Chapter 22 - THE RULES FOR THE RECITAL

Elysia wrote the rules down.
She did not have to, but writing helped.
1. Dad can come.
2. Dad sits in the back.
3. No flowers before I play.
4. Do not tell people I am "back to normal."
5. If I make a mistake, nobody talks about it in the car unless I do first.
She showed the list to Mirelle before she showed Orson.
Mirelle read it without smiling.
"Anything else?"
"Is five too many?"
"No."
"Is number four rude?"
"No. Why did you write it?"
Elysia looked at the keys.
"Because I'm not back to normal."
Mirelle nodded.
"Good enough reason."
Orson read the list that evening.
He paused at the fourth rule.
"I have said that, haven't I?"
"Twice."
"I meant you seemed happier."
"Then say happier."
He nodded.
"Fair."
He signed the bottom of the page as if it were a contract.
Elysia laughed.
"You don't have to sign it."
"I've had a complicated year with agreements. I'm trying to improve."
She laughed again before deciding whether she wanted to.
It startled both of them.
The recital was still five days away.
In the meantime, Severine took Elysia shopping for winter boots.
Not because the old pair had suddenly become unusable. Because Elysia had checked the box saying she wanted to choose.
At the shop, Severine picked up a polished black pair.
"These would last."
Elysia tried them on.
They pinched.
"I don't like them."
Severine opened her mouth.
Elysia saw the old response preparing itself: they are sensible; you will get used to them; adults understand quality.
Severine closed her mouth.
"All right."
Elysia tried a brown pair with sturdy soles.
"These."
"They are less formal."
Elysia looked up.
Severine smiled faintly.
"Observation, not veto."
They bought the brown boots.
On the drive home, Severine said, "I have been thinking about the recital."
Elysia waited.
"I would like to attend. But I don't want you to assume I am coming."
Elysia appreciated the awkwardness of the sentence.
It meant Severine was trying.
"You can come."
"Any rules?"
"Same as Dad. But you don't have to sit in the back."
Severine glanced over.
"Why not?"
"Because you never told Mirelle to stop taking the money."
Severine's expression tightened.
"I still told you something untrue."
"I know."
"You don't have to rank us."
Elysia looked out the window.
"I'm not."
She wasn't.
Children could be hurt by two people differently without needing to decide who was worse.
That night, Thaddeus asked for his own recital permission.
"Where am I allowed to sit?"
Elysia pretended to think.
"Front."
"An honor."
"But no clapping before the piece is finished."
Thaddeus looked offended.
"I know concert etiquette."
"You clapped after my first scale when lessons started again."
"That was an exceptional scale."
Elysia giggled.
Then she grew serious.
"Grandpa?"
"Yes?"
"If Dad never gets the estate job back, will you think that's good?"
Thaddeus considered.
"I will think the board should decide based on what protects the estate and the people connected to it."
"That's not what I asked."
He smiled sadly.
"No. It isn't."
He folded his hands.
"Part of me wants him restored because he is my son and I know how much the role means to him. Part of me fears restoration because I know what he did. Both feelings are real. Neither should decide the governance question."
Elysia liked that answer because it admitted adults could want contradictory things.
"Do you want me to forgive him?"
Thaddeus looked surprised.
"That is not mine to want on your behalf."
"Everybody says forgiving is good."
"It can be. So can waiting. So can forgiving one thing and not another."
Elysia looked at her recital score.
"I don't know yet."
"Then you know enough for now."
The next morning, a courier delivered a package from Edinburgh.
Inside was not the orchard painting.
It was a high-resolution photograph of the back of the canvas, showing the exact place where Linette's envelope had been hidden.
Attached was a note from Gideon March.
If Elysia ever wishes to own the painting her mother loved, I will give the family first opportunity if I decide to sell. Until then, I thought she might like proof that the letter truly waited there all these years.
Elysia held the photograph.
Then she noticed one faint line written directly on the wooden stretcher behind the canvas.
May you like
In Linette's handwriting:
LET HER CHOOSE.