Chapter 23 - THE NIGHT BEFORE

The night before the recital, Elysia wanted to quit.
Not piano.
The recital.
The distinction mattered, but fear did not care about distinctions.
She had played the piece perfectly twice that week. On Friday evening, she could not get past the third page without making the same mistake.
Her left hand arrived late.
Then early.
Then struck two notes at once.
Elysia shoved the bench backward.
"I can't do it."
Mirelle, who had stayed for an extra rehearsal, closed the score.
"Can't do what?"
"Play tomorrow."
"You can withdraw."
The immediate permission made Elysia angry.
"You're supposed to tell me I can do it."
Mirelle raised an eyebrow.
"You can do it. You may still choose not to."
"That's not helpful."
"Choice often isn't."
Elysia crossed her arms.
Mirelle waited.
Finally Elysia said, "What if everyone thinks I stopped lessons because I wasn't good?"
There it was.
Not the notes.
The story around the notes.
Mirelle sat on the bench.
"Some people may think many things. You cannot play a piece accurately enough to control every story people invent about you."
"But Grandpa knows. Dad knows. Severine knows."
"Yes."
"What if they watch me make a mistake and think stopping was right?"
Mirelle looked toward the doorway.
Orson was there.
He had arrived silently and heard enough.
Elysia stiffened.
He took one step back.
"I can leave."
She almost said yes.
Then she asked, "Would you think that?"
Orson did not pretend not to understand.
"No."
"How do I know?"
He looked at the piano.
"You don't. Not just because I say it."
That answer hurt and helped at the same time.
He continued.
"But if you want to know what I am trying to learn: a mistake is not permission for me to decide you never wanted something."
Elysia's eyes stung.
Mirelle remained silent.
Orson stepped farther into the room.
"When I was twelve, after my cello was sold, I told myself I must not have loved playing very much."
Thaddeus had entered the hall behind him.
He stopped when he heard.
Orson continued.
"That story was easier than admitting I loved it and someone else decided it was expendable. Years later, when you stopped piano, I told myself you would get over it because children change interests. I knew better. I used the same story because it made me feel less cruel."
Thaddeus lowered his gaze.
Elysia looked between them.
"Did Grandpa think you got over cello?"
Orson smiled without humor.
"He convinced himself I did."
Thaddeus spoke from the doorway.
"Yes."
Elysia stared at the score.
"So if I quit the recital tonight, does that mean I don't want piano?"
Mirelle answered.
"No. It means you quit one recital."
The room was quiet.
Elysia slid back onto the bench.
"I don't want to quit the recital."
"Then don't."
She opened the music again.
"But I'm scared."
"You may be scared and play."
Elysia placed her fingers on the keys.
The first measure sounded cautious.
The second was stronger.
At the troublesome crossing, her left hand arrived slightly late.
She did not stop.
When she reached the final chord, no one clapped.
Elysia looked around.
Thaddeus had remembered his rule.
Orson had remembered too.
Mirelle smiled.
"Again?"
Elysia nodded.
They rehearsed until eight-thirty.
Before bed, Elysia placed the photograph of the back of her mother's painting beside the recital program.
LET HER CHOOSE.
May you like
She turned off the lamp.
For the first time in weeks, she slept without dreaming about bank statements, locked drawers, or adults speaking over her.