scribe

Chapter 18 - - What Thayer Left for Nerissa to Carry

Aurelie was not supposed to hear the argument.

It began after midnight.

She had gone downstairs for water and stopped on the staircase when she heard Nerissa say her name.

"You left me to be the parent who says no."

Thayer answered quietly. "That's not true."

"It is. You traveled. You worked late. You came home and wanted peace. When Aurelie was angry at a rule, you softened it. When Lorcan melted down, I handled it. Then you wondered why I became rigid."

Aurelie sat down on the step.

Thayer said, "You're not blaming the favoritism on me."

"No. That part is mine. I am saying our marriage built the conditions where I became resentful and you stayed likable."

Silence.

Aurelie had never thought of her father as the likable parent.

He was just Dad.

Nerissa continued.

"Do you know how many times you told Aurelie yes after I had already said no because you didn't want her upset with you?"

"Give me an example."

"The seventh-grade dance. The sleepover at Willa's. The phone curfew. You made me look unreasonable, then disappeared on Monday and left me to enforce the next boundary."

Thayer's voice dropped.

"I didn't realize."

"I know."

The exhaustion in Nerissa's answer made Aurelie's chest tighten.

This did not excuse what Nerissa had done.

But it added a truth Aurelie had not seen.

Her stepmother had sometimes been unfair partly because the adults themselves were not parenting as a team.

Thayer had avoided being the bad guy.

Nerissa had collected the resentment.

Then some of that resentment had landed on the older child who challenged her more.

The next morning, Aurelie said nothing about overhearing them.

At counseling, however, Thayer brought it up himself.

"Nerissa and I realized we have a co-parenting problem that predates the television."

Helena asked them to explain.

Aurelie listened.

Then she said, "So Dad got to be fun and Nerissa got meaner?"

Thayer winced.

"Simplified, but not completely wrong."

Nerissa looked at Aurelie.

"I still chose how I treated you."

"I know."

"Understanding the pressure doesn't erase the choices."

"I know."

Aurelie appreciated that Nerissa kept saying it.

Helena assigned the adults a separate couples session.

Lorcan groaned.

"Everybody gets therapy now."

"Apparently," Thayer said.

Aurelie laughed.

Over the next month, the parents changed practical things.

Rules were discussed privately before being announced. Thayer stopped reversing Nerissa's decisions in front of the children unless safety required it. Nerissa stopped presenting her preferences as universal household law.

Most importantly, both adults took turns being the unpopular parent.

When Aurelie asked to attend a concert on a school night, Thayer said no after reviewing the travel time.

She argued.

He listened.

He still said no.

Nerissa did not rescue her.

Aurelie was furious for an evening.

Then she noticed something strange.

She was angry at her father without worrying what the anger meant about their relationship.

Maybe Nerissa had been right about one thing from the beginning.

Family could survive ordinary anger.

The problem was not conflict.

The problem was what people did with it.

The adults' separate counseling sessions produced one change Aurelie did not expect: apologies between Thayer and Nerissa became less theatrical.

Before, an argument often ended with one of them making a large peace offering. Thayer brought flowers. Nerissa cooked his favorite dinner. The gesture told the house the conflict was over, but nobody explained what would be different next time.

Now they repaired in smaller, stranger ways.

When Thayer contradicted Nerissa in front of the children about a weekend curfew, he later said at dinner, "I changed the rule without discussing it with Nerissa. That put her in a bad position. We talked, and the original time stands tonight."

Aurelie hated the result.

"So therapy makes my curfew worse?"

"Sometimes growth is tragic," Thayer said.

Nerissa laughed.

But Aurelie also noticed that Nerissa did not have to become the villain to restore the boundary.

Another evening Nerissa snapped at Thayer for forgetting groceries he had never agreed to buy. Ten minutes later she said, "I was angry about three other things and assigned you a fourth. That's mine."

Thayer answered, "Thank you."

No flowers appeared.

No one needed them.

The children were learning from those exchanges too.

