scribe

Chapter 11 - Luke’s Second Story

Luke Cross returned to school on Wednesday with his father.

Unlike Henry, he did not look frightened. He looked angry.

Mr. Cross sat beside him in Dr. Morris’s office, one ankle resting on the opposite knee. “Luke tells me he has been dragged into something that isn’t his problem.”

Luke stared at the wall.

Ms. Monroe placed no photograph on the table, no leather strap, no transcript. Only a blank notepad.

“I want Luke’s own memory,” she said.

Mr. Cross nodded. “Then let him give it.”

Luke began with the original story.

Cece slipped.

Nobody touched her.

Everyone laughed because the fall looked funny.

They left.

Ms. Monroe listened without interrupting.

When Luke finished, she asked, “Did Brianna say, ‘Come here, princess’?”

His eyes flickered.

“I don’t remember.”

“Did Cece say, ‘Let go’?”

“I don’t remember.”

“Did Brianna say, ‘Still feeling special?’”

“I don’t remember.”

Mr. Cross shifted. “Where is this going?”

Ms. Monroe turned the laptop around.

She played Noah Kim’s video.

Luke’s face changed before his father’s did.

The splash sounded.

The laughter followed.

Then Brianna’s voice.

Luke looked down.

Mr. Cross uncrossed his legs.

“Son?”

Luke’s jaw worked.

“Were you there?”

“Yes.”

“Did that girl push Cecilia?”

Luke did not answer.

His father’s voice softened. “I’m asking you.”

Luke’s eyes filled with a shame that made him suddenly look eleven instead of older.

“Yes.”

Mr. Cross leaned back as if struck.

Luke spoke quickly then, as though a dam had cracked.

“I didn’t know she was going to. Brianna just wanted to scare her. That’s what she said. She said we were going to make Cece stop acting like she owned everything.”

“Did Cece act that way?” Ms. Monroe asked.

Luke shrugged miserably. “Not really.”

“Then why did you say it?”

“Because Brianna said it first.”

The answer was simple and terrible.

“What happened after Cece fell?”

“Brianna took a picture. Henry had the shoe strap. Emma said maybe we should go. Brianna told us nobody better say anything.”

“What did she say exactly?”

Luke swallowed. “She said if one person changed the story, everybody would know who the rat was.”

Mr. Cross shut his eyes.

Luke continued. “Then at lunch she made us practice.”

“Practice what?”

“The story. She said, ‘Cece walked by the maple puddle, Cece slipped, Cece laughed, we left.’ We said it until everybody said it the same way.”

That explained the repeated phrase.

Ms. Monroe asked, “Why did you stay home Monday?”

Luke looked at his father.

Mr. Cross answered. “He told me there was drama at school and asked to stay home. I let him.”

Luke whispered, “Brianna texted Sunday night.”

Ms. Monroe’s attention sharpened. “What did she say?”

Luke took out his phone.

His father had already preserved it.

The message thread contained no explicit confession. Brianna had been careful.

But three messages mattered.

Remember the maple.

Nobody touched anybody.

If Henry wants to ruin himself, let him.

Ms. Monroe read them twice.

“May the school save copies?”

Mr. Cross nodded immediately. “Yes.”

Luke stared at his hands. “Is Henry mad at me?”

Ms. Monroe said, “You’ll have to ask Henry.”

“Is Cece?”

“You’ll have to ask Cece too, if she chooses to talk to you.”

Luke looked sick.

For the first time, he seemed to understand that admitting the truth did not erase what he had done.

Outside the office, Cece was walking to the library when Luke came out.

They stopped six feet apart.

Luke opened his mouth.

Cece’s entire body stiffened.

He saw it.

Whatever apology he had prepared vanished.

He stepped aside.

Cece walked past.

That evening, Luke sent one message to Henry.

I told them.

Henry replied five minutes later.

Good.

May you like

Then another message appeared.

Now tell Cece when she’s ready to hear it.

Related Stories

Other posts