Chapter 18 - MABEL SAYS NO

The first real test came from Mabel.
She had a class picnic scheduled for the same Saturday as Lila’s final City Arts exhibit.
The picnic ran from ten to noon.
The exhibit opened at eleven-thirty.
At breakfast, Elise laid out the options.
“We can leave the picnic at eleven and go together, or Daddy can stay with you and I’ll go to Lila’s opening.”
Mabel frowned.
“I want everybody at my picnic.”
Lila immediately said, “You can stay.”
Patrick put down his coffee.
“No automatic volunteering.”
Lila looked annoyed. “I’m just saying.”
“And we’re asking Mabel.”
Mabel looked from face to face.
“What happens if everybody stays with me?”
Elise said, “Then we miss the beginning of Lila’s exhibit.”
Mabel thought about this.
“Is her picture there?”
“Yes.”
“The door one?”
“Yes.”
Mabel stirred her cereal.
Then she said, “I don’t need everybody.”
Lila blinked.
Mabel pointed at Patrick. “Daddy can do picnic. Mommy can go see the door.”
Elise smiled. “That works.”
Mabel added, “Then Daddy and me come after cake.”
Patrick said, “Deal.”
Lila looked at her sister.
“Are you sure?”
Mabel shrugged with the enormous seriousness of a six-year-old making a moral decision.
“I don’t want you to have no people.”
Lila’s throat tightened.
“I’d have Mom.”
“You should have more than one.”
Nobody corrected her math.
On Saturday, Elise arrived at the exhibit before the doors opened.
Patrick and Mabel came forty minutes later, Mabel still wearing a paper sun visor from the picnic.
The drawing hung at eye level under Lila’s title.
PROOF I WAS SMALL HERE.
Mabel stood in front of it.
“That’s my tape too,” she said.
“Yes,” Lila replied.
Mabel pointed at the star.
“And that’s yours.”
“Yes.”
A stranger nearby smiled at the sisters and moved on.
Mabel whispered, “I like your star best.”
Lila smiled.
“You’re not supposed to pick favorites.”
Mabel grinned.
“I’m six. I can.”
For once, favoritism sounded harmless.
At the picnic, Patrick let Mabel choose whether to stay until cake. She did, but halfway through dessert she looked at the clock on his phone.
"We need to go to Lila."
"We have time."
"No, we need to go now."
Patrick smiled. "Okay."
Mabel ran to say goodbye to her teacher and returned with frosting on her cheek.
In the car she asked, "Will Lila know I left early?"
"Probably."
"Good."
Patrick glanced at her in the mirror. "You don't have to prove anything."
"I know. I want her to know."
That distinction sounded familiar.
At the gallery, Mabel spent longer in front of ASK FIRST than in front of the star drawing. The piece showed two hands and a narrow strip of tape suspended between them.
"Which hand is yours?" she asked.
"Neither."
"Then whose?"
"They're just hands."
Mabel accepted the abstraction with visible disappointment.
Later, while eating ice cream outside, she offered Lila the last bite of her cone.
Lila said, "No thanks."
Mabel shrugged and ate it herself.
May you like
Patrick noticed and smiled.
Months earlier, Mabel might have been praised extravagantly for sharing and Lila for accepting. Now a small offer could remain exactly that: an offer, not a test of anybody's goodness.