Chapter 17

The Table Between Them
Alaric requested a meeting at a quiet restaurant on the waterfront, saying he wanted to discuss practical matters. Elowen agreed only after writing down the conditions: a public place, no surprise guests, no attempt to arrange medical care, and permission to leave at any moment. She asked Celestine to accompany her. She did not ask Merritt, because she wanted her father to understand that she could speak for herself.
The restaurant overlooked moored sailboats and a strip of gray-blue sea. Alaric was already seated, perfectly dressed, when they arrived. He stood and pulled out a chair for Elowen, as though courtesy could create a bridge above the conflict.
"You look well," he said.
"I am receiving care," she answered.
He glanced at her abdomen and quickly away. "Your mother tells me you're staying comfortably."
"Nell has been kind. I'm working."
"Photographing buildings," he said, with faint disbelief. "At least you are using that camera for something beyond diversion."
Celestine put down her menu. "You asked to discuss arrangements, Alaric."
He slid a folder across the table. It contained a proposed allowance, college funding terms, and a temporary housing agreement in which Elowen would return home under the supervision of a family-appointed adviser. In exchange, she would cease public discussion of the pregnancy and follow a "mutually agreed medical plan." No medical plan had been mutually agreed.
Elowen read every page. The waiter brought water. Sailboat rigging rang faintly against metal masts outside. She placed the papers neatly back in the folder.
"I won't sign."
"You haven't considered the scale of what I'm offering."
"I read every line. You're still offering support on the condition that I surrender the decisions."
"That is not an accurate description."
"Then remove the conditions."
Alaric looked at Celestine. "Has she told you what raising a child at her age entails? The sleeplessness? The expense? The way opportunities disappear?"
"Yes," Celestine said. "We have discussed all of that."
"And you encourage her?"
"I encourage her to understand her choices and get support. Those aren't the same as pretending everything will be easy."
His composure faltered. "I have spent seventeen years protecting her from hardship."
Elowen folded her hands on the table so he would not see them shake. "Dad, I'm grateful you paid for my schooling. I know you worked to give me things other people don't have. But when I needed you to listen, you hit me. Then you told me you wouldn't have a daughter unless I did what you wanted. I need you to understand that I can't return to the way things were just because you've prepared another folder."
For an instant he looked older. His eyes dropped to his watch, and she could see him gathering the parts of his reply.
"My father expected results," he said. "He didn't make room for excuses. I learned to survive that. I was not trying to hurt you."
"You did hurt me."
"I was frightened."
"Then say you're frightened. Don't make me responsible for stopping it."
Alaric watched the harbor through the window as though hoping the water might offer a simpler answer than his daughter. "What happens if Merritt leaves?" he asked. "What happens if the school takes back its offer? You have a plan that depends on other people behaving well."
"So did yours," Elowen answered. "You expected everyone you called to keep opening doors. And you expected me to want the room on the other side."
"I expected you to be safe."
"Then ask what I will do when things go wrong. I have a backup plan for child care. I have a second list of places I can live. I know the school might be too much all at once, and I'm prepared to change my schedule. Those things aren't proof that I'm helpless. They're proof that I'm trying."
Alaric considered replying that none of her alternatives matched the life he had prepared. The look on her face stopped him. He recognized determination there, the same determination he had praised when she won debates and difficult examinations. Only the direction had changed. He could not decide whether that was the most painful part of the afternoon or the first thing he could understand.
The waiter returned to ask whether they were ready to order. Alaric said they were not. When the young man left, silence spread across the table. Elowen felt hungry and exhausted, but the greater exhaustion came from watching her father search for a way to retain authority without changing his behavior.
"If I remove the conditions," he asked eventually, "what assurance do I have that you'll make sensible choices?"
"You don't," she said. "Parents never have that assurance. They can help their children learn, but they can't own the outcome."
Celestine looked at her daughter with unmistakable pride. Alaric noticed. His expression became guarded again.
Elowen rose. "I came because I thought you wanted to hear me. If you want to try again, I will. But not with contracts."
He remained seated. "You're walking away from security."
She picked up her coat. "I'm walking toward a kind of security you never offered."
Outside, the wind off the water was cold despite the sunlight. Celestine walked beside her without speaking until they reached the car. Then she asked whether Elowen wanted to go back to the bookshop or stop for something to eat. Elowen thought about the untouched menu and laughed softly.
May you like
"Something to eat," she said. "I shouldn't have to lose lunch every time I disagree with Dad."
They bought sandwiches from a stall by the harbor and ate them on a bench as gulls wheeled overhead. It was not a dramatic victory. Her father still held the tuition money, and he had not apologized. But Elowen had spoken at his table without asking permission to finish a sentence. That, she decided, was worth remembering.