Chapter 15

The Photograph in the Attic
Elowen went back to Commonwealth Avenue in late August for her childhood sketchbooks. She needed two drawings for her conservancy portfolio: a bridge she had studied when she was eleven and a careful elevation of the family townhouse. Celestine promised that Alaric would be at work, and for an hour the house appeared to belong entirely to its old smells and quiet passages.
Her room was unchanged. The college brochures remained in the drawer where she had placed them. Her graduation gown had been cleaned and hung in a garment bag. The pearl necklace sat in its box. For a moment Elowen felt the old wish to lie on the bed and pretend she had come home after an ordinary school day. Then she noticed that the stack of her photographs on the desk had been rearranged by somebody else's hands.
She took her portfolio and went toward the attic, where her mother kept old drawing materials. Celestine had said a box of archival paper might be useful. The attic smelled of dust, cedar, and summer heat. Through a round window, the city looked pale beneath a clouded sky.
The trunk itself carried stickers from places Celestine had traveled before her marriage. One showed the coast of Maine, another a summer arts program in New Hampshire. Elowen turned the brass latch and discovered a packet of entrance tickets to small galleries, postcards covered in drawings, and a scholarship certificate from a painting competition. She had grown up hearing that her mother enjoyed art as a hobby. These objects belonged to someone who had once worked at it with ambition and discipline.
A notebook beneath the certificates held charcoal sketches of hands. They were expressive, some clenched with tension, others open as though they were offering or releasing something. On one page Celestine had written, I am afraid I will forget what I meant to say. The handwriting looked unusually rushed. Elowen felt she was intruding on a private moment, yet the very act of keeping the words suggested her mother had once hoped they would be seen.
She set the notebook aside and breathed the warm dusty air. The attic was the opposite of the downstairs rooms. Nothing was arranged to impress a guest. Even the boxes were mismatched, and the floorboards creaked. It occurred to Elowen that the untidy spaces of a life might preserve more truth than the polished ones. She knelt beside the blue trunk and lifted its heavy lid, careful not to catch her sleeve on the tarnished brass.
She found the paper in a blue trunk near the window. Beneath it were sketchbooks in Celestine's handwriting. There were charcoal studies of trees, an unfinished portrait of a sleeping woman, and a painting of a small room with a single chair facing a window. The images were full of skill and an unease Elowen had never recognized in her mother's polished flower arrangements.
At the bottom lay a photograph wrapped in tissue. Celestine, about nineteen, stood beside a stone wall in a loose summer dress. Her hair was long and dark-blonde, her face younger but instantly recognizable. One hand rested on the unmistakable curve of a late pregnancy. On the back, in fading ink, someone had written: July. The summer before everything changed.
Elowen sank onto an old traveling case. She had not expected her mother's secret to take such an immediate, human shape. There was the girl Celestine had once been, looking into a camera with almost the same mixture of fear and defiance Elowen remembered from her own graduation. The resemblance made her dizzy.
Beneath the photograph was a soft knitted cap the color of primroses. Stitched into its edge, in uneven thread, was one word: June. A small envelope held a card with the printed words Baby Girl Fenwick and a date twenty-three years earlier. Elowen did the arithmetic twice. Her mother had been nineteen. The child would now be older than Elowen by six years.
She heard footsteps on the stairs and put the photograph down carefully. Celestine appeared at the attic door carrying a glass of water.
"I thought you might need..." She stopped. Her gaze settled on the photograph.
"I'm sorry," Elowen said. "I was looking for drawing paper. I didn't mean to find this."
Celestine crossed the attic and sat beside her on the old case. She did not reach to cover the photograph. For a long time she looked at the face of her younger self as though meeting a stranger she had wronged.
"I was nineteen," she said.
"I know."
"I thought I was in love. I was in love. People spoke as though that meant I could not think clearly about anything else."
Elowen swallowed. "Did you have a baby?"
Celestine closed her eyes. "Yes. A girl."
"What happened to her?"
The question seemed to exhaust the air in the room. Celestine touched the little yellow cap, then withdrew her fingers.
"I gave her away," she said. "Or perhaps I was taught to call it giving when I had so little choice."
Elowen felt tears gathering before she knew who they were for. Her mother looked at the photograph again.
"Her name was June for one afternoon," Celestine whispered. "I don't know what they called her after. At least, I didn't for a very long time."
May you like
Elowen remembered the cream envelope in the linen cupboard and the name that had stopped dinner. She placed the photograph between them, neither hiding it nor forcing her mother to continue.
From the garden below came the faint sound of the fountain. The house had been built to preserve family history in marble and wood. Here, hidden in a trunk, was the part of its history no one had permitted to be displayed.