scribe

Chapter 2 - - Evidence Is Not Trust

Nerissa was waiting at the kitchen table when Aurelie came downstairs.

Lorcan sat beside her with his hands folded in his lap. The soccer ball had been placed on top of the refrigerator, far above his reach. From the living room, the fallen television was still visible on the carpet.

Nerissa pointed to the chair across from her.

"Sit down."

Aurelie remained standing.

"I have something to show you."

Nerissa's mouth tightened slightly. "We can talk first."

"No."

The word surprised all three of them.

Aurelie almost never said no to Nerissa directly.

She placed the tablet on the table.

Lorcan's face changed before Nerissa's did.

His eyes dropped.

That was enough to tell Aurelie he already understood.

She opened the video and pressed play.

Nobody spoke.

On the small screen, Lorcan's foot swung. The ball flew. The television cracked. Aurelie rose from the sofa.

Then the recorded argument began.

Nerissa watched herself enter the living room and accuse Aurelie without asking a question.

Aurelie watched Nerissa instead of the video.

At "I've heard enough lies," Nerissa's jaw shifted.

At Lorcan's "No. She knocked it over," Lorcan covered his face with both hands.

At "Children don't lie," Nerissa closed her eyes.

The clip ended.

The kitchen became very quiet.

Aurelie locked the tablet and pulled it toward herself.

Nerissa looked at Lorcan.

"Go to your room."

Lorcan looked frightened.

"Mom--"

"Now."

He slid off the chair.

Aurelie spoke before he could leave.

"No."

Nerissa turned toward her.

"Aurelie--"

"He lied in front of me. He should hear this too."

Lorcan stood beside his chair, uncertain.

Nerissa took a slow breath.

"All right."

She looked at Aurelie.

"You were telling the truth."

Aurelie waited.

"I'm sorry."

The apology should have felt like victory.

It did not.

"For what?" Aurelie asked.

Nerissa frowned. "For blaming you for the television."

"That's not the part I'm mad about."

"Then what part?"

Aurelie could feel her heart beating in her throat.

"You didn't even ask me what happened. You saw me standing there and decided it was me. Then when I told you what happened, you called me a liar."

Nerissa looked toward the tablet.

"I was upset. I heard a crash."

"You weren't confused. You were sure."

"Aurelie--"

"You said I always blame him."

Nerissa's expression changed.

Lorcan stared at the table.

Aurelie continued.

"The money from your purse. The bathroom vase. His folder. Every time something happens, you think I did it or you think I'm blaming him."

Nerissa leaned back.

"Those situations were complicated."

"No, they weren't. They only became complicated because you didn't believe me."

The words hung between them.

Nerissa's face became guarded.

"I don't think this is fair."

Aurelie laughed once, without humor.

"Exactly."

Lorcan began to cry quietly.

Nerissa immediately turned toward him.

"Honey--"

Aurelie stood.

"See?"

Nerissa froze.

"I didn't say anything to him," Aurelie said. "He lied about me, and you're already worried about how he feels."

Lorcan wiped his nose with his sleeve.

"I said I'm sorry."

"You didn't say anything."

"I am sorry," he whispered.

Aurelie looked at him.

He looked smaller than he had in the living room.

For a moment, she felt guilty for making him cry. Then she remembered the way he had looked into her eyes before lying.

"Why did you do it?" she asked.

Lorcan's mouth trembled.

"I thought Mom would be mad."

"So you made her mad at me."

He did not answer.

Nerissa put a hand on the table.

"Lorcan, lying about something this serious is not acceptable."

Aurelie looked at her.

"Would it be serious if I didn't have the video?"

Nerissa's face went still.

Aurelie picked up the tablet.

"That's what I want to know."

She left the kitchen before Nerissa could answer.

Upstairs, Aurelie sent the video to her own school email, then to the private cloud folder her father had set up for family photos.

She did not know why she did it.

Maybe because a part of her was afraid that if the tablet disappeared, the truth would disappear too.

That thought bothered her.

She sat at her desk and stared through the window at the bare branches in the backyard.

Her father, Thayer Varenne, would be home the next evening.

He had been in Connecticut for four days overseeing a construction inspection. He traveled more often than he used to, which meant many of the smaller arguments at home happened when he was gone.

Aurelie wondered what Nerissa would tell him.

She wondered whether Nerissa would show him the video.

She wondered whether he would say what he often said when Aurelie and Nerissa argued.

Let's not make this bigger than it needs to be.

That sentence had once sounded reasonable.

Now Aurelie heard something else inside it.

Let's make this small enough that nobody has to change.

There was a knock on her bedroom door.

"Can I come in?" Nerissa asked.

Aurelie did not answer immediately.

Then she said, "Okay."

Nerissa entered but did not cross the room. She stood near the door with both hands folded in front of her.

"Lorcan is grounded from the game console for two weeks," she said. "And he's going to use his allowance toward replacing the television."

Aurelie nodded.

"I also told him he has to apologize to you."

"Okay."

Nerissa waited.

"I want to apologize again."

Aurelie looked at her.

"I shouldn't have called you a liar."

"Why did you?"

Nerissa opened her mouth, then stopped.

"I don't know."

Aurelie's eyes stung again.

"That's worse."

Nerissa looked as though she had been slapped.

Aurelie hated that expression because it made her want to comfort the adult who had hurt her.

She looked away.

"Dad needs to see the video," she said.

"I know."

"I want to show him."

Nerissa nodded slowly.

"All right."

"And I don't want you to tell him first."

That request made Nerissa stiffen.

"Why?"

"Because every time something happens, the first person who tells the story gets to decide what the story is."

Nerissa stared at her stepdaughter.

Aurelie had not planned the sentence. It simply came out.

After a moment, Nerissa said, "Okay."

Then she left.

Aurelie remained at her desk until the light outside faded.

Downstairs, she heard Nerissa making dinner and Lorcan moving quietly through the house.

Nobody turned on the broken television.

The living room, usually full of noise, stayed silent.

For once, Aurelie did not mind the silence.

May you like

It felt like everyone was waiting for something.

She was too.

Related Stories

Other posts