Chapter 17 - A Dinner Without the Younger Sister

Mirelda proposed a family supper in early June. Nothing elaborate: roast vegetables, a few bottles of wine, the dining room in Odilia's apartment, a place where no one needed to rearrange seats for a photographer. She invited Bastien, Seren, Iver, Vespera, and Elowen, carefully explaining that attendance was voluntary and no confrontation had been planned.
Elowen declined.
"I appreciate the invitation," she told her aunt. "But I don't want a room full of people watching to see whether I can stand next to her."
Mirelda was disappointed. She did not say so. "Then we can have lunch another day."
Vespera arrived at the supper early and helped Odilia place water glasses on the table. She counted the chairs without meaning to. There were six. Mirelda told her Elowen would not be coming.
"Did she say why?" Vespera asked.
"She didn't need to give a reason."
The words echoed Caedmon's questions in the ballroom, but there was no audience this time. Vespera adjusted a napkin and left the place settings as they were.
Dinner began with careful conversation. Iver spoke about his new apartment in Brooklyn, a fourth-floor walk-up with a bedroom that received sunlight for approximately forty minutes a day. Seren described a book she had helped edit. Bastien complained that a city permit application required three separate copies of the same drawing. Everybody laughed, and for half an hour the meal resembled the family gathering Odilia had hoped for.
Iver asked Vespera whether she had ever visited the apartment he rented in Brooklyn. She hadn't. He showed her a photograph of the room where he hoped to build a shelf and asked whether the old family desk would fit. Vespera knew that the desk belonged at Odilia's home and suggested a secondhand furniture shop instead. They talked about hinges, wall studs, and the strange challenges of drilling into old plaster. Seren listened with surprise. She had spent years expecting Vespera to direct conversation toward connections, donations, or appearances. Now her cousin seemed content discussing cheap hardware and uneven floors. It did not mean Vespera had changed permanently. It meant there was a version of her who could inhabit an ordinary evening. Seren wondered whether the younger relatives had sometimes given up on finding that version because criticizing the other one had become a family ritual of its own.
Then Rosalind called Vespera. Her name appeared on the phone resting beside the plate. Vespera declined the call without explanation. A minute later her mother sent a message accusing her of abandoning the woman who had raised her in order to please relatives who had betrayed her.
Vespera turned the phone facedown.
Odilia noticed. "You can take it if you need to."
"I don't."
Mirelda watched her niece, wondering when the elegant woman across the table had become so practiced at treating every invitation as a test. Her own resentment threatened to rise. She had spent weeks defending Elowen and wanted Vespera to show visible remorse. She also remembered that any demand for visible remorse might become another performance.
"I owe you an apology," Mirelda said abruptly.
Everyone stopped eating.
Vespera lifted her eyes. "For what?"
"I've been speaking about you as though your worst decision is the only thing you've ever done. I won't defend that decision. But I shouldn't use it to erase everything else."
Vespera's face tightened. "You don't owe me that."
"I know. I'm saying it because it's true."
Bastien set down his glass. He had something to say about the years before the wedding, but he took his time finding the words. He remembered seeing Elowen excluded at two Christmas celebrations. He remembered telling himself that he should not interfere between the sisters. He remembered seeing Vespera stiffen whenever their father entered a room with Elowen. He had assumed the problem belonged to the women because he was relieved not to be involved.
"We made you each carry more than you should have," he said. "And then we criticized the way you carried it."
Vespera looked toward the empty part of the table. "That doesn't make my decision fair."
"No," Bastien answered. "It doesn't."
Odilia had been watching all of them. The meal was far from peaceful, but there was honesty on the table, and nobody seemed in a hurry to sweep it away with the dishes.
After dinner Vespera volunteered to wash the plates. Iver dried them. They worked quietly for a while, the mundane task giving them something to do with their hands.
"Elowen liked those books you sent her when she was sick," Iver said.
Vespera nearly dropped a plate. "How did you know about that?"
"Dad told me years ago. He thought it was a good thing you did."
She had forgotten that Bastien might know. She had ordered the books without a note because acknowledging the gesture seemed to require acknowledging the relationship. Now she wondered how many private acts of kindness she had protected from public view until they could no longer build anything.
May you like
When she left, Odilia walked her to the door. The grandmother did not tell her the evening had been a success. She simply said she was glad Vespera had come.
On the elevator down, Vespera thought of Elowen staying away. She did not interpret it as punishment. It was a decision made by a woman who, at long last, knew she did not need to accept every invitation to prove she belonged.