Chapter 3 - THE EASY ONE

The next morning, Elise found Lila eating cereal at the kitchen island with the photograph beside her bowl.
“What’s that?”
Lila slid it across the counter.
Elise smiled immediately. “Oh, look how tiny Mabel was.”
Then she saw where Lila’s finger rested.
“There’s the star,” Lila said.
Elise’s expression softened. “So it is.”
“Do you remember that day?”
“Bits of it.”
“Do you remember Dad measuring me?”
Elise paused.
“I remember you wanting attention because everything was about the new baby.”
The sentence landed harder than Elise intended.
Lila’s spoon stopped halfway to her mouth.
Elise noticed.
“I didn’t mean it like that.”
“What did you mean?”
“You were seven. You had a new sister. Of course you wanted us.”
“I was sick.”
“I know.”
“Dad drew the star because I didn’t grow.”
Elise looked down at the photograph as if searching for a hidden caption.
“I don’t remember that part.”
Lila nodded.
Mabel ran into the kitchen wearing mismatched socks and carrying the stuffed rabbit.
“Mom, look! Bunny has one yellow foot and one pink foot.”
Elise turned immediately.
“What happened to the other yellow sock?”
“I don’t know.”
“Let’s go find it before school.”
They disappeared toward the laundry room.
Lila remained at the island.
Patrick entered, already dressed for work.
“Morning, kiddo.”
He noticed her expression. “Everything okay?”
Lila pushed the photo toward him.
“Mom said I wanted attention when Mabel came home.”
Patrick exhaled through his nose.
“You did have a hard time for a little while.”
“How?”
“You got clingy.”
“What did I do?”
“You wanted one of us in your room at bedtime. You kept asking if the baby was asleep. You complained when we had to leave places early.”
Lila’s voice became quiet. “Was that bad?”
“No. You were seven.”
“Then why do you say it like I caused trouble?”
Patrick opened his mouth, then closed it.
Lila folded the photograph carefully.
“You and Mom always say I was the easy one.”
“You were.”
“But you just said I wasn’t.”
Patrick leaned against the counter.
“Being easy doesn’t mean you never needed anything.”
Lila looked at him.
“Then what does it mean?”
He did not answer quickly enough.
And in that pause, Lila understood something she had never had words for before.
Easy meant she stopped asking sooner.
At school, Lila found herself listening whenever someone described her as responsible. Teachers meant it as praise. She had always liked it. That week, the word sounded different.
During group work, Mrs. Bell asked Lila to collect everyone else's charcoal trays because "you're my dependable one." Lila did it without complaint. Halfway back to the cabinet, she wondered whether dependable was another word that could become a job if people used it often enough.
At recess, her friend Zoe asked why she was staring at the playground fence.
"Do your parents call you easy?" Lila asked.
Zoe laughed. "No. My dad says I'm expensive."
Lila smiled despite herself.
"Why?"
"Nothing."
Zoe nudged her. "That's never true when somebody says it like that."
Lila did not tell the whole story. She only mentioned the height marks and the tape.
Zoe shrugged. "Just make them save yours too."
The simplicity of the answer irritated Lila.
"I did."
"Then good."
"It's not just that."
"What else?"
Lila searched for language. "I think I got good at not needing stuff."
Zoe looked genuinely confused. "Everybody needs stuff."
The bell rang before Lila could answer.
At home, Patrick was replacing a loose hinge screw near the marked doorframe. Lila watched from the stairs.
"Dad?"
"Yeah?"
"If I asked you for more things when I was little, would you remember more?"
Patrick set down the screwdriver.
"I don't think memory works like that."
"But you'd have more things to remember."
He leaned back against the wall. "Maybe."
Lila came down two steps.
"Did you like that I was easy?"
"I was proud of you."
"For not asking?"
"For being patient. Helpful. Independent."
"Those aren't the same."
Patrick rubbed his forehead. "No. They're not."
Lila looked at the star under its blue square of tape. "I think you mixed them up."
Patrick followed her gaze.
"I think you're right," he said.
May you like
It was not a dramatic admission. He did not kneel or cry or make promises. He simply picked up the screwdriver again and sat there, unable to return to the hinge for several seconds.
That was the first time Lila saw regret before an apology.