scribe

Chapter 4 - - Things That Happened

The family meeting began Saturday morning at ten and almost ended at ten twelve.

Thayer put four mugs on the kitchen table even though only the adults drank coffee. Aurelie had hot chocolate. Lorcan had milk.

The arrangement felt formal enough to make everyone uncomfortable.

Aurelie brought her notebook.

Lorcan stared at it as if it contained criminal charges.

Nerissa noticed.

"She's allowed to have notes," she told him.

Aurelie looked at her stepmother.

That small sentence mattered.

Thayer began.

"We're not here to decide who is a good person and who is a bad person. We're here because something in this house hasn't been working."

Aurelie waited for the familiar ending: and we all have a part in it.

It did not come.

Instead, Thayer looked at her.

"You asked us to listen. So we're listening."

Aurelie opened the notebook.

Her hands trembled slightly.

She read the first item.

"The twenty dollars from Nerissa's purse."

Nerissa nodded.

"I accused you before we found out Lorcan used it."

"Three times."

Nerissa swallowed. "Three times."

Aurelie moved to the next item.

"The vase."

Lorcan stared at his milk.

"I knocked it over," he whispered.

"You said I bumped you."

"I know."

"And I got sent upstairs."

Nerissa rubbed her hands together.

"Yes."

Next came the folder.

Then the juice on Thayer's blueprints.

Then the deleted game.

Then the spelling-test insult.

Not every memory was clean.

On one occasion, Aurelie had snapped at Lorcan. On another, the two children genuinely had been arguing when something broke.

But a pattern emerged anyway.

Lorcan made mistakes and feared consequences.

He discovered that blaming Aurelie often worked.

Nerissa believed him more quickly than she believed Aurelie.

Thayer, when present, focused on ending the conflict rather than examining the pattern.

Aurelie had slowly become louder because quiet explanations failed.

Then her loudness became evidence that she was difficult.

When she finished, nobody spoke for several seconds.

Lorcan was crying again.

This time Nerissa did not immediately reach for him.

"Lorcan," she said gently, "I need you to tell the truth about something. Have you blamed Aurelie on purpose because you thought I would believe you?"

He rubbed his face with both hands.

"Sometimes."

Aurelie's stomach turned.

The answer hurt even though she had expected it.

Thayer leaned forward.

"How many times?"

"I don't know."

"More than twice?"

Lorcan nodded.

"More than five?"

Nerissa looked at Thayer.

"Don't interrogate him."

Aurelie stiffened.

Nerissa immediately corrected herself.

"Sorry. That sounded like I was protecting him from the question."

Lorcan looked at his mother.

Nerissa continued, "You do need to answer honestly."

He whispered, "Maybe."

Aurelie stared at him.

"Why?"

He shrugged.

"Because Mom gets mad at you."

The room went still.

Nerissa's face drained of color.

Lorcan continued, too young to understand the full weight of what he was saying.

"And when she gets mad at me, I hate it."

Nerissa pressed her lips together.

Aurelie felt suddenly dizzy.

She had imagined a hundred explanations for why Lorcan lied.

None felt as simple or as ugly as the truth.

He lied because it worked.

Nerissa had taught him, without meaning to, that Aurelie was a safe place to put blame.

Thayer leaned back.

"Okay."

Aurelie almost laughed.

Of course he said okay.

But he did not try to move on.

He looked at Nerissa.

"We have a serious problem."

She nodded.

"I know."

Her eyes were wet now.

Aurelie looked away.

Nerissa spoke to Lorcan first.

"You are responsible for lying. Even if you thought I would believe you, you chose to let your sister get blamed. That's not acceptable."

Lorcan nodded.

Then Nerissa turned to Aurelie.

"And I am responsible for making that strategy effective."

Aurelie looked at her.

Nerissa's voice shook.

"I need to say something without asking you to make me feel better about it."

Aurelie waited.

"I think I have been harder on you because you're older."

"That's not all."

"No."

Nerissa looked at Thayer, then back at Aurelie.

"I think I have also been defensive around you because I am your stepmother."

Aurelie frowned.

"What does that mean?"

Nerissa took a slow breath.

"When I first married your dad, I was terrified of being the woman who tried too hard to replace your mother. So I told myself I would be practical. Fair. Not overly emotional. Then Lorcan was born, and loving him was simple because nobody could accuse me of replacing anyone."

Aurelie's chest tightened.

Her biological mother, Celeste, lived in Oregon and spoke with her by video call every other week. She and Thayer had divorced when Aurelie was three. Celeste was not absent, but distance had made daily life belong mostly to Thayer and Nerissa.

Nerissa continued.

"With you, I think I started watching myself so carefully that I became colder. And once you got older, I told myself that meant I was respecting you. But maybe some of that distance became suspicion."

Aurelie stared at her.

"Why would being my stepmom make you think I lie?"

"It shouldn't."

"But it did."

"I think I started interpreting your anger as rejection. Every time you were upset with me, a part of me thought, Of course. I'm not her real mother. Then I defended myself before I listened to you."

Aurelie's eyes filled.

"I never asked you to be my real mom."

"I know."

"I just wanted you to believe me."

Nerissa lowered her head.

"I know."

Lorcan began crying harder.

"I don't want Aurelie to hate me."

Aurelie looked at him.

"I don't hate you."

He looked up.

"But I'm mad at you," she said. "Really mad."

He nodded miserably.

"You don't get to make me stop being mad because you're sorry."

Another nod.

Thayer glanced at Aurelie with something like surprise.

She noticed.

"What?"

"Nothing."

"You look surprised."

He gave a small, sad smile.

"You sound older than twelve."

Aurelie's expression hardened.

"That's not a compliment."

Thayer's smile vanished.

"You're right."

The meeting lasted two hours.

They created new rules.

No accusation before questions.

No punishment while facts were unclear.

No using age as a reason one child's word should matter less or more.

No automatic demand that Aurelie forgive Lorcan because he was younger.

Lorcan would lose game privileges for three weeks, pay half his saved allowance toward the television, and complete extra household chores. Not because the television mattered more than the lie, Nerissa said, but because causing damage still had consequences.

They also agreed to see a family counselor.

That idea made Aurelie uncomfortable.

"Does that mean you think something is wrong with us?" she asked.

Thayer answered, "Something is wrong with how we've been handling things. That's different."

When the meeting ended, Aurelie closed her notebook.

Nerissa reached toward the mugs, then stopped.

"Aurelie?"

"Yeah?"

"Thank you for writing it down."

Aurelie did not say you're welcome.

She simply picked up her mug and carried it to the sink.

Later that afternoon, Lorcan knocked on her bedroom door.

He stood in the hallway holding the soccer ball.

"Mom said I can't use it inside anymore."

Aurelie looked at him.

"Obviously."

He stared at the floor.

"I wanted to say sorry without Mom telling me."

Aurelie crossed her arms.

"Okay."

"I'm sorry I lied."

She waited.

"And I'm sorry I looked at you before I did it."

That detail startled her.

Lorcan's chin trembled.

"I knew you wanted me to tell the truth."

Aurelie swallowed.

"Yeah."

"I was scared."

"I know."

"Does that make it better?"

"No."

He nodded.

"Okay."

He turned to leave.

Aurelie almost called him back.

She did not.

May you like

Not because she wanted him to suffer.

Because for once, she did not want the family's discomfort to become her responsibility to fix.

Related Stories

Other posts