scribe

Chapter 5 - A Lie With Four Voices

On Monday morning, Ms. Monroe printed the photograph.

She did not show it to Cece.

Not yet.

Instead she requested permission from Dr. Pierce to conduct individual student interviews regarding the damaged coat and the courtyard incident.

Dr. Pierce sighed behind his broad walnut desk.

“Rebecca, I respect your instincts. But we need to be careful.”

“With what?”

“With escalation.”

“A child came inside covered in mud with one shoe missing. Two days later her coat was marked ‘little liar.’ That is already escalation.”

He folded his hands. “Gregory Vale has raised serious concerns in the past about teachers making assumptions about Brianna.”

“Has Brianna been accused before?”

Pierce hesitated.

That was an answer.

“Of bullying?” Ms. Monroe pressed.

“There have been interpersonal conflicts.”

“Were they documented?”

“Some.”

“Were families informed?”

“Rebecca.”

She held his gaze.

Pierce exhaled. “You may speak to the students. Separately. Counselor present. No accusations. And do not contact parents until we have facts.”

“Agreed.”

By noon, Luke, Emma, Henry, and Brianna had each told their version.

They were nearly identical.

Cece walked toward the puddle alone.

Cece slipped.

Cece laughed afterward.

Cece said she was fine.

No one touched her.

No one saw her lose a shoe.

No one knew who wrote on the coat.

The problem was that identical stories often sounded less truthful when children told them separately.

Emma said the puddle was “beside the maple tree.”

Luke said “by the old maple.”

Henry said “the maple puddle.”

Brianna said, “The puddle by the maple, where she slipped.”

Ms. Monroe wrote every phrase down.

Then she placed the school photograph in front of Henry.

“What is that in your hand?”

His face changed.

“Nothing.”

“It appears to be a leather strap.”

“I found it.”

“Where?”

“Outside.”

“When?”

He swallowed. “Friday.”

“The photograph was taken Friday. The strap appears to match a piece missing from Cece’s shoe, which was damaged Tuesday.”

Henry looked at the counselor.

“I don’t know.”

“Did Brianna give it to you?”

“No.”

“Did you take it from the puddle?”

“No.”

“Then where is it now?”

Henry’s breathing changed.

“I threw it away.”

“Where?”

“I don’t remember.”

Ms. Monroe closed her notebook.

After school, Henry waited near the bus loop.

When Ms. Monroe passed, he spoke without looking at her.

“She said it was funny.”

Ms. Monroe stopped.

Henry’s eyes filled with tears. “I didn’t push Cece.”

“I know.”

“I didn’t write on the coat either.”

“I didn’t say you did.”

“She said if we all said the same thing, nobody could prove anything.”

Ms. Monroe kept her voice calm. “Who is she?”

Henry finally looked at her.

But before he could answer, a black SUV pulled up.

Brianna sat in the back seat.

Gregory Vale was driving.

Henry’s mouth closed.

He stepped away from Ms. Monroe.

The rear window of the SUV lowered.

Brianna smiled at him.

Not warmly.

“See you tomorrow, Henry.”

The window rose.

The SUV rolled away.

May you like

Henry stared after it.

Then he whispered, almost too softly to hear, “That’s who.”

Related Stories

Other posts