Chapter 2 - THE MARKS THAT WERE MISSING

They did not paint the star that afternoon.
Patrick finally tore off a small square of tape and placed it over the faded pencil drawing.
“There,” he said.
His tone was practical, as if he had solved the problem completely.
Lila whispered, “Thank you.”
But later, after dinner, she returned to the doorway alone.
Mabel’s protected marks formed a small bright-blue ladder near the floor. Lila’s star sat higher by itself, a single square near the hinge.
She searched above and below it.
There had been more.
She knew there had.
At five, she had stood there after preschool wearing a purple jacket. At six, she had demanded to be measured twice because she claimed lunch made her taller. At eight, she had worn soccer cleats until Elise told her shoes did not count.
Where were those lines?
Lila crouched and tilted her head under the hallway light.
Some marks had already faded from years of wiping the trim. Others might have been covered during an earlier touch-up. She could see traces that might have been numbers, but nothing certain.
Behind her, footsteps approached.
Patrick came around the corner holding a glass of water.
“You’re supposed to be getting ready for bed.”
Lila stood. “Were some of my marks painted before?”
Patrick stared at the frame.
“I don’t know. Maybe when we fixed the hallway after the pipe leak.”
“Did we save them?”
“I don’t remember.”
The answer was ordinary.
That was what made it painful.
Lila asked, “Do you remember measuring me when I was six?”
Patrick smiled faintly. “Of course.”
“What was I wearing?”
His smile vanished.
“Lila, I don’t remember every detail from every year.”
She nodded quickly. “Okay.”
Patrick studied her face. “That doesn’t mean it wasn’t important.”
“I know.”
She went upstairs before he could say more.
In her room, she opened the bottom drawer of her desk where she kept birthday cards, school ribbons, old stickers, and two friendship bracelets that no longer fit.
She searched for photographs.
There were several printed pictures of Mabel by the doorway.
Mabel standing under the measuring marks at age three, grinning with chocolate on her mouth.
Mabel at four, holding Patrick’s pencil.
Mabel on her fifth birthday, Elise kneeling beside her.
Lila found one photograph of herself near the same door.
She was in the background.
Seven years old.
Sick-day pajamas.
Patrick’s hand holding a pencil beside her head.
The camera had focused on Mabel as a baby in Elise’s arms.
But near Lila’s shoulder, blurred and almost invisible, was the small star.
Lila stared at it for a long time.
At the bottom of the photo, someone had written in black marker:
Mabel’s first week home.
Nothing about Lila.
That night, the single photograph refused to leave Lila's mind. She placed it flat on her desk and turned on the small lamp beside her bed. Her seven-year-old self looked blurry because the camera had focused on the baby, but there were details she could still identify: the rabbit-print pajama bottoms she had loved, the messy braid over one shoulder, the thermometer on the side table because she had been running a fever.
She tried to remember what happened after Patrick drew the star.
A baby crying. Elise calling. The television muted. The taste of cherry medicine.
Then nothing.
She opened the family photo app on the tablet she shared with Mabel and searched by date. Hundreds of images from Mabel's first month appeared. Mabel sleeping. Mabel yawning. Mabel with Patrick. Mabel with Elise. Mabel with grandparents. Mabel in a stroller.
Lila appeared in seventeen photographs.
In eleven, she was in the background.
She counted twice to make sure.
The numbers embarrassed her because they felt like evidence in a trial nobody had agreed to hold. She shut the app, then opened it again. This time she searched the months before Mabel was born.
There were pictures of Lila at the park, baking with Patrick, painting Elise's nails badly, sitting on the kitchen counter eating strawberries, asleep under a blanket fort.
The contrast was too obvious.
A soft knock came at the door.
Elise entered holding folded laundry. "Still awake?"
Lila minimized the photos.
"Yeah."
Elise placed clothes on the dresser. "You seem quiet."
"I'm tired."
Elise nodded and turned to leave.
Lila almost let her.
"Mom?"
Elise turned.
"When Mabel was a baby, did I stop liking pictures?"
Elise blinked. "What?"
"There's not many of me."
"We were terrible about taking pictures of everything that year."
Lila looked at the tablet screen, where a grid of baby photographs waited behind the minimized window.
"Okay."
Elise followed her gaze. Understanding arrived slowly.
"Oh," she said.
Lila hated that word now too.
Elise sat on the edge of the bed. "I don't have a good answer."
"You don't have to make one."
The sentence sounded more grown-up than Lila felt.
Elise reached toward her, then stopped before touching her shoulder. "Goodnight, honey."
May you like
"Night."
When the door closed, Lila reopened the photo app but did not count anymore.