Chapter 10 - WHAT THADDEUS SOLD

The cello had belonged to Thaddeus first.
That was the part no one had told Elysia.
Orson stood beside the locked drawer, looking not at his daughter but at his father.
"Go on," he said. "Tell her."
Thaddeus remained still.
Severine looked between them.
"Tell her what?"
Orson laughed once, bitterly.
"That this family has been financing emergencies with children's music for generations."
Elysia's skin prickled.
Thaddeus moved to the chair opposite Orson and sat down.
"When your father was twelve," he said to Elysia, "the estate had a bad year. Two, actually. There was a tax judgment and damage after a winter storm. I sold his cello."
Orson's jaw tightened.
"Not just the cello."
Thaddeus nodded.
"I stopped his lessons."
"And what did you tell me?"
Thaddeus looked at him.
"That everyone in the family had to contribute."
"No." Orson's voice sharpened. "You told me I was old enough to understand priorities. You told me music was a luxury. You told Grandmother I had lost interest because you were ashamed to tell her you needed money."
Elysia felt as if someone had opened a hidden door inside the room.
The same sentences.
Not exactly, but close enough.
Thaddeus looked down at his hands.
"Yes."
Orson turned toward Elysia.
"Do you see? He is sitting there judging me for repeating the lesson he taught me."
Elysia did not know where to look.
Part of her wanted Thaddeus to deny it.
He did not.
"I did teach you that," he said.
Orson blinked, perhaps surprised by the admission.
Thaddeus continued.
"And I was wrong."
"Convenient."
"No. Late. There is a difference."
"You got the estate through the crisis."
"At your expense."
"And now you intend to punish me for doing what kept this place standing."
Thaddeus's eyes hardened.
"No. I intend to stop pretending survival makes every method honorable."
Silence.
Elysia looked at the piano through the open study doorway across the hall. From this angle she could see only one edge of it.
A black line in a bright room.
Orson walked to the window.
"When Linette left me the cello, she thought it was funny," he said. "She found it years later at an auction in Bath. Bought it back without telling me."
Severine's expression softened despite herself.
"I didn't know that."
"She gave it to me on our tenth anniversary."
His voice lowered.
"I never played it. Not once."
Elysia looked at the memorandum.
"Where is it now?"
Orson stared outside.
"Sold."
"When?"
"After she died."
Thaddeus inhaled slowly.
Orson turned around.
"I could not look at it. The hospital bills were real. The debts were real. And every time I saw that cello, I heard her asking me why I wouldn't play for her. So I sold it."
For the first time, Elysia saw her father not as the man who had taken her piano money, but as a boy who had lost music before he knew how to argue for it.
The understanding hurt because it did not erase anything.
If anything, it made the question worse.
"Then why did you do it to me?" she asked.
Orson's face changed.
No one moved.
Elysia's voice remained small.
"If you hated when Grandpa did it, why did you do it to me?"
Orson opened his mouth.
Closed it.
He looked at Thaddeus as if the answer might still be there.
It was not.
Severine looked down.
Dorian quietly gathered the papers, giving the silence somewhere to go.
Finally Orson said, "I thought I was protecting you from the fear."
"But you made me think I was the problem."
He flinched.
Elysia stood.
She did not feel brave. Her knees were shaking.
"I don't want to talk anymore."
Thaddeus started to rise.
"Do you want me to-"
"No."
He stopped.
The word sounded strange in her own mouth.
Clearer than she expected.
She left the study alone.
Upstairs, she went to her room and opened the bottom desk drawer.
Under school papers and a broken pencil case was the folded list.
THINGS I CAN STOP NEEDING.
She read each line.
Then she turned the page over.
On the blank side, she wrote a new heading.
THINGS I DID NOT CHOOSE TO GIVE UP.
The first line was easy.
PIANO.
The second took longer.
TRUSTING DAD WHEN HE SAYS LATER.
She stared at the words until footsteps stopped outside her door.
Orson knocked once.
"Elysia?"
May you like
She did not answer.
After a moment, he said through the door, "There's something else you need to know about your account."