Chapter 6 - THE EMAIL

Dorian printed the email chain.
Thaddeus insisted on paper.
"Screens encourage people to pretend words are temporary," he said.
They gathered in the morning room after Elysia returned from the outfitter. The new blazer was upstairs, still wrapped in tissue. Elysia had changed into a gray jumper and skirt, but she could feel the weight of the old blazer even though she was no longer wearing it.
The upright piano stood against the far wall.
Its walnut surface was dusty.
The little metronome that had belonged to Linette sat on top, motionless.
Dorian handed the first page to Thaddeus.
The message was from Orson to Severine, dated October 16.
Severine,
Please tell Mirelle we are suspending Elysia's lessons immediately. Do not mention the reserve issue to Father. I need his monthly transfers to continue until the vineyard sale completes and I can replace the funds. I will explain everything once the gap is closed.
O.
Elysia read the message twice.
Her father had not written that she was bored.
He had not written that she was too busy.
He had written that he needed Grandpa's transfers to continue.
Thaddeus set the paper down.
"So the plan required me to keep believing the lessons were being paid."
Orson looked exhausted.
"For a few months."
"That is a yes."
"I was going to replace every pound."
"That is not the same question."
Severine stood near the piano, one hand resting on the lid.
"I sent the cancellation email," she said.
No one answered.
She looked at Elysia.
"Your father asked me to. I should have refused."
Elysia's throat tightened.
"Why did you tell me I lost interest?"
Severine's fingers curled against the piano wood.
"Because I did not want to tell you the estate was in trouble."
"You could have said we had to stop for a while."
"Yes."
The immediate agreement unsettled Elysia.
She had expected an explanation, maybe even another lecture about adults.
Severine continued.
"I thought if I made it sound like a choice you had already made, you would not feel frightened about money."
"But it wasn't my choice."
"No."
"And Grandpa thought it was."
Severine looked down.
"Yes."
Elysia glanced at Orson.
"Did you know she told me that?"
He hesitated.
That was enough.
"Dad?"
"I knew the general explanation."
"Did you know?"
"Yes."
The word was quiet.
Elysia stared at him.
Something inside her hardened, not into hatred, but into clarity.
She had spent weeks wondering what was wrong with her. Why she could love playing and still somehow have "lost interest" without noticing. She had wondered whether adults could see parts of children that children could not see in themselves.
Now she understood.
They had not seen something she missed.
They had simply said something untrue because it made their problem easier.
Mirelle's reply was printed beneath Severine's cancellation email.
Mrs. Varel,
Elysia has shown no loss of interest in her lessons. She is progressing steadily and recently asked to begin preparation for the spring youth recital. If this is a financial matter, please tell me. I am willing to defer payment or reduce the fee temporarily. I do not want Elysia to believe she has failed.
Elysia stopped reading.
"She offered to teach me anyway?"
Severine closed her eyes briefly.
"Yes."
"You didn't tell me."
"No."
"Why?"
This time Orson answered.
"Because accepting charity from your teacher was unnecessary."
Thaddeus turned toward him.
"You preferred taking money from your daughter?"
"That is not what I meant."
"Then choose your words more carefully."
Orson's face flushed.
"I was protecting the family's dignity."
Elysia looked at the dusty keys.
"Whose dignity?"
No one answered.
She walked to the piano and lifted the fallboard.
The keys looked exactly as they had six weeks ago.
She pressed middle C.
The note sounded through the room, plain and slightly out of tune.
Severine flinched.
Thaddeus looked at Elysia.
"Would you like me to call Mirelle?"
Elysia nodded.
Orson spoke immediately.
"Not until we settle the account question."
Elysia's hand stayed on the key.
"Why?"
"Because this family needs to stop making emotional decisions in the middle of a financial review."
She turned on the bench.
"Is learning piano an emotional decision?"
Orson rubbed his forehead.
"That is not what I said."
Dorian's phone buzzed.
He glanced at it, frowned, and stepped toward the window.
"I need to take this."
A minute later he returned with an expression Elysia had learned to fear.
"There's another problem."
Thaddeus sighed.
"What now?"
Dorian looked at the piano.
"The estate asset schedule for the refinancing includes the contents of this room."
Severine went still.
Elysia's hand lifted from the keys.
May you like
Dorian continued.
"Including the piano."