scribe

Chapter 10

What Grandmother Iris Remembered

Iris Fenwick chose a restaurant where the tables stood so far apart that no one could overhear a conversation without making a deliberate effort. She had worn understated diamonds for half a century and carried herself with the serene certainty of someone who had rarely needed to repeat a request. Elowen had adored her as a child. Iris taught her to recognize trees by their leaves and to fold letters without creasing their edges. She also corrected Elowen's posture when nobody else noticed she was slouching.

They ordered tea. Iris looked at the loose linen dress Elowen had chosen and the cardigan resting over it, then placed her cup carefully on its saucer.

"Your mother tells me you're having a difficult season."

"That's one way to describe it."

"I know your father can be severe. But his plans have always been designed to give you a secure future."

Elowen looked through the window at a woman helping a child climb a step. "He struck me."

Iris's expression changed, just enough to show she had not been told. "He should not have done that."

"He says I must end my pregnancy or I am no longer his daughter."

"People say hard things when frightened."

"He has kept saying them."

Iris remembered Celestine at nineteen, standing in the doorway of the family drawing room with a college catalog folded under one arm. The girl's face had been white with fear, but she had spoken steadily: she wanted to finish school, and she wanted help finding a place to live with the baby. Iris had called it impossible before asking whom Celestine had already spoken to. Later, when the arrangements were made, Iris had told herself that her daughter looked calmer. She had ignored the fact that calmness sometimes arrived when a person learned that arguing changed nothing.

The memory had grown less comfortable with age. Iris's husband had died believing they had saved their daughter from disgrace. After his funeral, Iris had opened boxes of family letters and found that Celestine had written to a friend asking whether women could finish university while raising a child. The letter had never been sent. Iris kept it for years without understanding why it hurt her to look at it.

Across the table, Elowen waited for an answer that would cost Iris something to give. The older woman was suddenly aware that she had one more chance to be honest, not because her granddaughter owed her reconciliation, but because silence would be another decision.

The waiter arrived with a plate of small cakes. Iris waited until he left. "A child is a great responsibility. You have an extraordinary education ahead of you."

"I know both things are true."

"Sometimes protecting a future means choosing against the present."

Elowen heard the careful phrases of her grandfather in the words her mother had described. She put down her teacup. "Did you say that to Mother?"

Iris went still. The garden beyond the restaurant window moved in a bright afternoon breeze. At last she asked, "What has Celestine told you?"

"Nothing yet. But there was a letter from someone named Tamsin. And Father acted as though the name could bring down the house."

For the first time Elowen saw uncertainty on her grandmother's face. Iris touched her pearls, then folded her hands together.

"When your mother was young," she said, "we thought we were preventing her from being hurt. I suppose we thought having the right connections and resources meant we knew more than she did."

"What happened?"

"That is Celestine's story to tell."

"Did you ever ask what she wanted?"

Iris looked toward the window again. Her voice was almost inaudible. "We asked. We did not listen."

The statement stood between them. Elowen was angry at her grandmother for the mystery and angrier still at the familiar language of protection. She wanted an explanation, but she did not want to become another person forcing open her mother's past without permission.

"If you think what happened then was wrong," she asked, "why are you telling me to obey Father now?"

Iris closed her eyes briefly. "Because I have spent a very long time believing the decisions we made were necessary. If they weren't, then I have to live with what we did."

"You already live with it," Elowen said.

Iris opened her eyes. There was no graceful reply available. They drank their tea while it cooled, and the silence was neither a reconciliation nor a rejection. On the way out, Iris touched Elowen's arm.

"Your mother drew every day when she was a girl. Afterward, she stopped. I told myself she had matured."

"She still draws sometimes."

"Does she?"

"When she thinks no one is watching."

The older woman seemed to find this both a consolation and a fresh indictment. Outside, their cars waited in the shaded drive. Iris took a small card from her handbag.

"This is Nell Ash. She owns a bookshop near Beacon Hill. She was your mother's teacher and is one of the few people I know who never once told me what I wanted to hear. If you need an adult outside the family to talk to, she'll listen."

Elowen took the card. "Why haven't you talked to her?"

Iris managed a rueful smile. "Because she'll tell me what I ought to have done years ago."

May you like

That night, Iris telephoned Celestine herself. She did not ask after the charity reception or whether Elowen had reconsidered. She said only, "I was wrong about some things. If you'll allow me, I would like to start saying so while I'm still here."

Celestine listened on the other end of the line, one hand resting on the unsent letter beside her. For a moment she could not answer. Then she said, "You can start with the truth."

Related Stories

Other posts