Chapter 2 - What Cece Wouldn’t Say

By the time fourth-period language arts began, Cece had cleaned her face but not her coat. She had folded it into a tight square beneath her desk, as though making it smaller could make the morning disappear.
Ms. Monroe taught from the front of the classroom, but her attention kept returning to Cece.
The girl was usually careful in everything: handwriting, posture, homework, even the way she aligned her pencil with the edge of her notebook. Today her page was blank.
“Cecilia?” Ms. Monroe said gently.
Cece looked up.
“Would you read the next paragraph?”
Her lips parted, but no sound came.
Brianna sat two rows behind her.
Cece could feel the stare before she saw it.
“I… I lost my place.”
A few students shifted. Luke smirked at his desk.
Ms. Monroe closed the book in her hands. “That’s all right. Emma, continue.”
As Emma began reading, Ms. Monroe walked slowly between the rows. She stopped beside Cece’s desk and saw that the child’s hands were hidden beneath it.
One fist was clenched so tightly that the knuckles had gone pale.
At lunch, Ms. Monroe asked Cece to remain behind.
The room emptied. Brianna paused at the door.
“Ms. Monroe?” she said brightly. “Do you need help carrying anything?”
“No, thank you, Brianna.”
Brianna looked at Cece and smiled before leaving.
The door clicked shut.
Cece’s shoulders dropped.
Ms. Monroe noticed.
She pulled a chair beside Cece’s desk rather than sitting behind her own. “I found your shoe.”
Cece looked at her sharply.
“It was in the mud near the maple trees.”
“Oh.”
“It was pressed down deep. Deeper than I would expect if it simply slipped off.”
Cece stared at the floor.
Ms. Monroe lowered her voice. “Did someone hurt you?”
“No.”
“Did someone push you?”
“No.”
“Did someone take your shoe?”
“No.”
Each answer came faster than the last.
Ms. Monroe did not challenge her. “All right.”
Cece blinked, almost confused.
“I’m not going to force you to tell me something before you’re ready,” Ms. Monroe continued. “But I want you to know this: you will not get in trouble for telling the truth.”
Cece’s throat moved.
“I know.”
“Do you?”
Cece gave the smallest nod.
Ms. Monroe placed the cleaned shoe on the desk. “Your mother called this morning. She said your family is attending the Hawthorne Foundation reception Friday night. You seemed worried when she mentioned it yesterday. Is this connected?”
Cece’s eyes widened.
“No.”
Too fast again.
Ms. Monroe studied her. “All right.”
Cece slipped on the shoe. It was still damp. She gathered her books.
At the door, she stopped.
“Ms. Monroe?”
“Yes?”
“If someone says something happened differently from how you remember it… how do you know which version is true?”
Ms. Monroe’s expression softened. “You look for what doesn’t change when the story changes. Details. Evidence. Patterns. And you listen carefully to the person who seems afraid to speak.”
Cece’s eyes filled.
Then footsteps sounded in the hallway.
Cece flinched and rushed out.
Ms. Monroe remained seated.
A minute later she walked to the doorway and looked down the corridor.
Brianna stood by the drinking fountain, pretending to fix her ponytail.
She had been waiting.
That afternoon, Ms. Monroe sent a quiet email to the assistant head of school requesting access to the courtyard supervision log and exterior camera coverage.
The reply arrived ten minutes later.
COURTYARD CAMERA 3 — OFFLINE SINCE 8:12 A.M. DUE TO WEATHER DAMAGE.
Ms. Monroe read the message twice.
Then she looked through the classroom window toward the wet courtyard.
May you like
Someone had chosen the one corner where the camera could not see.
And children rarely chose blind spots by accident.