One Friday Aurelie borrowed Nerissa's portable charger without asking and forgot it in her backpack. Nerissa searched for it before work and became frustrated.

When Aurelie came home, Nerissa said, "I needed that today."

Aurelie started to defend herself.

"My phone was at six percent and--"

Then she stopped.

The explanation was true. It was also irrelevant to the part she owned.

"I should have asked."

Nerissa nodded.

"Yes."

"Sorry."

"Thank you."

That was it.

Aurelie took the charger upstairs and thought about how strange it felt that accountability could be so undramatic when nobody was trying to protect an identity.

If she did something inconsiderate, she did not become The Difficult One.

If Nerissa made an unfair assumption, she did not become The Evil Stepmother.

If Thayer avoided conflict, he did not become A Bad Father forever.

If Lorcan lied, he did not become A Liar as a permanent noun.

Actions could be serious without becoming identities.

That idea mattered deeply to Aurelie because the original television incident had hurt partly by turning her into a category before facts existed.

Careless.

Dishonest.

Jealous of her brother.

Once adults believed the category, every new event fit inside it.

Now the family practiced describing behavior instead.

You interrupted me twice.

I blamed you before asking.

You lied about the vase.

I changed the rule without talking to your stepmother.

Specific facts left room for people to become different tomorrow.

Categories did not.

At their next family session, Aurelie told Helena this.

Helena smiled.

"That is one of the most important differences in conflict. Behavior can be accountable. Identity becomes a prison."

Thayer reached for his notebook.

Aurelie pointed at him.

"Do not write that down."

He froze.

Everyone laughed.

Then he wrote it down anyway.

Thayer's couples counseling also forced him to revisit the family he grew up in.

His parents, Aurelie's grandparents, were still married and still capable of arguing through an entire holiday meal without raising their voices. That was what made the fights confusing. They were quiet fights full of sarcasm, slammed cabinet doors, and days of silence.

As a child, Thayer had learned that the safest person in the house was the one who needed least.

He became agreeable.

He did homework without reminders. He cleaned before anyone asked. He told whichever parent was angrier that he understood. When his younger brother Corvin got into trouble, Thayer often smoothed things over before their parents could escalate.

He had been praised constantly for being mature.

When Helena pointed out the similarity to Aurelie, Thayer went silent for nearly a minute.

That evening he asked Aurelie to take a walk with him.

The neighborhood was cold and dark. Their breath showed under the streetlights.

"I owe you an apology I haven't made yet," he said.

Aurelie shoved her hands deeper into her coat pockets.

"For what?"

"For liking that you were easy."

She looked at him.

"We already talked about that."

"Not this part. I think I liked it because I recognized it. I was the easy kid too."

Aurelie walked silently beside him.

"Did Grandma and Grandpa not believe you?"

"Not exactly. They depended on me not to create another problem. That's different, but it teaches some of the same lesson."

"That being good means being low maintenance."

"Yes."

They passed Mrs. Ansel's house. Her porch light cast a square of yellow onto the sidewalk.

Thayer continued. "When you got upset, I think part of me wanted you to go back to being the kid who made parenting feel easy. So instead of asking why you were angry, I treated the anger itself as the problem."

Aurelie's throat tightened.

"I thought you liked Lorcan more sometimes."

Thayer stopped walking.

"No."

"I know that now."

"I'm sorry you ever had a reason to wonder."

They stood under a bare maple tree.

Aurelie looked at him.

"I don't want you to overcorrect and act like everything I do is deep because I had a hard year."

Thayer smiled faintly.

"Deal."

"Sometimes I'm just being annoying."

"I have noticed."

She bumped his shoulder.

They resumed walking.

The conversation did not transform anything instantly. But afterward Thayer became more careful about praise.

Instead of telling Aurelie he was proud because she never needed reminders, he praised specific effort. Instead of calling Lorcan difficult when he struggled, he described the behavior that needed work.

The labels slowly lost power.

May you like

In their place came descriptions.

And descriptions, Aurelie learned, were much easier to change.

Related Stories

Other posts