scribe

Chapter 10 - MABEL’S QUESTION

Mabel asked Lila about the star at bedtime.

She stood in Lila’s doorway wearing peach pajamas and holding the stuffed rabbit by one ear.

“Why do you care about that pencil?”

Lila looked up from her book.

“It’s not just pencil.”

Mabel considered this.

“What is it?”

“A memory.”

“But you remember it already.”

Lila closed the book.

“Sometimes seeing something helps.”

Mabel climbed onto the corner of the bed without asking.

“What happened?”

Lila almost said nothing.

Then she remembered the new rule about pretending.

“I was sick. Dad measured me. I didn’t get taller. He drew a star.”

“Why?”

“Because he said that made the mark count twice.”

Mabel smiled. “That’s funny.”

“Yeah.”

“Did I see?”

“You were a baby.”

Mabel’s face changed.

“So I was there?”

“Sort of.”

“Was Mommy holding me?”

Lila looked at the photograph on her desk.

“Yes.”

Mabel slid off the bed and picked it up.

“There I am.”

Then she noticed Lila in the background.

“And there you are.”

Lila nodded.

Mabel traced the edge of the photograph with one finger.

“Why does it say my first week home?”

“Because that’s what Mom wrote.”

“It should say your star too.”

Lila’s throat tightened.

“Mabel, it’s okay.”

“No.”

The word was blunt and uncomplicated.

Mabel carried the photograph into the hallway.

Elise was folding laundry in the bedroom.

“Mommy?”

“Yes?”

“You wrote it wrong.”

Elise looked up.

Mabel held out the picture.

“It says me, but Lila’s in it too.”

Elise took the photograph.

Mabel pointed. “Write her star.”

Elise looked toward Lila, who had followed her into the hall.

“I can add it,” Elise said softly.

Lila shook her head.

“No.”

Mabel frowned. “Why?”

“Because that’s what you wrote then.”

Elise understood.

Changing the caption now would make the old omission disappear.

Lila did not want it erased.

She wanted it acknowledged.

Elise turned the photograph over and, beneath the original line, wrote:

I noticed years later that Lila’s star was being drawn in the background. I wish I had noticed then.

She dated it.

Then she handed the photograph back.

Lila read the new words twice.

For the first time, a correction did not pretend the mistake had never happened.

The next day, Mabel asked whether she had stolen Lila's childhood.

She used exactly those words because six-year-olds often absorb adult language without understanding its size.

Lila was drawing at the dining table when Mabel whispered, "Did I steal it?"

Lila put down her pencil immediately.

"What?"

"Your childhood."

"Who said that?"

"Nobody. I heard Mom say she missed things after I was born."

Lila pulled out the chair beside her. "Come here."

Mabel climbed up.

"You didn't steal anything."

"But they took lots of pictures of me."

"You were a baby. Babies change every five seconds."

Mabel frowned. "I don't."

"You did. You were weird."

Mabel giggled.

Lila continued, "Mom and Dad made choices. You were just there."

"So you're not mad at me?"

"No. Sometimes I'm jealous of stuff you got. That's different."

Mabel considered this with surprising seriousness. "I'm jealous you can draw houses."

"See?"

"Can I be jealous and still like you?"

"Yes."

Mabel leaned against her shoulder.

That evening Lila told Elise about the conversation.

Elise's face fell. "I shouldn't have said that where she could hear."

"Probably not."

"Thank you for talking to her."

Lila frowned. "Don't make that my job either."

Elise stopped.

The correction was sharp but fair.

"You're right," she said. "I'll talk to her too."

May you like

Lila returned to her drawing.

A year earlier, she might have accepted praise for being mature and carried the responsibility silently. Now she was learning that protecting Mabel did not require becoming another parent.

Related Stories

Other posts