Chapter 15 - - Nerissa at the School Office

Two weeks after the group project, Aurelie was called to the assistant principal's office.
A student named Paige Holloway had accused her of stealing a silver mechanical pencil from art class.
Aurelie felt physically sick when she heard the accusation.
"I didn't take it."
Assistant Principal Cooper nodded.
"I'm not saying you did."
But there was a clear plastic bag on the desk containing the pencil.
It had been found in Aurelie's backpack.
Her mouth went dry.
"I don't know how that got there."
Paige sat in another chair with her arms crossed.
"It has my initials on it."
"I know. I saw you using it."
"Then why was it in your bag?"
"I don't know."
The room tilted toward an old nightmare.
A broken television.
A stepmother's folded arms.
Children don't lie.
Aurelie's eyes filled.
The school called Nerissa because Thayer was in Albany.
Aurelie expected the drive from home to give Nerissa time to build a conclusion.
When Nerissa arrived, she sat beside Aurelie.
She looked at the pencil.
Then at Mr. Cooper.
"What facts do we have?"
Aurelie turned toward her.
Mr. Cooper explained that Paige reported the pencil missing after art class. A teacher searched the immediate area. Later, during science, the pencil fell from Aurelie's backpack when she moved it.
"Did anyone see Aurelie take it?" Nerissa asked.
"No."
"Did anyone see Paige put it down?"
"She says she left it on the art table."
"Was Aurelie alone near that table?"
Mr. Cooper checked a note.
"No. There were twelve students cleaning up."
Nerissa nodded.
"Then we know the pencil was found in Aurelie's backpack. We do not know how it got there."
Paige protested.
"Why would somebody put it there?"
Nerissa turned toward her, not unkindly.
"I don't know. But not having another explanation doesn't make the first explanation automatically true."
Aurelie stared at her stepmother.
Mr. Cooper agreed to review hallway and classroom camera footage where available.
Nerissa did not demand Aurelie be cleared immediately. She did not attack Paige. She did not insist her stepdaughter would never do such a thing.
She simply refused to let uncertainty become guilt.
In the car, Aurelie was silent for several minutes.
Nerissa drove without pressing her.
Finally Aurelie said, "You believed me."
Nerissa glanced at her.
"I believed that you said you didn't take it. I also knew we didn't have enough facts."
"That's not the same thing."
"No."
Aurelie looked out the window.
"Before, you would've thought I took it."
Nerissa's hands tightened on the wheel.
"Probably."
The honesty hurt and healed at the same time.
The next afternoon the school called.
A hallway camera showed Paige's friend, Lacey, picking up the pencil after class. Lacey later admitted slipping it into Aurelie's open backpack as a joke after Paige complained that Aurelie was "teacher's favorite."
The school issued consequences.
Paige apologized for accusing Aurelie.
Lacey apologized for planting the pencil.
Aurelie accepted neither apology immediately.
At dinner that night, Thayer joined by video call from Albany.
"I'm proud of you," he told Nerissa.
Nerissa frowned.
"For what?"
"For how you handled the school."
She shook her head.
"I did what I should have been doing all along."
Thayer went quiet.
Aurelie looked at Nerissa.
That answer mattered more than praise would have.
After dinner, Aurelie found Nerissa loading the dishwasher.
"Hey."
Nerissa looked up.
Aurelie hesitated.
Then she hugged her.
Nerissa went completely still.
She did not squeeze too tightly. She did not say finally. She did not cry.
She simply put one arm around Aurelie and let the moment be what it was.
When Aurelie stepped back, Nerissa smiled.
"Good night."
"Good night."
Aurelie went upstairs feeling strangely light.
The school incident had frightened her.
May you like
But it had also given her something the television video never could.
Proof that when there was no recording, no obvious culprit, and no certainty, Nerissa could still choose not to make Aurelie defend her innocence alone.