownership chain includes a trust over which the chairman exercises formal powers. Whether that creates ultimate beneficial ownership is under review, but the relationship should have been disclosed before the chairman signed the sale agreement.”

Lucien said, “It was disclosed to counsel.”

The general counsel shifted uncomfortably. “The trust relationship was described as non-economic. We were not provided the full protector instrument.”

Lucien’s eyes cooled.

Cassian continued.

“Second, Varenne is subject to a personal consent right held by Eulalie Valmont under a 1999 Contribution Agreement. We have located the original. The 2004 waiver relied upon to extinguish that right is now disputed. The named witness was documented in Lyon during the relevant period, and the notary requested for the execution recorded the appointment as cancelled.”

One director asked, “Are you alleging forgery?”

“No. I am saying the board cannot responsibly rely on that waiver until its authenticity is independently examined.”

Lucien leaned back.

It was the correct answer and both men knew it.

Cassian then disclosed the historical royalty issue.

Not as theft.

Not yet.

As a material related-party accounting dispute requiring audit.

When he finished, the room was silent.

The director who had proposed limiting Cassian’s authority cleared his throat.

“I withdraw my motion.”

Lucien looked at him.

“You do not get to withdraw a duly circulated matter because the CEO has staged a document dump.”

“Then I will vote against my own motion.”

The vote proceeded anyway.

Two directors supported restricting Cassian.

Six opposed.

Sabine abstained.

The motion failed.

Then Sabine spoke.

“I move that all transactions involving Varenne be suspended and that an independent special committee investigate the waiver, Aurore 17, Delmare, and Montclair.”

Her father stared at her.

“You have no idea what you are doing.”

Sabine’s voice shook once, then steadied. “That is why I am asking independent people to find out.”

The motion passed seven to two.

Lucien did not raise his voice.

That frightened Cassian more than anger would have.

After the meeting, Lucien waited for him in the corridor.

“You think you won.”

Cassian shook his head. “No.”

“For once, you sound intelligent.”

Lucien stepped closer.

“The audit will find what audits always find: complexity. Shared decisions. Missing context. Your father’s signatures. Your mother’s decades of silence. And when the newspapers reduce all of it to scandal, you will discover that truth does not arrive alone. It brings ruin with it.”

Cassian said, “Then perhaps we should have considered that before creating so much to uncover.”

Lucien’s mouth tightened.

“Ask Apolline why Claire really left.”

Cassian went still.

Lucien walked away.

After the failed vote, several employees quietly contacted the special committee. None possessed a dramatic smoking gun, but their accounts established patterns. A retired assistant remembered instructions that Eulalie’s correspondence be routed through Lucien’s office “to avoid duplication.” A former archivist recalled being told not to catalogue Beauchamp materials separately because “the brand history is unified.” A lawyer described seeing the 2004 waiver only as a scan until years later.

Cassian resisted the urge to treat every suspicious memory as proof. The committee attorneys separated corroborated facts from recollections that could not be verified. That process was frustrating and necessary. The story grew less cinematic and more convincing.

One testimony cut him personally. His former executive assistant said Eulalie had asked three times in 2022 for a meeting about Varenne. Cassian’s office had declined because he was traveling and later because Lucien had told the team the matter was “already settled at family level.” Cassian searched his emails and found the requests. He had skimmed two and never opened the third.

That night he showed them to Eulalie. He did not say Lucien had blocked her. He said, “I did.”

May you like

Eulalie read the messages. Then she signed: “Yes.”

No comfort. No exaggeration. Just responsibility placed where it belonged.

Related Stories

Other posts