scribe

Chapter 14 - The People Who Knew Him Differently

Livia came into Manhattan the following Monday with a canvas bag full of homemade biscuits and a willingness to speak of Edric without defending his every decision. She had not visited Odilia since the funeral. The two women greeted each other awkwardly at the study door, then found their old rhythm over tea. Both had spent long years caring for a man who made promises earnestly and kept them selectively.

Elowen sat between them at the kitchen table, where the afternoon light made the flour dust on Livia's coat look almost silver. Her mother taught drawing and design, preferred comfortable shoes, and had never learned to be intimidated by expensive rooms. The Halden apartment still made her careful with her cups, though.

"I need to know what actually happened when Dad left Rosalind," Elowen said. "Not what either family tells at dinners."

Livia set down her mug. "I met Edric after he and Rosalind had separated. We weren't having an affair, if that's what you've been told. The divorce wasn't final, but they were living apart. I was a visiting lecturer at a museum where he served on an advisory committee. We became friends before we became anything else."

Odilia nodded. "That's true."

"But there were times," Livia continued, "when he escaped discomfort with me by talking as if his first marriage had simply ended on its own. It hadn't. He had made choices that hurt Rosalind. He was absent for much of Vespera's teenage life even before the separation. Then he acted surprised that she mistrusted him."

Elowen had expected a cleaner story. She felt, absurdly, disappointed in the adults for refusing to provide one.

"Did Vespera ever want to know me?"

"I think she wanted to know who you were without having to accept what your existence meant to her," Livia said. "Those are different things."

Odilia reached for a biscuit. "Once, when Elowen had pneumonia, Vespera sent a parcel of books. She didn't put her name on it. Edric told me afterward."

Elowen looked up. She had been nine. She remembered three books arriving in a blue paper bag, including a collection of myths she still owned.

"Dad told me the books were from a friend," she said.

"He was trying to avoid explaining why Vespera didn't want to sign the note," Odilia replied. "Or perhaps he was afraid you'd expect more."

The complication hurt differently from the photograph in the album. It suggested that Vespera had sometimes reached across the distance and then withdrawn the hand before anyone could see. It did not excuse the wedding. It made the relationship less convenient to dismiss as a single person's unchanging cruelty.

Livia also recalled Vespera's first visit after Elowen was born. The older girl had arrived with Rosalind, carrying a gift of baby clothes. She stood in the doorway and refused to hold the infant when Edric asked her to. Livia, still exhausted, had felt rejected and angry. Years later she understood that an eighteen-year-old dealing with a new family arrangement might need to refuse an invitation without being unkind. The problem was that adults had kept interpreting the same refusal for years, attaching stories to it that belonged to their own disappointments. Livia remembered trying to make everything pleasant, insisting on cheerful holiday photographs when Vespera clearly wanted to leave. She had called it keeping peace. In retrospect, it had taught nobody how to talk. Telling Elowen this did not mean accepting Vespera's later cruelty. It meant acknowledging that the family's habits had been built by adults who had more choices than either daughter.

Later Livia asked to walk with Elowen through the park. They moved beneath dripping branches, passing children playing in coats too warm for the weather. Elowen confessed she had spent years picturing a reconciliation in which Vespera would one day admit she was a sister and everything else would follow.

"I think I wanted her to say it so I could stop asking Dad why she wouldn't," she said.

"And now?"

"Now I don't know whether I even want her to say it."

"You don't have to want the same thing forever."

A little farther along, they stopped beside a shallow pond. Ducks disturbed a film of sunlight on the water. Livia told her daughter about her own childhood, when two sisters in her family had stopped speaking over a borrowed sum of money. Everybody had treated the silence as an inherited tradition. Years later, when one needed care after surgery, the other came with groceries and a list of medications. They never resumed their old intimacy. They developed a workable kindness.

"I'm not offering that as a model," Livia said. "I'm telling you that relationships don't always end in either reunion or exile. Sometimes they become smaller and safer."

Elowen considered that. At twenty-four, she was still young enough to imagine every meaningful relationship had to reach a decisive conclusion. Her work at the archive taught otherwise. Histories were full of partial evidence, unanswered letters, and changed habits that never earned a dramatic photograph.

That evening she called Odilia and asked whether she could have copies of the documents, leaving the originals where they belonged. She wanted to read them slowly rather than search for one sentence to justify her anger.

Odilia agreed. She added that Vespera deserved to see any letter written to her by her father, but that no one should deliver it as ammunition.

"Can you promise me something?" the grandmother asked.

"What?"

May you like

"If you give her those papers, don't make it a test she has to pass in front of you. Truth is important. So is the freedom to decide what to do with it."

Elowen promised to think about it. It was the closest she could come to agreement that evening.

Related Stories

Other posts