scribe

Chapter 13 - The Locked Drawer in Edric's Study

Edric Halden had kept his writing desk at Odilia's apartment after he downsized from the family townhouse. Five years after his death, the desk still stood against the study window. Mirelda had once proposed donating it to a library, but Odilia said she liked having the scratches beneath its green leather writing surface. They reminded her that her middle child had been a boy before he became a complicated father.

When Elowen visited on a rainy Saturday, the older woman asked whether she would help sort some papers. Odilia no longer enjoyed kneeling to open low drawers, and she had decided to reduce the mountain of accumulated correspondence while she was still able to recognize it.

The drawer held old receipts, business notes, invitations, and an empty case for fountain pens. Beneath a stack of envelopes was a narrow cardboard box with two names written on top: Vespera and Elowen. The writing was unmistakably Edric's, though thinner than it had been in the years when he made lists for grocery shopping.

Elowen lifted the lid. Inside were drafts of letters, several unsent birthday cards, and a page divided by a line down the middle. Her name appeared on one side, Vespera's on the other. Under each were memories Edric had evidently tried to preserve: the first time Vespera rode a bicycle, Elowen's habit of examining stones in parking lots, the way one sang under her breath and the other always checked whether everyone had enough to eat.

"He wrote a great deal he never said," Odilia observed.

Elowen felt both affection and anger. Their father had been eloquent in private and baffled by confrontation. He could write ten lines about a child's courage but could not ask his elder daughter to stop excluding the younger one at dinner.

Some of the papers were ordinary enough to make Elowen ache. Edric had recorded the cost of replacing a broken watchband, a list of books he hoped to read, and a recipe for the soup he made whenever Livia was ill. A yellow note instructed him to ask Elowen about a history examination. On another sheet, he had written Vespera's work telephone number beside a reminder to congratulate her on a grant award. Elowen touched the pages carefully, conscious of the difference between a record and a person. Her father had been methodical about remembering obligations on paper, but reminders had not always become calls or visits. She had once thought the desk would prove how completely he had loved his daughters. Instead it showed a man trying, failing, and sometimes stopping short of an uncomfortable truth. She felt an archivist's obligation to preserve all of it and a daughter's desire to hide the parts that made him smaller.

A folded letter, dated six years before his death, began with the words Dear Vespera. It referred to a birthday dinner at which Elowen had been seated separately from the family. Edric wrote that he was ashamed of having allowed it. He wrote that a parent's failure to insist on fairness could make the child who was excluded feel as though she had caused the conflict. He asked Vespera to meet him for a frank conversation.

The letter had never been mailed. It was followed by another draft with the central sentence removed, then by a third that merely wished her a happy birthday.

"Did she ever see any of this?" Elowen asked.

"Not to my knowledge."

"Why would he write it three times and not send it?"

Odilia's answer took time. "He was frightened she would stop speaking to him. He decided he could manage the hurt more easily than he could manage her anger."

"So he let me manage the hurt."

"Yes."

The truth stung precisely because Elowen loved him. She remembered the way he had lifted her onto his shoulders during a street fair, bought cheap postcards for her archive collection, and waited outside the emergency department when she had a severe asthma attack. Those were not false memories. Neither were the birthdays when he watched her sit farther away from him than she wanted.

Odilia opened a window a few inches. Rain carried the smell of wet stone into the room.

"You needn't read everything today," she said.

"I think I need to."

They spent the afternoon sorting letters into three piles: personal keepsakes, papers relating to the family property, and notes that required discussion with other relatives. Elowen worked carefully, refusing the archivist's temptation to transform every feeling into a catalog entry. She stopped when she found a grocery receipt with her childhood handwriting on the back. She had drawn a crooked map of the city and written HOME beside a building that had since been demolished. She pressed it against her palm, remembering how confidently children label places without knowing how easily they can be lost.

Near sunset, Livia called to check on her. Elowen explained what they had found. Her mother was silent for so long that Elowen wondered whether the call had dropped.

"Your father often thought writing something down meant he had taken care of it," Livia finally said. "He wanted to be decent. He sometimes confused wanting with doing."

"Did you ever tell him?"

"More than once. I also let him avoid difficult things when I was tired. We were grown-ups. We knew better."

May you like

Elowen felt no satisfaction in hearing her mother accept a portion of responsibility. She wanted the past repaired, which no admission could accomplish.

Before leaving, she returned the unsent letter to the box and wrote a note recording where it had been found. She asked Odilia not to send it to Vespera yet. Its existence might explain some history, but it was not proof that either sister had been loved correctly. They would need time to decide what the document actually changed.

Related Stories

Other posts